Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Caswell v Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries Ltd
• Alphacell Ltd v Woodward

REFERS TO

• Thompson v Smiths Shiprepairers (North Shields) Ltd
• Clark v MacLennan
• Vyner v Waldenberg Bros

[See more]

• Nicholson v Atlas Steel Foundry and Engineering Company Ltd

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority

APPLIES

• Bonnington Castings Ltd v Wardlaw

CITES

• Rendal (A/S) v Arcos Ltd
• Wakelin v London and South-Western Railway Company
• McDermid v Nash Dredging & Reclamation Company Ltd

[See more]

• Brown v Rolls Royce Ltd
• Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee
• Barnett v Chelsea and Kensington Hospital Management Committee
• Rahman v Kirklees Area Health Authority (Practice Note)
• F v West Berkshire Health Authority and another (Mental Health Act Commission intervening)
• Gardiner v Motherwell Machinery and Scrap Company Ltd
• Caswell v Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries Ltd
• Whitehouse v Jordan
• Alphacell Ltd v Woodward
• Whitehouse (A.P.) (Suing by his Mother and Next Friend Eileen Whitehouse) v Jordan and Others

REVERSES

• Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority

DISTINGUISHES

• McGhee v National Coal Board

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1988] UKHL J0310-1
• 3 BMLR 37
• [1988] 1 All ER 871

[See more]

• (1988) 87 NR 140
• [1988] 2 WLR 557
• [1988] AC 1074

REFERRED in

• Ivan Letnik and Captain Normac's Riverboat Inn Ltd v Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto and Others (The Trillium)
• Loveday v Renton
• Mrs Jolene Sims (as Widow and Administratrix of the Estate of Paul Sims, Deceased) v Dr Neil MacLennan

[See more]

• Fish & Company Restaurants Pte Ltd (formerly known as OB Singapore Operations Pte Ltd) v Revenue Valley Sdn Bhd
• Kiara Emas Asia Industries Berhad v Tetuan Wong-Chooi & Mohd Nor
• Professor Dr Hj Mohammed Feizal Abdullah @ Balakrishnan a/l Krishnan v Harvender Jeet Kaur Kaka Singh
• Azizah Abdul Manan v Dr Norlelawati Ab Latip
• Abdul Ghafur bin Mohd Ibrahim v Pengarah, Hospital Kepala Batas
• Dr KS Sivananthan v The Government of Malaysia and Another
• Dr Gun Suk Chyn v Kartar Kaur a/p Jageer Singh (Sebagai wakil diri Harta Pusaka Govindasamy a/l Ponnusamy, si mati)
• Sa-Art Sae-Lee (juga dikenali sebagai Sa-Art Phuakthim) and Another v Dr Noor Aini binti Haji Sa'Ari
• Dr Chin Yoon Hiap v Ng Eu Khoon and Others and other appeals
• Chai Beng Hock v Sabah Medical Centre Sdn Bhd
• Alison Therese McArdle
• The Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs v Sunico A/S and Others
• Tracey Anne Negus v Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust
• Michael Holmes v Poeton Holdings Ltd

CONSIDERED in

• Coleen Burrell v Cornwall Regional Hospital (Board of Management Montego Bay Region) & Doctor Wright & Attorney General of Jamaica
• Genas (Howard) v Attorney General of Jamaica and Others
• Bryan (Devon) (Administrator of the estate of Ian Bryan, deceased v Attorney General

[See more]

