David Shields Montgomery (Appellant) HM Advocate and Another (Respondents) Andrew Alexander Marshall Coulter (Appellant) HM Advocate and Another (Respondents)

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Brown v Stott (Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline)
• H. M. Advocate v Hepper
• HM ADVOCATE Petitioner against SCOTTISH MEDIA NEWSPAPERS Ltd JOHN SCOTT IAIN DUFFs

[See more]

• Pullar v HM Advocate
• McLean and Another v Buchanan and Another
• British Broadcasting Corporation, Petitioners (No. 2)
• HM Advocate v Little
• Advocate v Montgomery
• Boodram v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago
• Stewart v H. M. Advocate
• McKENNA v HM ADVOCATE
• Advocate v Renwick
• Paterson v H. M. Advocate
• Girvan v Inverness Farmers Dairy (No 2)

CONSIDERS

• Scotland Act 1998
• Scotland Act 1998 - Articles : S-57
• Act of Adjournal (Criminal Procedure Rules) 1996

[See more]

• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-305
• Human Rights Act 1998 - Articles : S-22
• Criminal Appeal Act 1968 - Articles : S-7
• Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 1980 - Articles : S-12
• Contempt of Court Act 1981 - Articles : S-4
• Criminal Justice Act 1988 - Articles : S-43
• Road Traffic Act 1988 - Articles : S-172
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-124
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-304
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-34
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-65
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-72
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-73
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-74
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-78
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-79
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 - Articles : S-91
• Government of Wales Act 1998
• Human Rights Act 1998 - Articles : S-6
• Human Rights Act 1998 - Articles : S-7
• Human Rights Act 1998 - Articles : S-9
• Scotland Act 1998 - Articles : S-126
• Scotland Act 1998 - Articles : S-44
• Northern Ireland Act 1998
• Act of Adjournal (Devolution Issues Rules) 1999
• Scotland Act 1998 - Articles : SCH-6
• Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995
• Government of Wales Act 1998 - Articles : SCH-8
• Northern Ireland Act 1998 - Articles : SCH-10
• Scotland Act 1998 - Articles : SCH-5
• Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 1980 - Articles : SCH-4
• Human Rights Act 1998 - Articles : SCH-1
• Human Rights Act 1998
• Human Rights Act 1998 - Articles : S-3
• Stuurman v H. M. Advocate
• Minister of Home Affairs v Fisher
• Z v DPP
• Attorney General v MGN Ltd
• Spink v Advocate (HM)
• W & J Burness, Ws v Smith

RESUELVE RECURSO

• DAVID SHIELDS MONTGOMERY ANDREW ALEXANDER MARSHALL COULTER Appellants and Minuters against HM ADVOCATE THE ADVOCATE GENERAL for SCOTLANDs

REFERS TO

• McFadyen v Annan
• HM Advocate v Robb
• Paton v Ritchie

[See more]

• Normand v Rooney
• Paterson v Advocate (HM)
• X v Sweeney
• HM Advocate v Dickson (Annie Mulvey)
• Lawrie v Muir
• Starrs v Ruxton

CITES

• John Spink Appellant Against HM Advocate
• Brown v Stott (Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline)
• Law Hospital NHS Trust v Lord Advocate and Another

[See more]

• R v DPP ex parte Kebeline
• Chahal v United Kingdom (App No 22414/93)
• Boodram (also called Dole Chadee) and Others v State
• R v Manchester. ; Stipendiary Magistrate and Another, ex parte Granada Television Ltd
• Z v DPP
• DAVID SHIELDS MONTGOMERY ANDREW ALEXANDER MARSHALL COULTER Appellants and Minuters against HM ADVOCATE THE ADVOCATE GENERAL for SCOTLANDs

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• DRA Nos 1 and 2 of 2000
• DRA Nos 1 and 2 of 2000
• [2001] 2 LRC 569

[See more]

• 2000 Scot (D) 4/12
• 9 BHRC 641
• [06/12/2000] TLR 1
• 2001 SLT 37
• [2001] 2 WLR 779
• [2003] 1 AC 641
• 2001 SC PC 1

CONSIDERED in

• R v Dobson
• R v Richard Bates
• R v Thakrar and Another

[See more]

• The Queen v Boriss Vjestica
• Ramda v Secretary of State for the Home Department
• R v Williams and nine other defendants
• News Digital Media Pty Ltd (ACN 000 529 457) v DPP
• O'Connor v Bar Standards Board
• John William Maitland(Applicant) v R
• R v Ronald Edward Medich (No. 28)
• R v Farhad Qaumi
• The Queen (on the application of Robert Palmer) v Northern Derbyshire Magistrates' Court
• R v A-G and DPP, ex parte Rushbridger
• Attorney General v Random House Group Ltd
• Jacques Benichou v Mauritius Commercial Bank
• McInnes v HM Advocate
• HM Attorney General v Stephen Yaxley-Lennon
• McLean and Another v Buchanan and Another
• R v Paul James MACKIN Mark Alan LILLEY Philip Anthony Sullivan
• Ramda, R v Secretary of State for the Home Department
• M v AG
• Dyer v Watson and Another; HM Advocate v K
• "R" v HM Advocate and Another
• R (Roberts) v Parole Board
• Attorney General's Reference (No. 2 of 2001); R v J
• DPP v McCarthy and Others
• The Queen v Jeffrey Alexander Barnes
• HM the Queen Respondent v Jeffrey Barnes Appellant
• Panday v Virgil
• Christopher Thomas v R
• Joshua Boden v The Governor of Bermuda
• The State v Gomes
• Cannonier v The Director of Public Prosecutions; Isaac et Al v The Director of Public Prosecutions
• Attorney General v Sexius
• R v H and Another
• Clark v Kelly
• HM Attorney-General v MGN Ltd and Another
• A v Secretary of State for the Home Department (No. 2)
• Attorney-General's Reference (No 3 of 1999), Re British Broadcasting Corporation
• R v Jones
• The State v Abu Bakr
• DPP v Anthony McCarthy and Others
• Bradley Milton Millingen v Lisa Stoddart Millingen
• Angela Barkhouse v Samuel Bankman-Fried
• R v Abu Hamza

