Framus Ltd v CRH Plc

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Murphy v J. Donohoe Ltd (No 2)
• Smurfit Paribas Bank Ltd v A.A.B. Export Finance Ltd

FOLLOWS

• Ryanair p.l.c. v Aer Rianta c.p.t.
• Jack O'Toole Ltd v MacEoin Kelly Associates
• Lismore Homes Ltd ((in Receivership)) v Bank of Ireland Finance Ltd

[See more]

• Fallon v an Bord Pleanála
• Thalle v Soares and Others

CONSIDERS

• A4 Trunk Road (Bath Road, Hillingdon) (Bus Lane) Order 1999
• The Rules of the Superior Courts 1986
• Companies Act, 1963

[See more]

• Rules of the Superior Courts (No. 2) (Discovery), 1999

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Framus Ltd v CRH Plc

REVERSES

• Framus Ltd v CRH Plc

REFERS TO

• Perry v Stratham, Ltd
• S.E.E. Company Ltd v Public Lighting Services Ltd
• Smurfit Paribas Bank Ltd v A.A.B. Export Finance Ltd

[See more]

• Sterling-Winthrop Group Ltd v Farbenfabriken Bayer A.G.
• Swords v Western Proteins Ltd
• Taylor v Anderton (Police Complaints Authority Intervening)
• Taylor v Clonmel Healthcare Ltd
• Aquatechnologie Ltd v National Standards Authority of Ireland and Others
• Brooks Thomas Ltd v Impac Ltd
• Burke v DPP
• Compagnie Financiere du Pacifique v Peruvian Guano Company
• Cooper-Flynn v RTE
• Hannon v Commissioner of Public Works and Others
• Irish Nationwide Building Society v Charlton
• Murphy v J. Donohoe Ltd (No 2)

CONSIDERED in

• Oppermann Associates Ltd v Noone Casey
• BAM PPP PGGM Infrastructure Cooperatie UA v National Treasury Management Agency & Min for Education & Skills
• Bayerische Moteren Werke Aktiengsellschaft v Ronayne (t/a BMWCARE)

[See more]

• Keane v Aer Rianta
• Danske Bank A/S (t/a National Irish Bank) v Rockridge Development and Others
• O'Brien v Red Flag Consulting Ltd(1)
• Norton (Waterford) Ltd t/a Teva Pharmaceuticals Ireland v Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma Gmbh & Company Kg (No.1) and Others
• Astrazeneca AB and Others v Pinewood Laboratories Ltd
• Pat Ryan v Dengrove Designated Activity Company
• Coughlan v ESB Wind Development Ltd
• Re Astrazeneca AB
• Michael Lowry v Mr. Justice Michael Moriarty
• N.D. (Albania) v The International Protection Appeals Tribunal
• Biogen Inc. v Celltrion Inc.
• James Patrick Flannery and Another v Mortimer John Walters and Others
• Framus Ltd and Others v CRH Plc and Others
• A v B
• A v B
• Oltech (Systems) Ltd v Olivetti UK Ltd
• Darragh Mackin v Denis O'Brien and James Morrissey
• Wegner v Murphy
• Avoncore Ltd and Canmont Ltd t/a Douglas Shopping Centre v Lesson Motors Ltd, Adam Opel GmbH, Opel Automobile GmbH and Vauxhall Motors Ltd
• Irish Bank Resolution Corporation Ltd and Others v Quinn and Others
• Betty Martin Financial Services Ltd v EBS DAC
• Denis O'Brien v Red Flag Consulting Ltd, Karl Brophy, Seamus Conboy, Gavin O'Reilly, Brid Murphy, Kevin Hiney and Declan Ganley
• Pat Carey v Independent News & Media Plc, Independent Newspapers (Ireland) Ltd, The Commissioner of an Garda Síochána, Ireland and The Attorney General
• Hartside Ltd v Heineken Ireland Ltd
• Promontoria (Aran) Ltd v Sheehy
• O'Donnell v Michael Ryan
• Murphy v The Revenue Commissioners
• Ryanair DAC v SC Vola.Ro Srl
• Chubb European Group SE [Formerly Ace European] v Perrigo Company Plc
• Comcast International Holdings Incorporated v The Minister for Public Enterprise
• Marshall and Others v Electricity Supply Board and Others
• PJ Carroll & Company Ltd v Minister for Health and Children
• Dome Telecom Ltd v Eircom Ltd
• Anglo Irish Bank Corporation Ltd v Browne
• Linfen Ltd and Others v Rocca and Others
• Linfen Ltd and Others v Rocca and Others
• Ciara Quinn and Others v Irish Bank Resolution Corporation Ltd and Others
• McNally v Molex Ireland Ltd
• Flogas Ireland Ltd v Tru Gas Ltd and Others
• Protégé International Group (Cyprus) Ltd v Irish Distillers Ltd
• Lehane v Dunne
• Lar Sheeran, Aisling Murphy and Richard Mulcahy v Alan Fitzpatrick, as Liquidator of the Sixth Irish Forestry Fund Plc ((in Liquidation)) and the Third Forestry Growth Plan Plc ((in Liquidation))
• Delta Index Ltd v Ayondo Markets Ltd
• Bazsont Ltd Trading as Starbucks (Liffey Valley) v BVK Highstreet Retail Liffey Property Ltd
• University College Cork v Electricity Supply Board
• Comcast International Holdings Incorporated v The Minister for Public Enterprise
• Green Pastures (Donegal) v Aurivo Co-Operative Society Ltd and Another

