Mallett v McMonagle

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Davies v Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries (No. 2)
• Le Abbe del Monastery de Everwike per Indenture recite que R C. tenoit un
• Sir Rafe Longforth seisi de Advouson de Marlborough present un que fuit admit

APPLIES

• Nance v British Columbia Electric Rly. Company Ltd
• Davies v Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries (No. 2)

CONSIDERS

• Fatal Accidents Act 1846 - Articles : S-II

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1969] UKHL J0211-2
• [1969] 1 Lloyd's Rep 127
• [1969] 2 All ER 178

[See more]

• 6 KIR 322
• [1969] NI 91
• [1970] AC 166
• [1969] 2 WLR 767

CITED in

• Peaudouce SA v Kimberly-Clark Ltd
• Brown v Lewisham and North Southwark Health Authority
• O&R Jewellers Ltd v Terry

[See more]

• Romeo v Conservation Commission of the Northern Territory
• Bright v Barnsley District Hospital
• Page v Sheerness Steel Company
• Novartis AG v Hospira Pty Ltd
• Mander v Commercial Union Assurance Company Plc
• La Trobe Capital and Mortgage Corporation Ltd v Hay Property Consultants Pty Ltd
• Sue Ellen O'Reilly v Western Sussex Hospital NHS Trust
• Nasir Hussain v Bradford Teaching Hospital NHS Foundation Trust and Another
• Kevin Lillington v Ministry of Defence
• Palliser Ltd v Fate Ltd ((in Liquidation))
• Grieves v Everard and Sons and Another and associated claims
• Mark Simon Smithurst (Claimant/Appellant) v Sealant Construction Services Ltd
• Warren v Harvey; Thomson v Thomson; Argus Insurance v Somers Isles
• Dunbar v A. & B. Painters Ltd
• Chester v Afshar
• Tabet v Gett
• Gregg v Scott
• Warren v Harvey
• Wells v Wells
• Wellesley Partners Llp v Withers Llp
• Wells v Wells
• Wells v Wells

REFERRED in

• Ministry of Defence v Cannock
• Thomas v Brighton Health Authority
• Judge v Huntingdon Health Authority

[See more]

• Thomas v Brighton Health Authority
• Robertson v Lestrange
• Telfair Shipping Corporation v Athos Shipping Company S.A. (Athos)
• Axe Australasia Pty Ltd v Australume Pty Ltd
• Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd
• Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum Nl
• Pennant Hils Restaurants Pty Ltd v Barrell Insurances Pty Ltd
• Todorovic v Waller
• Larkham v Lynch
• Udale v Bloomsbury Area Health Authority
• Scottish Ministers v Stirton
• Sarzali bin Mohd Jamil (menuntut dan mendakwa sebagai seorang bapa yang sah untuk Muhammad Faiz bin Sarzali, plaintif kedua) and Another v Hafiz bin Rohizan and Another
• Sapura Holdings Sdn Bhd v Northern Telecom (Asia) Ltd
• Anna Jong Yu Hiong v Government of Sarawak
• Seafield Holdings Ltd (trading as Seafield Logistics) v Drewett
• Tanjung Tiara Sdn Bhd v Southwind Development Sdn Bhd
• Ong Ah Long v Dr. S. Underwood
• A v National Blood Authority and Another (No. 1)
• Warren v Northern General Hospital N.H.S. Trust (No. 2)
• A Train & Sons Ltd v Maxine Emma Fletcher
• Tahir v Haringey Health Authority
• Hay v Hughes
• Britned Development Ltd v ABB
• Nalliah Karanakaran v Secretary of State for The Home Department
• Geofabrics Ltd v Fiberweb Geosynthetics Ltd
• Herring v Ministry of Defence
• Lim Chin San Contractors Pte Ltd v Shiok Kim Seng
• Lassiter Ann Masters (suing as the widow and dependant of Lassiter Henry Adolphus, deceased) v to Keng Lam (alias Toh Jeanette) (No 2)
• Bugsby Property LLC (a company incorporated under the laws of Delaware) v LGIM Commercial Lending Ltd
• Hotson (A.P.) v East Berkshire Health Authority
• Harris v Empress Motors Ltd
• Noreen Stapleton (Administratrix of the Estate of Cammie Stapleton, deceased) 1ST Plaintiff Ermine Stapleton (Administratrix of the Estate of Hugh Stapleton, deceased) 2nd Plaintiff v Ralph Walker 1st Defendant Rudolph Charles 2nd Defendant [ECSC]
• Bank of Baroda v Mrs Anne Maniar
• Taylor v O'Connor
• Popoviciu v Curtea De Apel Bucharest (Romania)
• S. v Distillers Company (Biochemicals) Ltd
• Laboratoires Servier v Apotex Inc.
• Wells v Wells
• Hodgson and Others v Trapp and Another
• Wells v Wells

