McGhee v National Coal Board

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Gardiner v Motherwell Machinery and Scrap Company Ltd
• R v Furser

REFERS TO

• Gardiner v Motherwell Machinery and Scrap Company Ltd
• Alphacell Ltd v Woodward
• Gibson (A.P.) v British Insulated Callender's Construction Company Ltd

RESUELVE RECURSO

• McGhee v National Coal Board

APPLIES

• Bonnington Castings Ltd v Wardlaw
• Nicholson v Atlas Steel Foundry and Engineering Company Ltd

REVERSES

• McGhee v National Coal Board

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1972] UKHL J1115-2
• [1972] 3 All ER 1008
• [1973] 1 WLR 1

[See more]

• 13 KIR 471
• 1973 SC HL 37
• 1973 SLT 14

REFERRED in

• McSherry v British Telecom
• Countess of Malmesbury v Secretary of State for Transport
• Ivan Letnik and Captain Normac's Riverboat Inn Ltd v Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto and Others (The Trillium)

[See more]

• Stockdale v Nicholls
• Schneider v Hoechst Schering Agrevo Pty Ltd
• Gallon and Others v Swan Hunter Shipbuilders Ltd
• Loveday v Renton
• The Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease Litigation (No.7), Group A and C Plaintiffs
• The Creutzfeldt-Jacob Disease Litigation, Straddlers Groups A and C v Secretary of State for Health
• Thomas Miller & Company and Another v Richard Saunders & Partners
• Stacey v Chiddy
• Phillips v Syndicate 992 (Gunner)
• Novartis Grimsby Ltd v John Cookson
• Fish & Company Restaurants Pte Ltd (formerly known as OB Singapore Operations Pte Ltd) v Revenue Valley Sdn Bhd
• Adventist Hospital & Clinic Services (M) v Kee Boon Suan
• Chai Beng Hock v Sabah Medical Centre Sdn Bhd
• Dominic Puthucheary v Dr Goon Siew Fong
• Sundram Ramasamy v Arujunan Arumugam and Another
• Pai Lily v Yeo Peng Hock Henry
• R v Poplar Coroner, ex parte Thomas
• Miss Melissa Rich (A Protected Party by her Mother and Litigation Friend Helen Rich) v Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals Nhs Trust
• Bull and another v Devon Area Health Authority
• International Energy Group Ltd v Zurich Insurance Plc Uk Branch
• March v Stramare (E and Mh) Pty Ltd
• Durham v Thorpe Campbell Holdings Ltd and another
• R (Touche) v Inner London North Coroner
• Tahir v Haringey Health Authority
• Bryn Michael Chetwynd and Another v Barry John Tunmore and Another
• Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd
• Aviva Insurance Ltd v The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
• Michael Holmes v Poeton Holdings Ltd
• Thyssen Canada Ltd and Mariana Maritime S. A and Another
• Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA ((in Liquidation)) v Ali (No. 3)
• Zurich Insurance Plc UK Branch v International Energy Group Ltd
• AB & Others v Ministry of Defence
• Holtby v Brigham and Cowan (Hull) Ltd
• Barber v Somerset County Council
• Mediterranean Freight Services Ltd v BP Oil International Ltd (The Fiona)
• Sunny Metal and Engineering Pte Ltd v Ng Khim Ming Eric
• Bailey v Ministry of Defence and Another
• Page v Smith
• Hotson (A.P.) v East Berkshire Health Authority
• Kirkham v Chief Constable of the Greater Manchester Police
• Craig Hartwell v Kelvin Laurent Attorney General

CONSIDERED in

• Pauline Henderson v The Wakefield Shirt Company Ltd
• Jeffrey King v Gareth King
• Thomas Huxley (Plaintiffs) v Elvicta Wood Engineering Ltd & James Neil (Services) Ltd

[See more]

