Harris v Empress Motors Ltd

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Gammell v Wilson
• Benham v Gambling
• Skelton v Collins

REFERS TO

• Harris v Brights Asphalt Contractors Ltd
• Rose v Ford
• Oliver v Ashman

[See more]

• McCann v Sheppard
• Mallett v McMonagle
• Benham v Gambling
• Chaplin v Hicks
• Flint v Lovell
• Young v Percival
• Pope v D. Murphy & Son Ltd
• Murray v Shuter

CONSIDERS

• Damages (Scotland) Act 1976
• Pickett v British Rail Engineering Ltd
• Fatal Accidents Act 1976

[See more]

• Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1934
• Fatal Accidents Act 1976 - Articles : S-1
• Damages (Scotland) Act 1976 - Articles : S-9
• Administration of Justice Act 1982 - Articles : S-4

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Harris v Empress Motors Ltd

APPLIES

• Gammell v Wilson

APPROVES

• White v London Transport Executive

REVERSES

• Harris v Empress Motors Ltd

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• (1983) 80 LSG 2362
• [1983] EWCA Civ J0714-3
• (1983) 80 LSG 2362

[See more]

• [1983] 3 All ER 561
• [1983] 127 SJ 647
• [1984] 1 WLR 212

CONSIDERED in

• Alan Stanley Horace Davis and Another (Respondents (Plaintiffs) v Nicholas Charles Howard Wormell (Appellant
• Eric Wilson (Administrator of the Estate of Brian Martin Wilson Deceased) v Michael David Stag and Another
• Michael Walker v Brigham & Cowan (Hull) Ltd and Ors

[See more]

• Jacqueline Sarah Owen (formerly Giddings) (Widow and Administratrix of the Estate of Darryl Gerrard Giddings, deceased) (Respondent (Plaintiff) Robert Henry Martin (Appellant (First Defendant) Sunblest Bakeries Ltd (Appellant (Second Defendant) Edward Robert Brooks (Third Party)
• Daphne Robina Stevenson (formerly Tegerdine) and Others v Christina Plowright (Married Woman)
• Raymond Thomas Shanks v Swan Hunter Group Plc
• Wray v Anderson et Al
• Dorothy Taylor (First Plaintiff) John Barrie Cordingley and Others (Respondents (Second Plaintiffs) George David Taylor (Appellant (Defendant)
• Thomas v Mitchell et Al
• Osborne (Applicant/Respondent) v Oetegenn
• Goulbourne v Clarendon Parish Council et Al
• Mr Loyola Lea Watson v Cakebread Robey Ltd
• Sharon Walker-Glasgow v Innotech Services (SVG) Ltd
• Matthew Franklyn Veinotte v Daniella C Williams Mitchell
• Matthew Franklyn Veinotte v Daniella C Williams Mitchell
• Yvonne Thomas (Administratrix of the Estate of Roy Thomas, Deceased) Claimant v James Mitchell Audlyn Mitchell Defendants [ECSC]
• Marilyn Plitman (Formerly Marilyn Yedid) Executrix and Administratrix of The Estate of Joshua Yedid Deceased) (Plaintiff) v National Health Service Litigation Authority
• Phipps (Plaintiff/Appellant) v Brooks Dry Cleaning Service Ltd
• Johnston et Al v Stewart et Al
• Collingford John (of Dickson Village) v The Attorney General
• Collingford John v The Attorney General
• Sharon Walker-Glasgow Attorney Administratrix for the Estate of Callis Alron Roy Walker aka Alron Walker v Innotech Services (SVG) Ltd
• Rackal v La Pierre and Trinidad and Tobago Housing Development Corporation
• Lisa Ann Mc Kenzie, Ornella Mc Kenzie and Daniella Mc Kenzie v Medcorp Ltd and Cancer Centre of The Caribbean Ltd
• Greene v Colebrooke
• Cardenas v Zimmer and the Presidential Insurance Company Ltd
• Eldon Wilson et Al v Lance Willie
• Tesheira v Gulf View Medical Centre Ltd and Roopchand
• Gorgichuk et Al v Barbados Transport Co-op Society Ltd et Al
• Jennifer Mazilan Vidale-Mark as (Administrator ad litem) for the estate of Andy Emanuel Mark v Rellon John, The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago
• Earleen Natasha Charles v Well Services Petroleum Company Ltd
• Modeste et Al v Jacobs et Al
• Sisnett v Gittens
• Singh v Persaud
• Baby Sharon Latchman-Tilkaran, Isabel Sophia Tilkaran v Anand Singh and The New India Assurance Company (Trinidad and Tobago) Ltd
• The Administrator General for Jamaica v Airlift Handlers Ltd
• R (O'Brien and Others) v Independent Assesor
• Novella Phillip v Akeem Benjamin
• Dyer v Stone
• Mohammed et Al v the Mayor Aldermen and Burgesses of Arima and Attorney General
• Boodram v Persad, Mangaroo and Motor One Insurance Company Ltd
• Administrator General for Jamaica (Administrator – Estate of David Benloss, deceased) v People's Favourite Baking Company Ltd
• Pilgrim v Transport Board et Al
• Bideshi et Al v Attorney General; Bideshi et Al v Attorney Genrral and Worrell
• Anthony Peter Crofts (by his Wife and Litigation Friend MARIA CROFTS) v Alan Murton
• Auguste v Maynard et Al
• Compton (Nee Blaize) v Nathaniel et Al
• Ramroop v Ramnarine
• Griffith et Al Chan et Al
• Frederick v Lam
• Richard Lolley and Another (Appellant (Plaintiff) v Peter Charles Keylock (Respondent
• Roxanne Frederick as Administratrix for the Estate of Steve Fraser Deceased) Claimant v Richard Lam Defendant [ECSC]
• Smith et Al v Phillip and Jackson (T/A Tropical Express Rentals)
• James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd v Roberts and Another
• Margaret Anne Coward v Comex Houlder Diving Ltd
• Michael Head v The Culver Heating Company Ltd
• Brad Pitt (Son and Personal Representative of the Estate of Keriel Wiltshire Deceased) v Mario Wilson
• Brad Pitt (Son and Personal Representative of the Estate of Keriel Wiltshire Deceased) v Mario Wilson
• Sidhu v Hiebert,
• Jamaica Public Service Company Ltd v Morgan et Al
• Wendy Price (Widow and Administratrix of the estate of David Wayne Price Deceased) v Marston's Plc