REFERRED in

• CB Richard Ellis (plaintiff) v Dunne
• Protégé International Group (Cyprus) Ltd v Irish Distillers Ltd
• McKillen v Irish Bank Resolution Corporation (in special liquidation) and Others

[See more]

• Morrissey v National Asset Management Agency Ltd
• Kelleher v National Asset Loan Management Ltd
• Walsh v Health Service Executive
• Volkswagon Group Ireland Ltd v Higgins
• O'Brien v Red Flag Consulting
• O'Neill and Others v an Taoiseach and Others
• Ryanair Ltd v Channel Four Television Corporation No. 3
• West Donegal Land League Ltd v Udaras Na Gaeltachta
• Permanent TSB Plc formerly Irish Life & Permanent Plc
• Quinn Insurance Ltd (Under administration) v PriceWaterhouseCoopers (A Firm)
• Dunnes Stores and Another v McCann
• Medtronic Inc. and Others v Guidant Corporation and Others
• CMC Medical Operations Ltd ((in Liquidation)) t/a Cork Medical Centre v Voluntary Health Insurance Board
• Ryan v Dengrove Designated Activity Company
• Tobin v Minister for Defence
• Tobin v The Minister for Defence
• Ganley v RTE
• De Lacy v Coyle
• Goode Concrete v CRH Plc
• Waterford Credit Union Ltd v J & E Davy
• Susquehanna International Group Ltd v Needham
• Kelland Homes Ltd v Ballytherm Ltd
• Promontoria (Aran) Ltd v Sheehy
• Irish Bank Resolution Corporation Ltd & Irish Nationwide Building Society v Fingleton and Others
• V v W
• Waterford Credit Union v J & E Davy
• Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma GmbH v Norton (Waterford) Ltd
• Coolbrook Developments Ltd v Lington Development Ltd
• Hire Services Ltd (E) v an Post
• Schneider (Europe) GmbH v Conor Medsystems Ireland Ltd
• O'Brien v Revenue Commissioners
• O'Brien v Red Flag Consulting Ltd
• Marshall and Others v Electricity Supply Board and Others
• Be Spoke Capital AG v Altum Capital Management LLC
• James Elliott Construction Ltd v Lagan
• Goode Concrete v CRH Plc
• Thema International Fund Plc v HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Irl) and Others
• Protégé International Group (Cyprus) Ltd v Irish Distillers Ltd
• Comcast International Holdings Incorporated v The Minister for Public Enterprise
• Marian Cave v Walter Beatty and Others