• Sandra Mayne (executrix of the Estate of Keith Norman Deceased) v Atlas Stone Company Ltd and Others
• Seasalter Shellfish Ltd (Plaintiffs/Appellants) v Canterbury City Council
• Rice and Another v Secretary of State for Business, Enterprise & Regulatory Reform and Another
• BHP Billiton Petroleum Ltd and Others v Dalmine SpA
• Rachael Sarah Mcdonald (Plaintiff/Appellant) v Tees Health Authority
• Nicholas John SPARKS v HSBC Plc
• Jonathan James Lee (Plaintiff/Appellant) v Barry Clark
• PEARCE v LINDFIELD and Others
• Hotson v East Berkshire Area Health Authority
• Maurice Neville Saggers (Plaintiff) Respondent) v Lea Valley Regional Park Authority Appellants)
• Evans v Queanbeyan City Council
• West v Ministry of Defence (No.2)
• Janet M Robb (Widow of David Main Robb Deceased) (Respondent/Plaintiff) v Ft Everard & Sons Ltd
• Hull v Sanderson (Admin of Estate of Mr Sanderson - Deceased)
• Griffiths and Others v British Coal Corporation and another
• Poste House Hotels Ltd v Robin David Brown
• Royston Clifford Carss (Plaintiff/Appellant) v Oxfordshire County Council
• P&O Developments Ltd (Plaintiff) v The Guy's and St Thomas' National Health Service Trust (Defendant (by original action)
• State of New South Wales and Another v Thomas; State of New South Wales and Another v Welling
• Bitupave Ltd v McMahon and Others
• Van Wees v Karkour and Another
• Cockatoo Dockyard v Browne
• Kingsgrove RSL v Spasevski
• Andrea Lyndon v Royal Free Hampstead NHS Trust
• State of New South Wales v Buckland and Others; Katena Pty Ltd and Others Buckland and Others
• Roney, Leanne Patricia v Priestman, Reginald
• Mrs Jolene Sims (as Widow and Administratrix of the Estate of Paul Sims, Deceased) v Dr Neil MacLennan
• Perera v Prestige Property Services Pty Ltd
• Mcgroder v Maguire
• Rodney Brown and Rowena Brown t/as Town and Country Children's Centre v Benjamin Hewson by his tutor Sharon Hewson
• William Hill Organisation Ltd v Bernard Sunley & Sons Ltd
• Eb v John Haughton
• Barry Thomas Blunden v Commonwealth of Australia
• Peabody Housing Association Ltd (Plaintiff Respondent) v Reginald Green and Others
• State of New South Wales v Burton
• Shire of Wakool v Jesse William Walters (by his Litigation Guardian Michelle Stead)
• Workers” Compensation (Dust Diseases) Board v Kelly
• Kathryn Deal v Father Pius Kodakkathanath
• Lloyd v John Lewis Partnership
• Thaine v London School of Economics
• Gavalas v Singh
• Rufo v Hosking
• Elayoubi v Zipser
• Flounders v Millar
• TC v State of New South Wales
• Eliza Grace Maree Hirst (Bnf Amanda Hirst) v Dr David Browning
• Tabet v Mansour and Another
• Denzin and Others v Nutrasweet and Others
• Paul Jonathon Keith Wilkins v Council of the City of Broken Hill
• Mevlit Mustafa Tahir v Haringey Health Authority and Another
• Transco Plc v Griggs
• North Sydney Council v Binks
• Alexander Joseph Johnstone (Personal Representative of the Estate of Elaine Jean Johnstone, Deceased) v Fawcett's Garage (Newbury) Ltd
• Barker v Corus UK Ltd
• C v D [2006]
• Pauline Rose Bull (Suing as and formerly Pauline Rose Wakeham) (First Respondent (First Plaintiff) Stuart Paul Wakeham (an infant suing by Pauline Rose Bull His Mother and Next Friend) (Second Respondent (Second Plaintiff) v Devon Area Health Authority (Appellant
• Dalling v RJ Heale & Company Ltd
• Sienkiewicz v Greif (UK) Ltd
• Department of National Heritage (Plaintiffs) Steensen Varming Mulcahy (A Firm)(Defendants) Balfour Beatty Ltd (First Third Party) Laing Management Ltd (Second Third Party)
