Tobin v Minister for Defence

Core Citations

CONSIDERS

• Environmental Protection Act 1990
• Environmental Protection Act 1990

CONSIDERS

• Tobin v Minister for Defence

REFERS TO

• Compagnie Financiere du Pacifique v Peruvian Guano Company
• Framus Ltd v CRH Plc
• Independent Newspapers (Ireland) Ltd v Joseph Murphy Junior

[See more]

• Hannon v Commissioner of Public Works and Others
• Dome Telecom Ltd v Eircom Ltd
• Hartside Ltd v Heineken Ireland Ltd
• Anglo Irish Bank Corporation Ltd v Browne
• Astrazeneca AB and Others v Pinewood Laboratories Ltd
• Flogas Ireland Ltd v Tru Gas Ltd and Others
• Ryanair p.l.c. v Aer Rianta c.p.t.
• Ryanair Ltd v Billigfluege.de GmbH and Others
• Tobin v Minister for Defence
• Joseph McCabe v Irish Life Assurance Plc
• Persona Digital Telephony Ltd v Minister for Public Enterprise, Ireland
• Dunnes Stores and Another v McCann
• SPV Osus Ltd v HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Ireland) Ltd
• Tobin v The Minister for Defence

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2019] 7 JIC 1502
• [2020] 1 IR 211

CONSIDERED in

• Novartis Pharma AG v Eli Lilly and Company Ltd
• Hurley v Valero Energy [Ireland] Ltd
• Comcast International Holdings Incorporated v The Minister for Public Enterprise

[See more]

• Avoncore Ltd and Canmont Ltd t/a Douglas Shopping Centre v Lesson Motors Ltd, Adam Opel GmbH, Opel Automobile GmbH and Vauxhall Motors Ltd
• Lorraine Lench v St. Patrick's Guild (Incorporated)(in Voluntary Liquidation), Kathleen Newell, Kathleen Lang, Patricia Lenihan, Ireland and The Attorney General
• Little v IBRC
• Tweedswood Ltd v Power
• Harrison v Charleton
• O'Keeffe v Governors and Guardians of the Hospital for the Relief of the Poor Lying-in Women Dublin
• Pat Ryan v Dengrove Designated Activity Company
• B.H. v The Director of Public Prosecutions and Others
• Gerry Adams v British Broadcasting Corporation
• Comcast International Holdings Incorporated v The Minister for Public Enterprise
• Comcast International Holdings Incorporated v The Minister for Public Enterprise
• McNally v Molex Ireland Ltd
• Holmes v CJ Fallon Unlimited Company
• Kearney v J&E Davy, T/A Davy
• Browne v The Minister for Justice and Equality and Others
• Egan v Castlerea Co-Operative Livestock Mart Ltd
• Lidl GmbH v Bilo Property Holdings & Others
• McKillen v The National Asset Management Agency and Others
• Dilger v Burke and Others
• O'Donovan v Cork County Council
• Moore v St. John of God Community Services Company CLG and Another
• CHC Ireland DAC v The Minister for Transport
• Brophy v Mediahuis Ireland Group Ltd
• O'Donnell v Michael Ryan
• O'Donnell v Michael Ryan
• National Truck Rental Company Ltd v Man Importers Ireland Ltd
• Chubb European Group SE [Formerly Ace European] v Perrigo Company Plc
• Irish Bank Resolution Corporation Ltd (in Special Liquidation v McKillen
• Nolan v Dildar Ltd (2)
• O’Donnell v Saltan Properties Ltd
• Ryanair DAC v SC Vola.Ro Srl
• Desmond v The Irish Times Ltd
• Bazsont Ltd Trading as Starbucks (Liffey Valley) v BVK Highstreet Retail Liffey Property Ltd
• Irish Water v Hypertrust Ltd, Desmond Reddy, Brian Reddy and O'Rourke Well Drilling Ltd
• Byrne v ABO Wind Ireland Ltd
• N.D. (Albania) v The International Protection Appeals Tribunal
• Tom McEvaddy Property Ltd Trading as Nexus Homes ((in Liquidation)) v National Asset Loan Management Dac
• Griffith v Parma Investments BV
• STT Risk Management v Transdev
• Griffin v Irish Aviation Authority _Final
• O'Mahony v Guardian News & Media Ltd
• Whelan Limestone Quarries Ltd v Companies Act 1963 to 2009
• Betty Martin Financial Services Ltd v EBS DAC
• David White v Arrabawn Co-Operative Society Ltd
• The White Country Inn (A Firm) v Crowley (2)
• Daly v Ardstone Capital Ltd
• The White Country Inn (A Firm) v Crowley (1)
• Victoria Hall Management Ltd v Patrick Cox
• Hireservices (e) Ltd v an Post
• William J. P. Egan v Michael Fenlon, Barry Sullivan, Gerard Burns, Ray Devine, Shane O'Connor, John Flannery, Seamus Heraty, Padraic Breen, Margaret Neile, Tom O'Donnell, Seamus O'Brien, Pat Donlon, Paul Doran, Dan Curley, Paddy Flynn, Joe O'Loughlin, Des Furlong, John Diver, Carmel Magee, Peter Crinnion, Tom O'Shea, Leonard Rasmussen and Joe Synnott
• William J. P. Egan v Michael Fenlon, Barry Sullivan, Gerard Burns, Ray Devine, Shane O'Connor, John Flannery, Seamus Heraty, Padraic Breen, Margaret Neile, Tom O'Donnell, Seamus O'Brien, Pat Donlon, Paul Doran, Dan Curley, Paddy Flynn, Joe O'Loughlin, Des Furlong, John Diver, Carmel Magee, Peter Crinnion, Tom O'Shea, Leonard Rasmussen and Joe Synnott
• Micks-Wallace (A Minor) v Dunne
• Meridian Global Vat Services Ltd v Lindelauf Consultancy BV, Roger Lindelauf and Vertex, Inc.
• Clydaville Investments Ltd v Setanta Centre Unlimited Company
• Independent News and Media Plc v The Companies Act 2014
• Adams v British Broadcasting Corporation
• Darragh Mackin v Denis O'Brien and James Morrissey
• Foot Locker Retail Ireland Ltd v Percy Nominees Ltd
• Catherine (Tina) McCormack v Health Services Executive
• Denis O'Brien v Red Flag Consulting Ltd, Karl Brophy, Seamus Conboy, Gavin O'Reilly, Brid Murphy, Kevin Hiney and Declan Ganley
• Karl Brophy v Independent News and Media Plc
• Pat Carey v Independent News & Media Plc, Independent Newspapers (Ireland) Ltd, The Commissioner of an Garda Síochána, Ireland and The Attorney General
• Columbia Lake Partners Growth Lending (Luxco) Sarl v James Egan
• Oval Topco Ltd v Health Service Executive
• Promontoria (Aran) Ltd v Sheehy
• McNulty v The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland trading as Bank of Ireland Group
• AB v Chi