• Linda Burrows v Forest Health Care NHS Trust
• BHP Billiton Petroleum Ltd and Others v Dalmine SpA
• The Administrator General v Alcoa Minerals Inc. Ja. et Al
• Clarence Roy Hill (Suing on his own behalf and on behalf of all other members of Syndicates 186 and 193 (Plaintiff/Appellant) v Citadel Insurance Company Ltd and Another
• Burac Oksuzoglu and Another v Stewart Kay and Another
• Nicholas John SPARKS v HSBC Plc
• Josephine Ocloo (as the Administratrix of the Estate of Krista Ocloo, Deceased) v Royal Brompton and Harefield Hospital Nhs Trust
• Evans v Queanbeyan City Council
• Janet M Robb (Widow of David Main Robb Deceased) (Respondent/Plaintiff) v Ft Everard & Sons Ltd
• Macey v Warwickshire HA
• Cooper v Reed and Another
• Griffiths and Others v British Coal Corporation and another
• 1. Frederick James Izzard and Another v 1. Field Palmer (A Firm)and Others
• St George v Home Office
• Royston Clifford Carss (Plaintiff/Appellant) v Oxfordshire County Council
• Temple v South Manchester Health Authority
• Yvonne Byatt (Plaintiff) v Ferguson Ltd
• Morris v Blackpool Victoria Hospital NHS Trust
• R (A Minor)
• Peter Alfred Jackson and Another v Ford Gunningham (A Firm)
• Barry Edward McDonald (t/as B.E. McDonald Transport) v Girkaid Pty Ltd & 4 Ors; Robert Bryce & Company Ltd v Girkaid Pty Ltd & 4 Ors; Hudson Resources Pty Ltd & 5 Ors v Robert Bryce & Company Ltd
• University of Western Sydney v Middlebrook
• Graham v Remo Constructions P/L and Another
• Henry Walker Eltin Contracting Pty Ltd v Hrstic
• Kingsgrove RSL v Spasevski
• Pollock, Cregton & Maureen Pollock v Bee Homes Ltd
• Rodney Brown and Rowena Brown t/as Town and Country Children's Centre v Benjamin Hewson by his tutor Sharon Hewson
• Jovanovski v Billbergia Pty Ltd
• Barry Thomas Blunden v Commonwealth of Australia
• Shire of Wakool v Jesse William Walters (by his Litigation Guardian Michelle Stead)
• Nominal Defendant v Clancy
• Bailey v Ministry of Defence and Another
• Rawle Hannibal v The BVI Health Services Authority
• Joycelyn Evanson Plaintiff/Appellant v Andrew E. Holm Ltd Defendant/Respondent [ECSC]
• Rufo v Hosking
• TC v State of New South Wales
• Drinkwater v Caddyrack Pty Ltd
• Tabet v Mansour and Another
• Denzin and Others v Nutrasweet and Others
• Sovereign v Bevillesta
• Williams v Fraser
• Hutton-ashkenny v Diggiss
• Grant et Al v Barnett and Others of the Public Hospitals Authority (on Behalf of the Princess Margaret Hospital)
• Finch v Rogers
• Neville Knowles, JNR v South East Regional Health Authority
• Allen v British Rail Engineering Ltd
• Alan Taylor (Plaintiff v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council (Defendants
• Pauline Elizabeth Hutchinson v Epson & St Helier Nhs Trust
• Dixon v Harris et Al
• Rupert Campbell v The Attorney General of Jamaica
• Lamorna Phillips v Barbados Public Workers' Co-Operative Credit Union
• Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA ((in Liquidation)) v Ali (No. 3)
• Erlene Melbourne v Jamaican Infrastructure Operator Ltd
• Tesheira v Gulf View Medical Centre Ltd and Roopchand
• Berkeley v Guardian Life Holdings Ltd and Guardian Life of the Caribbean Ltd
• Karen Rae Clemons v Minister of Education
• Lezama v Achong Low
• Joan Thompson v Jamaica Health Security Network Ltd
• Norma Scott v Tomijam Company Ltd (T/A Rick's Convenience Store)
• Kemar Maybury v The Bermuda Hospitals Board
• Redman v Samuel
• Garfield Segree v Jamaica Wells and Services Ltd and National Irrigation Commission Ltd
• A v Jonathan Jon Cumberbatch
• Charles v Trinidad & Tobago Electricity Commission
• Alverine Witter v Gore Development Ltd
• Rawle Hannibal Claimant v The Bvi Health Services Authority Defendant
• Gouldsmith v Mid Staffordshire General Hospitals NHS Trust
• Denzil Shawe-Lincoln v Dr. Arul Chezhayan Neelakandan
• Wiki v Atlantis Relocations (NSW) Pty Ltd
• Pauline Rose Bull (Suing as and formerly Pauline Rose Wakeham) (First Respondent (First Plaintiff) Stuart Paul Wakeham (an infant suing by Pauline Rose Bull His Mother and Next Friend) (Second Respondent (Second Plaintiff) v Devon Area Health Authority (Appellant
• Jeffrey Jones and Others v The Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change (First Defendant) Coal Products Ltd (Second Defendant)
• Paula Whyte v Attorney General and South East Regional Health Authority
• Boycie Fahie v The BVI Health Services Authority
• Mangal v Ponnappa et Al
• Robert Joseph v Issoufou Moutary
• CNZ (Suing by her Father and Litigation Friend MNZ) v Royal Bath Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
• AB & Others v Ministry of Defence (No 2)
• St George v Home Office
• Sienkiewicz v Greif (UK) Ltd
• Anne Marie Quinn (A Minor) suing by her mother and next friend, Kathleen Quinn v Mid Western Health Board and Donal O'Sullivan
• Sienkiewicz v Greif (UK) Ltd; Knowsley Metropolitan Borough Council v Willmore
• Williams v The Bermuda Hospitals Board (Bermuda)
• A v Jonathan Jon Cumberbatch
• Robinson Helicopter Company Incorporated v Graham James McDermott and Others
• Gett v Tabet
• Seltsam Pty Ltd v McGuiness; James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd v McGuiness
• Tc by his tutor Sabatino v The State of New South Wales and Others
• AB & Others v Ministry of Defence
• Hannibal v The Bvi Health Services Authority
• Carol Metanczuk v Jay Watson,
• Lagrito v Bettiol,
• Evanson v Andrew E. Holm Ltd
• Nigel Freeman (Plaintiff) Appellant) v Barratt East Midlands Ltd Respondents)
• Miss Victoria Richins v Birmingham Women's and Children's NHS Foundation Trust
• CDE v Surrey & Sussex Healthcare Trust
• Thompson v Accident Compensation Corporation
• Di-Giandomenico v Accident Compensation Corporation
• Naylor v Preston Area Health Authority
• Palmer v RTA and Others