• Independent Broadcasting Authority v BICC Construction Ltd
• Derek Brown (Plaintiff/Appellant) v Lewisham and North Southwark Health Authority
• Robinson Helicopter Company Incorporated v Graham James McDermott and Others
• Seltsam Pty Ltd v McGuiness; James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd v McGuiness
• Tc by his tutor Sabatino v The State of New South Wales and Others
• Strong v Woolworths Ltd
• Roads and Traffic Authority v Royal
• Martyn Clarke v Hull City Council
• Nigel Freeman (Plaintiff) Appellant) v Barratt East Midlands Ltd Respondents)
• Russell v Russell,
• John Patrick Dowdall v William Kenyon & Sons Ltd and Others
• CI Knitwear v Hotchkiss
• Thompson v Smiths Shiprepairers (North Shields) Ltd
• Vero Insurance New Zealand Ltd v Anthony Brendon Morrison
• Mark Mather v Ministry of Defence
• Allen v British Rail Engineering Ltd
• Cape Distribution Ltd v Cape Intermediate Holdings Plc
• Clough v First Choice Holidays and Flights Ltd
• Sienkiewicz v Greif (UK) Ltd; Knowsley Metropolitan Borough Council v Willmore
• Various v Flintshire County Council (The Former Clwyd County Council)
• Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd and Others
• Henville v Walker
• Carl Heneghan (Son and Executor of James Leo Heneghan, Deceased) v Manchester Dry Docks Ltd and Others
• CNZ (Suing by her Father and Litigation Friend MNZ) v Royal Bath Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
• Northro9k Ltd v Jardine et Al
• Evanson v Andrew E. Holm Ltd
• Maharaj v Property Protectors Ltd et Al
• Northrock Ltd v Jardine et Al
• Ryan et Al v Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago Ltd
• Bryan (Devon) (Administrator of the estate of Ian Bryan, deceased v Attorney General
• Hutton-ashkenny v Diggiss
• Coe v Williams
• Carey Nee Mackey v Campbell D/b/a the Walk in Clinic et Al
• McPhee v Commonwealth Bank (Bahamas) Ltd
• Douglas v Warde et Al
• Robert Joseph v Issoufou Moutary
• Kelly v Lenihan
• Bailey v Ministry of Defence and Another
• Best v Wellcome Foundation Ltd
• Astor Rowe v Seawell Air Services
• Hotson v East Berkshire Area Health Authority
• Watson v British Boxing Board of Control Ltd and Another
• Charles v Trinidad & Tobago Electricity Commission
• Kuwait Airways Corporation v Iraqi Airways Company (Nos 4 & 5)
• Berkeley v Guardian Life Holdings Ltd and Guardian Life of the Caribbean Ltd
• Amatus Chuniesingh v Sergeant Wendell Williams and Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago
• Gett v Tabet
• Alexandria Ferguson v Yanique Smith
• Donachie v Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police
• Tesheira v Gulf View Medical Centre Ltd and Roopchand
• Norma Scott v Tomijam Company Ltd (T/A Rick's Convenience Store)
• C. Lorde v Boyce and Bay View Hospital Ltd; S. Lorde v Boyce and Bay View Hospital Ltd
• Alcoa Minerals of Jamaica Incorporated v Broderick
• Joan Thompson v Jamaica Health Security Network Ltd
• Grant et Al v Barnett and Others of the Public Hospitals Authority (on Behalf of the Princess Margaret Hospital)
• Lamorna Phillips v Barbados Public Workers' Co-Operative Credit Union
• Michael Watson v British Boxing Board of Control Ltd
• BAE Systems (Operations) Ltd v Konczak
• AB & Others v Ministry of Defence (No 2)
• Joycelyn Evanson Plaintiff/Appellant v Andrew E. Holm Ltd Defendant/Respondent [ECSC]
• Robinson v Post Office
• Clough v First Choice Holidays and Flights Ltd
• Boyce v Lorde et Al