CITED in

• Nankissoor Singh v Persaud
• Bibi Shamina and Another v Sampat Dyal and Others
• Jamaica Public Service Company Ltd v Morgan and Another

[See more]

• Fong Moi Yin (suing as the Administrator of the Estate of Tan Ah Ngun) v Rapian Bin Suhaili (also known as Mohd Sofian Suhaili) and Another
• Sue Ellen O'Reilly v Western Sussex Hospital NHS Trust
• Michelle Lee v Carlton Crest Hotel (Sydney) Pty Ltd
• Administrator General for Jamaica v Jamaica Pre-Mix Ltd and Another
• Rix (widow and executrix of the estate of Rix (Deceased)) v Paramount Shopfitting Company Ltd
• Wendy Price (Widow and Administratrix of the estate of David Wayne Price Deceased) v Marston's Plc

FOLLOWED in

• Lee Kui Jak and Others; Societe National Industrielle Aerospatiale
• Awang bin Muda and Another; Noor Famiza bte Zabri and Another
• Chang Chong Foo and Another v Shivanathan

[See more]

• Noorianti bte Zainol Abidin and Others v Tang Lei Nge
• Ho Yeow Kim v Lai Hai Kuen and Another
• Chan Heng Wah v Peh Thiam Choh
• Chan Heng Wah and Another v Peh Thiam Choh and Another

REFERRED in

• Rajeswary a/p Nageswaran v Lim Kim Huang
• Vasan a/l Devarassoo v Mohdnur Azuan bin Alwi Noorbi
• Leong Sit Mooi (mendakwa sebagai ibu menurut hukum dan orang tanggungan kepada Ong Han Keat, si mati) v Ahmad Tajudin bin Ali

[See more]

• Calito C Guinto and Another; Lita Maddox
• Muralitharan Naraisamy v Ahmad Nowawi Saad
• Irma Smith (Widow and Co-Administrator of the Estate of Ophiel Nathaniel Smith Aka Nathaniel Smith) Marinus Smith (Co-Administrator of the Estate of Ophiel Nathaniel Smith Aka Nathaniel Smith) Claimants v Omari Phillip Vaughn Jackson t/a Tropical Express Rentals Defendants [ECSC]
• Bertha Compton (nee Blaize) (Qua Administratrix of the Estate of the Late Macrina Blaize) v Dr. Christiana Nathaniel and Others
• Gul Chandiram Mahtani and another(administrators of the estate of Harbajan Kaur decreased) v Chain Singh and Another
• Hongkong Bank Trustee (Singapore) Ltd v Rajinder Singh
• See Soon Soon v Goh Yong Kwang and Another
• Thompson v Arnold
• Dr Kumudu Kumari Rupasinghe (Suing on her own Behalf and as Administratrix of the Estate of Rohan Rupasinghe Deceased) v West Hertfordshire Hospitals NHS Trust
• Ana Belen Cacheda Chouza (Personal Representative of Mr Albino Otero Rodriguez, Deceased) v Artur Mendonca Lopes Martins
• Balanalagirisamy Gowri Rajeswari and another (administrators of the estate of Radhakrishnan Hari Babu, deceased) v Wong Si Wah
• Cox v Hockenhull

APPLIED in

• Woods v Francis
• Carter v Dawson
• Deborah Head (Executrix of the Estate of Michael Head, deceased) v The Culver Heating Company Ltd

NOT FOLLOWED in

• Woods v Francis

This document cites

---

• Mallett v McMonagle
• McCann v Sheppard
• Benham v Gambling
• Young v Percival
• Gammell v Wilson



See all quotations

• Pickett v British Rail Engineering Ltd
• Oliver v Ashman
• Gammell v Wilson
• Rose v Ford
• Murray v Shuter
• Chaplin v Hicks
• Benham v Gambling
• Flint v Lovell
• Pope v D. Murphy & Son Ltd
• Grffiths v Kerkmayer
• Skelton v Collins
• Harris v Empress Motors Ltd
• White v London Transport Executive
• Harris v Brights Asphalt Contractors Ltd
• Fatal Accidents Act 1976
• Damages (Scotland) Act 1976
• Administration of Justice Act 1982
• Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1934