CITED in

• Robertson v Nottingham Health Authority
• Abbas v Kenney
• Darley v Shale

[See more]

• Stockdale v Nicholls
• Reynolds v North Tyneside Health Authority
• X and Y v Pal and Others
• Knight v West Kent Health Authority
• Ramlal v Deonarine and Others
• E v Castro
• Carroll v Lynch
• Pickford v ICI Plc
• Boustead v North West Strategic Health Authority
• The Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease Litigation, Group A and C Plaintiffs
• Nash v Kingston and Richmond Health Authority
• Brown v Lewisham and North Southwark Health Authority
• Le Page Kingston & Richmond Health Authority
• Re R (A Minor) (No 2)
• Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority
• Mrs Julie Devonport v Gateshead Health Nhs Foundations Trust
• Vernon v Bosley (No. 1)
• BHP BILLITON PETROLEUM Ltd and Others v DALMINE SpA
• Vernon v Bosley (No. 1)
• Miss Melissa Rich (A Protected Party by her Mother and Litigation Friend Helen Rich) v Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals Nhs Trust
• Wardlaw v Farrar
• Joyce v Wandsworth Health Authority
• Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago Ltd v Ryan and another (Trinidad and Tobago)
• Oksuzoglu v Kay and Another
• Ludwig v Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust
• Best v Wellcome Foundation Ltd
• Jason James (Widower and Intended Personal Representative of the Estate of Chivarane James, Deceased) Claimant v The BVI Health Services Authority Defendant
• Chappel v Hart
• J W Bollom & Company Ltd v Byas Mosley & Company Ltd
• Durham v Thorpe Campbell Holdings Ltd and another
• Joshua Jaddoo v Sugar Industry Authority
• XYZ & Others v Schering Health Care Ltd
• Smith v Barking, Havering and Brentwood Health Authority
• Ellis v The Environment Agency
• Chester v Afshar
• Oakes v Neininger
• Ganz v Childs and Others
• Dr Sido John v Central Manchester and Manchester Children's University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
• Holtby v Brigham and Cowan (Hull) Ltd
• Kingsberry v Greater Manchester Strategic Health Authority
• Gregg v Scott
• Barker v Corus (UK) Ltd; Murray v British Shipbuilders (Hydrodynamics) Ltd; Patterson v Smiths Dock Ltd and Others
• Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority
• Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd and Others
• Swinney v Chief Constable of Northumbria Police Force
• June Greenhorn (ap) V. South Glasgow University Hospitals Nhs Trust
• Angela Mcmanus And Robert Mcmanus Against (first) City Link Development Company Limited; (second) Scott Wilson Scotland Limited; And (third) Lanarkshire Housing Association Limited
• Tabet v Gett
• Pickford v Imperial Chemical Industries Plc
• Barber v Somerset County Council
• Bailey v Ministry of Defence and Another
• Gregg v Scott
• Chester v Afshar