CITED in

• Gordon v Wilson and Others
• Brown v Lewisham and North Southwark Health Authority
• Smith v Salford HA

[See more]

• David Yudt and Others v Leonard Ross & Craig (A Firm) and Others
• Brown v Lewisham and North Southwark Health Authority
• The Creutzfeldt-Jacob Disease Litigation, Straddlers Groups A and C v Secretary of State for Health
• P & O DEVELOPMENTS Ltd v THE GUY'S and St THOMAS' NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICE TRUST (by original action) and THE GUY'S and St THOMAS' NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICE TRUST v P & O DEVELOPMENTS Ltd, AUSTEN ASSOCIATES and AUSTEN ASSOCIATES Ltd (by counterclaim)
• Bennett v Minister of Community Welfare
• John Pfeiffer Pty Ltd v Canny
• The Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease Litigation, Group A and C Plaintiffs
• Brown v Lewisham and North Southwark Health Authority
• Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority
• Aviva Insurance Ltd v The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
• Vernon v Bosley (No. 1)
• BHP BILLITON PETROLEUM Ltd and Others v DALMINE SpA
• Amaca Pty Ltd v Ellis
• Sue Ellen O'Reilly v Western Sussex Hospital NHS Trust
• Nasir Hussain v Bradford Teaching Hospital NHS Foundation Trust and Another
• Chappel v Hart
• Air Express Ltd v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd
• Martyn Clarke v Hull City Council
• Elizabeth Miller V. Greater Glasgow Nhs Board
• Amaca Pty Ltd v Ellis
• CI Knitwear v Hotchkiss
• Mark Mather v Ministry of Defence
• Professor Carl Heneghan (Son and Administrator of the Estate of James Leo Heneghan, Deceased) v Manchester Dry Docks Ltd and Others
• Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago Ltd v Ryan and another (Trinidad and Tobago)
• Dr Sido John v Central Manchester and Manchester Children's University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
• Northrock Ltd v Jardine and Another
• Garfield Segree v Jamaica Wells and Services Ltd and Another
• Van De Weg v Minister of Health and Social Services and Another
• Attorney General v Phillip Granston
• Simmons v British Steel Plc; British Steel Plc v Simmons
• Chester v Afshar
• Mrs Susan Saunderson & Others v Sonae Industria (UK) Ltd
• Williams v The Bermuda Hospitals Board (Bermuda)
• Ricardo Wilkins v Powtronics Electrical Integrated Technology Ltd and Others
• Lenroy Connor Claimant v Cynthia Flemming Defendant
• Tabet v Gett
• Gregg v Scott
• Ellis v The Environment Agency
• Carroll v Lynch

DISTINGUISHED in

• Cerys Clements (by her mother and litigation friend Julia Geis-Clements) v Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust
• Anne Marie Quinn (A Minor) suing by her mother and next friend, Kathleen Quinn v Mid Western Health Board and Donal O'Sullivan
• Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority

[See more]

• Gemyma Shaunerva Norville Claimant v Attorney General of Saint Lucia Defendant [ECSC]
• Travia Douglas Claimant v Shivoughn Warde 1st Defendant Javid Warner 2nd Defendant Dwight Warde 3rd Defendant Quick Service Restaurants (ST Kitts nevis) Ltd (dba DOMINOS PIZZA) 4th Defendant [ECSC]
• Kay v Ayrshire and Arran Health Board

APPLIED in

• Bryce v Swan Hunter Group Plc
• Brown and Others v Corus (UK) Ltd
• Clark v MacLennan

[See more]

• Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd and Others
• Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority
• Fitzgerald v Lane
• Melvina Frett-Henry Appellant v [1] Tortola Concrete Ltd [2] Clayton Smithen Respondents
• Barker v Corus (UK) Ltd; Murray v British Shipbuilders (Hydrodynamics) Ltd; Patterson v Smiths Dock Ltd and Others

FOLLOWED in

• Dr. Soo Fook Mun v Foo Fio Na
• Surender Singh s/o Jagdish Singh v Li Man Kay

COMMENTED in

• Durham v Thorpe Campbell Holdings Ltd and another
• BAI (Run Off) Ltd (in Scheme of Arrangement) v Durham and Others

This document cites

---

• Alphacell Ltd v Woodward
• Nicholson v Atlas Steel Foundry and Engineering Company Ltd
• Gardiner v Motherwell Machinery and Scrap Company Ltd
• Bonnington Castings Ltd v Wardlaw
• R v Furser



See all quotations

• McGhee v National Coal Board
• Gardiner v Motherwell Machinery and Scrap Company Ltd