Susan Smith (on her own behalf and as administrator of the Estate of Philip Hewett, Deceased) (1st Appellant) Colin Redpath (on his own behalf and as Executor of the Will of Kirk James Redpath, Deceased) (2nd Appellant) Courtney Ellis (A Child) by her Litigation Friend Karla Ellis and Karla Ellis (3rd and 4th Appellants) v The Ministry of Defence

Core Citations

---

DISAPPROVES

CONSIDERS

• Barrett v Enfield London Borough Council
• Van Colle and Another v Chief Constable of the Hertfordshire Police
• Brooks v Metropolitan Police Commisioner

[See more]

• Stovin and Another v Norfolk County Council

REFERS TO

• Phelps v London Borough of Hillingdon
• R Gentle & Clarke v The Prime Minister and Others
• Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee

[See more]

• Shaw Savill and Albion Company Ltd v Commonwealth
• Hopps v Mott MacDonald Ltd and Another
• Stovin v Wise
• Gorringe v Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council
• Davies v Global Strategies Group
• Smith & Others v M.O.D.

APPLIES

• R (Smith) v Oxfordshire Assistant Deputy Coroner

AFFIRMS

• Smith & Others v M.O.D.

CITES

• AL-JEDDA v. THE UNITED KINGDOM
• Mulcahy v Ministry of Defence
• Kay v Lambeth City Council; Leeds City Council v Price

[See more]

• M and Another v London Borough of Newham and Others; X and Others v Bedfordshire County Council

APPROVES

• Multiple Claimants v Ministry of Defence
• Barrett v Enfield London Borough Council

CONSIDERS

• Soering v United Kingdom
• Human Rights Act 1998
• Human Rights Act 1998

[See more]

• Highways Act 1980
• Crown Proceedings Act 1947 - Articles : S-2
• Crown Proceedings (Armed Forces) Act 1987 - Articles : S-1

DISTINGUISHES

• Brooks v Metropolitan Police Commisioner
• Van Colle and Another v Chief Constable of the Hertfordshire Police
• Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire

CONSIDERED in

• Adam Broni, Simon Woof, Raphael Barbour v Ministry of Defence
• Ian Craig Malone v Ministry of Defence

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2012] WLR D 281
• [2013] 1 All ER 778
• [20/11/2012] TLR 1

[See more]

• [2013] 2 WLR 27

CITED in

• Kennedy v Information Commissioner and another (Secretary of State for Justice and Others intervening) [SC]

APPEAL RESOLVED in

• Smith v Ministry of Defence

REVERSED in

• Smith v Ministry of Defence

This document cites

---

• Convenio Europeo para la Protección de los Derechos Humanos y de las Libertades Fundamentales
• R Gentle & Clarke v The Prime Minister and Others
• Brooks v Metropolitan Police Commisioner
• Phelps v London Borough of Hillingdon
• Stovin and Another v Norfolk County Council



See all quotations

• Stovin v Wise
• Barrett v Enfield London Borough Council
• Mulcahy v Ministry of Defence
• Gorringe v Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council
• Kay v Lambeth City Council; Leeds City Council v Price
• Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire
• Van Colle and Another v Chief Constable of the Hertfordshire Police
• Fawdry v Ministry of Defence
• Barrett v Enfield London Borough Council
• M and Another v London Borough of Newham and Others; X and Others v Bedfordshire County Council
• Davies v Global Strategies Group
• Hopps v Mott MacDonald Ltd and Another
• Multiple Claimants v Ministry of Defence
• Van Colle and Another v Chief Constable of the Hertfordshire Police
• Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire
• Michael Chalk (a Patient by His Mother and by His Litigation Friend Ursula Morley) v The Ministry of Defence
• Brooks v Metropolitan Police Commisioner
• Smith & Others v M.O.D.
• Hitachi Capital (UK) Plc v V-12 Finance Ltd
• Barrett v Enfield London Borough Council
• Shaw Savill and Albion Company Ltd v Commonwealth
• Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee
• Crown Proceedings (Armed Forces) Act 1987
• Highways Act 1980
• Crown Proceedings Act 1947
• Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations 1998
• Personal Protective Equipment at Work Regulations 1992
• Gorringe v Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council
• Rabone and another v Pennine Care NHS Trust
• Kay v Lambeth City Council; Leeds City Council v Price