APPLIED in

• Knight v Home Office
• Cerys Clements (by her mother and litigation friend Julia Geis-Clements) v Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust
• Bryce v Swan Hunter Group Plc

[See more]

• Fitzgerald v Lane
• Mediterranean Freight Services Ltd v BP Oil International Ltd (The Fiona)

COMMENTED in

• Sheikh v Australian Postal Corporation

FOLLOWED in

• Payremalu Veerappan v Dr Amarjeet Kaur and Others
• Dr KS Sivananthan v The Government of Malaysia
• Ng Eu Khoon v Dr Gwen Smith

[See more]

• Hasan Datolah v Kerajaan Malaysia
• A-G of Singapore and Another; Chew Swee Hiang
• Muniyandi a/l Periyan v Eric Chew Wai Keat
• Mohd Yattim Baharom v Kerajaan Malaysia
• Sundram Ramasamy v Arujunan Arumugam and Another
• Chew Swee Hiang v Attorney General and Another
• Joseph Reece Mangal Claimant v (1) Dr. Bottengada Ponnappa (2) The Hospital Administrator pf Victoria Hospital (3) Attorney General of Saint Lucia Defendants [ECSC]

DISTINGUISHED in

• Lechemanavasagar a/l S.Karuppiah v Dr. Thomas Yau Pak Chenk
• International Credit & Inv Company (Overseas) Ltd v Adham
• Bryn Michael Chetwynd and Another v Barry John Tunmore and Another

This document cites

---

• Alphacell Ltd v Woodward
• McGhee v National Coal Board
• Nicholson v Atlas Steel Foundry and Engineering Company Ltd
• Whitehouse (A.P.) (Suing by his Mother and Next Friend Eileen Whitehouse) v Jordan and Others
• Rahman v Kirklees Area Health Authority (Practice Note)



See all quotations

• Gardiner v Motherwell Machinery and Scrap Company Ltd
• McDermid v Nash Dredging & Reclamation Company Ltd
• Bonnington Castings Ltd v Wardlaw
• Brown v Rolls Royce Ltd
• Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority
• Whitehouse v Jordan
• Rendal (A/S) v Arcos Ltd
• Alphacell Ltd v Woodward
• Vyner v Waldenberg Bros
• Barnett v Chelsea and Kensington Hospital Management Committee
• Wakelin v London and South-Western Railway Company
• F v West Berkshire Health Authority and another (Mental Health Act Commission intervening)
• Caswell v Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries Ltd
• Caswell v Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries Ltd
• Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee
• Thompson v Smiths Shiprepairers (North Shields) Ltd
• Clark v MacLennan