APPLIED in

• Comcast International Holdings Incorporated v The Minister for Public Enterprise
• Victoria Hall Management Ltd v Cox
• Trafalgar Developments Ltd v Mazepin

[See more]

• Ryan v Dengrove Designated Activity Company

REFERRED in

• Tweedswood Ltd v Power
• Arthropharm (Europe) Ltd v The Health Products Regulatory Authority
• Egan v Castlerea Co-Operative Livestock Mart Ltd

[See more]

• Purtill v Aer Lingus Ltd
• Mackin and Another v O'Brien and Another
• Word Perfect Translation Services Ltd v Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform
• Goode Concrete v CRH Plc
• Waterford Credit Union v J & E Davy
• Victoria Hall Management Ltd v Patrick Cox
• Hireservices (e) Ltd v an Post
• Micks-Wallace (A Minor) v Dunne
• Catherine (Tina) McCormack v Health Services Executive
• Orla McNulty v The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland t/a Bank of Ireland Group
• Promontoria (Aran) Ltd v Sheehy
• AB v Chi

CITED in

• Harrison v Charleton
• O'Keeffe v Governors and Guardians of the Hospital for the Relief of the Poor Lying-in Women Dublin
• McKillen v The National Asset Management Agency and Others

[See more]

• O'Donovan v Cork County Council
• CDB Aviation Lease Finance DAC and Others v Lloyd's Insurance Company S.A and Others
• CHC Ireland DAC v The Minister for Transport

NOT APPLIED in

• Denis O'Brien v Red Flag Consulting Ltd, Karl Brophy, Seamus Conboy, Gavin O'Reilly, Brid Murphy, Kevin Hiney and Declan Ganley

This document cites

• Dome Telecom Ltd v Eircom Ltd
• Dunnes Stores and Another v McCann
• Framus Ltd v CRH Plc
• Persona Digital Telephony Ltd v Minister for Public Enterprise, Ireland
• SPV Osus Ltd v HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Ireland) Ltd



See all quotations

• Hartside Ltd v Heineken Ireland Ltd
• Joseph McCabe v Irish Life Assurance Plc
• Independent Newspapers (Ireland) Ltd v Joseph Murphy Junior
• Ryanair Ltd v Billigfluege.de GmbH and Others
• Tobin v Minister for Defence
• Astrazeneca AB and Others v Pinewood Laboratories Ltd
• Flogas Ireland Ltd v Tru Gas Ltd and Others
• Yap v Childrens University Hospital Temple Street Ltd
• Anglo Irish Bank Corporation Ltd v Browne
• Ryanair p.l.c. v Aer Rianta c.p.t.
• Tobin v The Minister for Defence
• Hannon v Commissioner of Public Works and Others
• Tobin v Minister for Defence
• Compagnie Financiere du Pacifique v Peruvian Guano Company
• Aer Rianta c.p.t. v Ryanair Ltd
• Environmental Protection Act 1990
• The Rules of the Superior Courts 1986