CONSIDERED in

• Martijn Willem Otto Biesheuvel (Plaintiff) v Andrew Birrell
• Paul Collingwgod v Peter John Ryan
• Kevin Frederick Finnis v James Caulfield T/a and Another

[See more]

• First Interstate Bank of California (Plaintiffs/Respondent) v Cohen Arnold (A Firm)
• Jacqueline Sarah Owen (formerly Giddings) (Widow and Administratrix of the Estate of Darryl Gerrard Giddings, deceased) (Respondent (Plaintiff) Robert Henry Martin (Appellant (First Defendant) Sunblest Bakeries Ltd (Appellant (Second Defendant) Edward Robert Brooks (Third Party)
• Appleby v Northern Devon Healthcare NHS Trust
• John Dana Rosecrance by his litigation guardian John Charles Rosecrance v Marion Frances Rosecrance [NTR]
• Malec v Jc Hutton Pty Ltd
• LHS (by his Litigation Friends and Deputies, JBO and SJB) v First-Tier Tribunal (Criminal Injuries Compensation) Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (Interested Party)
• Dominic O'brien v Colin Buchanan Moyes and Another
• Crown Insurance Services Pty Ltd (ACN 005 214 237) v The National Mutual Life Association of Australasia Ltd (ACN 004 020 437)
• Doreen Whitworth (Widow) (suing as the Administratrix of the Estate of Gordon Alan Whitworth deceased) (Plaintiff) W. Dennis & Sons Ltd (First Defendants) Lincolnshire Tractors Ltd (Second Defendants)
• George Milatos v Clayton UTZ
• Kim Maree Shaw v The Commonwealth of Australia
• Qantas Airways Ltd v Lisica
• Kabic v AAI Ltd t/as GIO
• Hugo Timothy Cassel and Others (Appellant v Riverside Health Authority and Another (Appellant
• Helen MacDonald v Amy Mailander
• The Royal Dental Hospital of Melbourne v Birsel Akbulut
• Carl Henning Wright (as Executor of the will of Lindsay John Stafford, Deceased) v Commonwealth of Australia
• Caddajin Pty. Ltd and Others v Tasevski
• Linda Griffiths (Plaintiff) Respondent) v Charles Arthur Williams Appellant)
• State of Nsw (Nsw Police) v Nominal Defendant
• Insurance Australia Ltd t/a NRMA Insurance Ltd v Mustafa Al-Tabaibeh
• Rufo v Hosking
• Wharekawa v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd; Building Partners Pty Ltd v AEA Constructions Pty Ltd
• Biscayne Partners Pty Ltd v Valance Corporation Pty Ltd and Others
• P M Sulcs v Daihatsu Australia
• BestCare Foods v Origin Energy
• Gangi v Boral Resources (NSW) Pty Ltd (No 2)
• Halverson and Others v Dobler Halverson by his tutor v Dobler
• Pietrobelli v Jewell Family Nominees Pty Ltd
• Adam Lee Grills v Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd ABN 98 000 893 667
• Insurance Australia Ltd Ltd trading as Nrma Insurance v Hutton-Potts and Ors
• Henderson v Campbell
• Mevlit Mustafa Tahir v Haringey Health Authority and Another
• Minscombe Properties Ltd v Sir Alfred McAlpine and Son Ltd
• AstraZeneca AB and Another (Appellants/Claimants) v KRKA dd Novo Mesto and Another (Respondents/Defendants)
• Astrazeneca AB and Another v KRKA, d.d. Novo Mesto and Another
• O'Donoghue v Redcar & Cleveland Borough Council
• Margaret Longden v Kenalda Nominees Pty. Ltd
• Freeman v Lockett
• Transport for London v Spirerose Ltd ((in Administration))
• State of NSW v Moss
• Rebel Melanie Elizabeth Wilson(Plaintiff) v Bauer Media Pty Ltd and Another
• Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA ((in Liquidation)) v Ali (No. 3)
• Young v Percival
• Stillwell v Richmond Cabs Ltd,
• Steenhuisen v Francis,
• Lundgren v Taylor,
• Boettcher v Bengert,
• Tszyu v Fightvision Pty Ltd and Another; Fightvision Pty Ltd v Onisforou and Others
• A-G v Gilbert
• CLEAR v WAIKATO DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD NZEmpC AK
• McLean v Marshall
• Wagner v Cooper,
• Rust-andrews v First Tier Tribunal (Social Entitlement Chamber) and Another The Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (Interested Party)
• Brown v Ministry of Defence
• Lakatoi Universal Pty Ltd v L.A. Walker; Ensile Pty Ltd v Walker Consolidated Investments
• Various v Flintshire County Council (The Former Clwyd County Council)
• KY v Bahler,