DISTINGUISHED in

• HM Advocate v K
• R v Abdulla Ahmed Ali and Others

CITED in

• Kevin Ruddy and Others v Procurator Fiscal, Perth and Another
• R (Bonhoeffer) v the GMC
• DS v HM Advocate

[See more]

• R v Benjafield; R v Leal; R v Rezvi; R v Milford
• DS v HM Advocate
• Shaun Stewart McNeil v R
• The Queen (on the application of Johannes Philip Bonhoeffer) v General Medical Council
• Tibbetts v R
• R v Liam Dominic Adams
• Tahir Aziz v The Queen
• Nat Gordon Fraser V. Her Majesty's Advocate
• References Between John Barclay+william James Bain+her Majesty's Advocate+douglas Mclean+her Majesty's Advocate
• Duncan William Beggs Or Dreghorn Against Heer Majesty's Advocate
• Reclaiming Motion By Gordon Ross Against Lord Advocate
• Her Majesty's Advocate Against Angus Robertson Sinclair
• Petr Kupka+michal Rondos V. Her Majesty's Advocate
• R v Hansen
• R v Hansen
• Bonnett Taylor v The Queen
• R v Mirza; R v Connor and Rollock
• Tariq v Home Office
• Cannonier v DPP; Isaac and Others v DPP
• Attorney General v Sexius
• Attorney General of Saint Lucia Appellant v Kaim Sexius Respondent [ECSC]
• A v Secretary of State for the Home Department (No. 2)

REFERRED in

• R Allatt (Claimant) Chief Constable of Nottinghamshire Police (Defendants) Independent Police Complaints Commission (Interested Party)
• R v Johnson and Others
• McGowan (Procurator Fiscal)

[See more]

• R v Kansal (Yash Pal) (Change of Law) (No 2)
• Boyle v SCA Packaging Ltd
• Cannonier v DPP Isaac and Others v DPP
• Romeo Cannonier Appellant v DPP Respondent [ECSC]
• William Johnston (junior)+charles Woolard V. Her Majesty's Advocate
• Lowry v DPP
• The Queen Respondent v Andre Penn Applicant
• HM Attorney General v Stephen Yaxley-Lennon
• Romeo Cannonier Appellant v DPP Respondent [ECSC]

APPLIED in

• R v Hanna
• Follen v HM Advocate
• R (Mahfouz) v General Medical Council

FOLLOWED in

• Re B (2006)

COMMENTED in

• R v Spear; R v Hastie; R v Boyd; R v Williams and nine other defendants (Conjoined appeals)

ADOPTED in

• RB (Algeria) v Secretary of State for the Home Department

This document cites

---

• R. v. Corbett, (1988) 85 N.R. 81 (SCC)
• R v DPP ex parte Kebeline
• Girvan v Inverness Farmers Dairy (No 2)
• Z v DPP
• R v Manchester. ; Stipendiary Magistrate and Another, ex parte Granada Television Ltd



See all quotations

• Z v DPP
• Advocate v Montgomery
• W & J Burness, Ws v Smith
• McKENNA v HM ADVOCATE
• Lawrie v Muir
• H. M. Advocate v Hepper
• Stewart v H. M. Advocate
• Stuurman v H. M. Advocate
• Spink v Advocate (HM)
• McLean and Another v Buchanan and Another
• McFadyen v Annan
• HM Advocate v Robb
• John Spink Appellant Against HM Advocate
• Law Hospital NHS Trust v Lord Advocate and Another
• Pullar v HM Advocate
• X v Sweeney
• Normand v Rooney
• Paterson v Advocate (HM)
• Mackintosh v Lord Advocate
• Starrs v Ruxton
• Attorney General v MGN Ltd
• DAVID SHIELDS MONTGOMERY ANDREW ALEXANDER MARSHALL COULTER Appellants and Minuters against HM ADVOCATE THE ADVOCATE GENERAL for SCOTLANDs
• Minister of Home Affairs v Fisher
• HM ADVOCATE Petitioner against SCOTTISH MEDIA NEWSPAPERS Ltd JOHN SCOTT IAIN DUFFs
• HM Advocate v Little
• Advocate v Renwick
• Boodram (also called Dole Chadee) and Others v State
• Brown v Stott (Procurator Fiscal, Dunfermline)
• Paterson v H. M. Advocate
• Paton v Ritchie