CITED in

• QUINN v IRISH BANK RESOLUTION Corporation Ltd
• McCleary v Allied Irish Bank Plc
• CMC Medical Operations Ltd ((in Liquidation)) t/a Cork Medical Centre v The Voluntary Health Insurance Board

[See more]

• Fides Capital Ltd v Alchemy Products Ltd
• Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform v McGuigan
• Dylan Evans v University College Cork
• Thema International Fund Plc v HSBC Institutional Trust Service (Ireland) Ltd
• James Patrick Flannery and Another v Mortimer John Walters and Others
• James Elliot Construction Ltd v Lagan
• CDB Aviation Lease Finance DAC and Others v Lloyd's Insurance Company S.A and Others
• Power v Tesco Ireland Ltd
• Wegner v Murphy
• BAM PPP PGGM Infrastructure Cooperatie UA v National Treasury Management Agency
• Denis O'Brien v Red Flag Consulting Ltd, Karl Brophy, Seamus Conboy, Gavin O'Reilly, Brid Murphy, Kevin Hiney and Declan Ganley
• O'Donnell v Michael Ryan
• IBB Internet Services Ltd v Motorola Ltd
• (E)F & T(F) (plaintiffs) v Minister for Education and Science
• Trafalgar Developments Ltd v Mazepin
• Mustardside - v - Tacre
• Pebble Beach Owners Management Company Ltd v Neville
• Ferrotec Ltd v Myles Bramwell Executive Services Ltd t/a Slimming World
• O'Leary v Volkswagen Group Ireland Ltd
• Allergan Pharmaceuticals (Ireland) Ltd v Noel Deane Roofing and Cladding Ltd and Others

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2004] 4 JIC 2202
• [2004] 2 ILRM 439
• [2004] 2 IR 20

FOLLOWED in

• IBB Internet Services Ltd and Others v Motorola Ltd
• ACC Loan management v Dooley
• White v Bar Council of Ireland

APPLIED in

• Ticket Generator Ltd v Dublin Airport Authority & Others (No 2)
• Tobin v Minister for Defence
• Comcast International Holdings Incorporated v The Minister for Public Enterprise

[See more]

• McEvoy v an Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission
• Halpin v National Museum of Ireland

APPROVED in

• Edward Keating v Radio Telefís Éireann and Others

This document cites

---

• Taylor v Clonmel Healthcare Ltd
• Taylor v Anderton (Police Complaints Authority Intervening)
• S.E.E. Company Ltd v Public Lighting Services Ltd
• Burke v DPP
• Murphy v J. Donohoe Ltd (No 2)



See all quotations

• Irish Nationwide Building Society v Charlton
• Smurfit Paribas Bank Ltd v A.A.B. Export Finance Ltd
• Lismore Homes Ltd ((in Receivership)) v Bank of Ireland Finance Ltd
• Murphy v J. Donohoe Ltd (No 2)
• Swords v Western Proteins Ltd
• Aquatechnologie Ltd v National Standards Authority of Ireland and Others
• Smurfit Paribas Bank Ltd v A.A.B. Export Finance Ltd
• Ryanair p.l.c. v Aer Rianta c.p.t.
• Ryanair Ltd v Aer Rianta Cpt
• Hannon v Commissioner of Public Works and Others
• Fallon v an Bord Pleanála
• Brooks Thomas Ltd v Impac Ltd
• Cooper-Flynn v RTE
• Framus Ltd v CRH Plc
• Compagnie Financiere du Pacifique v Peruvian Guano Company
• Jack O'Toole Ltd v MacEoin Kelly Associates
• Perry v Stratham, Ltd
• Thalle v Soares and Others
• Sterling-Winthrop Group Ltd v Farbenfabriken Bayer A.G.
• Rules of the Superior Courts (No. 2) (Discovery), 1999
• Civil Procedure Rules 1998
• Companies Act, 1963
• Competition Act, 1991
• The Rules of the Superior Courts 1986