• Anthony McGill v The Sports and Entertainment Media Group and Others
• Donnellan v Woodland
• LMI v Baulderstone (No 2)
• Vald. Nielsen Holding A/S v Mr Victor Baldorino
• Paymaster (Jamaica) Ltd v Grace Kennedy Remittance Services Ltd
• Frederick v Lam
• Samaroo et Al v Jagdeo
• Coller v Hollis 1983 Civil Jur. No. 200
• Stapleton et Al v Walker et Al
• Hall v Bleasdell
• Ramnath v Wallace
• Daniel v The Attorney General and Planning and Development Authority
• Maximae v Chief of Police, Police Service Commission, Attorney General
• Southern Contracting Company Ltd v Esther Diaram and Others
• Auty v National Coal Board
• DN v Greenwich London BC
• Marlborough District Council v Altimarloch Joint Venture Ltd
• John v Securiserve Ltd and Sagicor General Insurance Inc.
• Mitchell (Plaintiff) v Mulholland and Anr
• Hotson v East Berkshire Area Health Authority
• Pritchard v Cobden Ltd and Another (No. 1)
• Jiselle Paul v RBC Royal Bank (Trinidad and Tobago) Ltd
• Errol Phill v Rajesh Ramsamooj
• Gregg v Scott
• Favianna Gajadhar v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago
• Lisa Ann Mc Kenzie, Ornella Mc Kenzie and Daniella Mc Kenzie v Medcorp Ltd and Cancer Centre of The Caribbean Ltd
• Tesheira v Gulf View Medical Centre Ltd and Roopchand
• Shah v Raymond and Motor and General Insurance Ltd
• Maraj et Al v Samlal; Maraj et Al v Bando
• Cookson v Knowles
• Simpson v Diamond and Another
• Roxanne Frederick as Administratrix for the Estate of Steve Fraser Deceased) Claimant v Richard Lam Defendant [ECSC]
• Anyelina Mejia Villa v Elmo Conner Jr
• The Minister for Communications and Others v Figary Watersports Development Company Ltd
• Brooke Homes (Bicester) Ltd v Portfolio Property Partners Ltd
• Mr Allan Hodgson v Creation Consumer Finance Ltd
• Assetco Plc v Grant Thornton UK LLP
• Kenxue Pty Ltd ATF The Susan Investment Trust v Westpro Finance Pty Ltd
• Mobile Innovations Ltd v Vodafone Pacific Ltd and Others
• Graham v Dodds
• Garfield Segree v Jamaica Wells and Services Ltd and Another
• Lasco Distributors Ltd v Pfizer Ltd
• Pfizer Ltd v Medimpex Jamaica Ltd, NMF Pharmaceuticals Ltd (T/A Mac's Pharmaceuticals) and Lasco Distributors Ltd
• Paymaster (Jamaica) Ltd v Paul Lowe
• Proboodai Rampersad v The Director of Forestry
• Tota-Maharaj v Autocentre Limitedx
• Gett v Tabet
• Jennifer Mazilan Vidale-Mark as (Administrator ad litem) for the estate of Andy Emanuel Mark v Rellon John, The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago
• Britned Development Ltd v ABB AB
• Levi Maximae Claimant v [1] The Chief of Police [2] The Police Service Commission [3] The Attorney General of Dominica Defendants
• Re H (A Minor); Re K (Minors) (Child Abuse: Evidence)
• Dylan Simon v Manuel Paul Helmot (by his next friends and guardians Rosemary Helmot and Kenneth Raymond Jordan)
• Dyer v Stone
• Biscayne Partners Pty Ltd v Valance Corporation Pty Ltd and Others

APPLIED in

• Byrnes v Jokona Pty Ltd
• Mrs Lorna Catherine Hayden v Maidstone & Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust

FOLLOWED in

• Cheah Oon Leng, Winnie v Arab-Malaysian Securities Sdn Bhd
• Tan Sri Khoo Teck Puat v Plenitude Holdings Sdn Bhd, SC
• Soon Pook Seng Arthur v Oceaneering International Sdn Bhd

[See more]

• Visvalingam a/l Arumugam v Toh Gim Choon (S Vickneswaran, Third Party)
• Giovanni Vinetti; Tiong Ing Chiong
• Lee Wee Hiong and Another (administrators of the estate of Lee Liak Meng (Deceased)) and Others v Koh Ah Sai Victor and Others

NOT FOLLOWED in

• Allen v Ebanks

COMMENTED in

• Administrator General for Jamaica v Jamaica Pre-Mix Ltd and Another

This document cites

---

• Davies v Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries (No. 2)
• Nance v British Columbia Electric Rly. Company Ltd
• Sir Rafe Longforth seisi de Advouson de Marlborough present un que fuit admit
• Le Abbe del Monastery de Everwike per Indenture recite que R C. tenoit un
• Davies v Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries (No. 2)