Porter v Magill

Core Citations

---

REFERS TO

• R v Lambert
• R (Alconbury Developments Ltd) v Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions
• R (Pretty) v DPP

[See more]

• R v Kansal (Yash Pal) (Change of Law) (No 2)
• Millar v Dickson; Payne and Others v Heywood

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• 96 LGR 157
• 30 HLR 997

REFERRED in

• Bernadette Patricia McDaid v Nursing & Midwifery Council
• R v F (C J) (2006)
• Cairnstores Ltd v Aktiebolaget Hassle (Application for Revocation)

[See more]

• Whitefield v General Medical Council
• R v Simeon Szypusz and David Anthony Gaynor
• Coates (Victory Henry Bright) and (Graves) Martin v The Queen
• Scrivens v Ethical Standards Officer
• R (TP) v West London Youth Court and Others
• Ansar v Lloyds TSB Bank Plc and Others
• Bardsley v The Office of Fair Trading and Another
• R v George (Owen)
• Kwamin v Abbey National Plc
• General Medical Council v Michael Pembrey
• DS v HM Advocate
• R v Carl Eldin
• Kataria v Essex Strategic Health Authority
• Suresh Deman and Association of University Teachers and Officers at Queen's University (AUT)
• In the matter of an application for Judicial Review by Trevor Purcell
• R (Opoku) v Principal and Governors of Southwark College
• Barke v SEETEC Business Technology Centre Ltd
• Cairnstores Ltd v Aktiebolaget Hassle (Application for Revocation)
• Sadler v General Medical Council
• Feld v Barnet London Borough Council; Pour v Westminster City Council
• The Queen (on the application of Mrs Gabriele Shaw) v (1) HM Coroner and (2) Assistant Deputy Coroner for Leicester City and South Leicestershire University Hospitals of Leicester Nhs Trust, Drs Kovac, West, Jilaihawi, Williams, Chin, Professor Spyt (Interested Parties)
• The Queen (on the application of Gregory McGetrick) v Parole Board and Another
• Hart and Another v Relentless Records Ltd and Others
• Alan Wilkinson and Lord Chancellor's Department and official Solicitor
• Chellaram v Chellaram (No. 2)
• Ghadami v Harlow District Council (Sapphire Retail Fund Ltd, interested party)
• R (R) v Durham Constabulary and Another
• Tang Kin Hwa v Traditional Chinese Medicine Practitioners Board
• Amec Capital Projects Ltd v Whitefriars City Estates Ltd
• Flaherty v National Greyhound Racing Club Ltd
• R (S (A Child)) v Brent London Borough Council; R (P (A Child)) v Oxfordshire County Council Exclusions Appeals Panel ;
• R v H and Another
• R v Secretary of State for Health ex parte Quintavalle (on behalf of Pro-Life Alliance)
• Rojas v Berllaque (Attorney General for Gibraltar intervening)
• R (Island Farm Development Ltd) v Bridgend County Borough Council

APPLIED in

• R(Aujla and Others) v Slough Borough Council
• The Council for National Parks Ltd and The Pembrokeshire Coast National Park Authority and J William McNamara Bluestone Holdings Ltd Alfred McAlpine Construction Ltd Parties
• Condron v National Assembley for Wales

[See more]

• R v Adrian Craig Mason; Clayton Paul Wood; Eammon Terry George McClelland; John Paul Tierney [CA (Crim), 13/02/2002]
• R (Giuseppe Agnello and Fourteen Others, known as the Western International Campaign Group) v The Mayor and Burgess of the London Borough of Hounslow
• Derry City Council and Brickkiln Ltd and Professor Stephen Willetts
• Donaldson MP & Ors v Empey & Ors
• Baglin v Attorney General
• Barette v Attorney General
• Georgiou v London Borough of Enfield and Others
• R Evandro Lagos v HM Coroner for the City of London Anele Austin (Interested Party)
• Meerabux v Attorney General of Belize
• Lawal v Northern Spirit Ltd
• Taylor and Another v Lawrence and Another
• Condron v National Assembley for Wales
• Gillies v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions

FOLLOWED in

• Shujaat Husain v Chief Constable of South Wales Police
• Re P (A Barrister) (2005)
• Director of Assets Recovery Agency and William Lovell

[See more]

• R v Nicolas Marquez-Arnedo
• Anchor Trust Company Ltd v Jersey Financial Services Commission

CONSIDERED in

• R v Shaun Blades
• R v Ian Macdonald
• In the matter of an application by Teresa Halligan for Judicial Review

[See more]

• R v Smith (Lance Percival)
• R (Mahfouz) v General Medical Council
• Almazeedi v Penner and another
• Timothy Walsh Appellant Stephen Ward Appellant Bjorn Bjerkham Appellant v Stephen Ward Bjorn Bjerkham Nature's Produce Inc. Respondents Timothy Walsh Bjorn Bjerkham Nature's Produce Inc. Respondents Timothy Walsh Stephen Ward Nature's Produce Inc. Respondents
• Gladden v Attorney General et Al
• Bartholomew Brown and Another v Jamaica National Building Society
• Browne (leader of the Opposition) v Attorney General et Al
• Gardiner v R
• Smith v The Queen
• Darrell v Board of Inquiry and Minister of Culture and Social Rehabilitation
• Oilfields Workers' Trade Union v R Turtle Beach Hotel
• Stubbs, Evans and Davis v R
• Darrell v Board of Inquiry (Appointed Under The Human Rights) and Minisater of Culture and Social Rehabilitation et Al
• Parris v Barbados Advocate Publishers (2000) Incorporated, Griffith (t/a Barbados Labour Party) and Nation Publishing Company Ltd
• Hawkesworth et Al v Superintendent of Prisons et Al
• St. George et Al v Hayward et Al
• F v F [SC Div (Bda)]
• RB & MB v Family Court Worshipful Stoneham & Panel [SC App (Bda)]
• Re; Hall, Julian Ernest Sinclair Phillips
• Mitchell v Georges (Sole Commissioner of the Ottley Hall Commission of Inquiry)
• Belize Bank Ltd v Attorney General et Al
• Wildman v Judicial and Legal Services Commission of the Eastern Caribbean States
• KCP Applicant v JB Respondent
• Goode Concrete v CRH Plc
• Re Summary, inquest into the Death of Israel
• Kensington International Ltd v Montrow International Ltd (in Provisional Liquidation)
• Doyle v The Queen
• ASM Shipping Ltd of India v TTMI Ltd of England
• Bank of Bermuda Ltd v Minister of Community Affairs and Sport
• Wheeler et Al v Tobago Regional Authority and Manswell-Myrie
• Demarco Almeida v Opportunity Equity Partners Ltd
• Jean v Montoute; Montoute et Al v Jean
• Gafoor v The Integrity Commisssion
• [1] Vance Amory Appellant v [1] Thomas Sharpe, QC [2] The Commission of Inquiry [3] The Nevis Island Administration [4] Attorney General of St. Kitts and Nevis Respondents [ECSC]
• Hon. Shawn K. Richards Claimant v The Constituency Boundaries Commission 1st Defendant Attorney General of St. Christopher and Nevis 2nd Defendant [ECSC]
• Sonya Young Appellant v Vynette Frederick Respondent [ECSC]
• Sir James Fitz Allen Mitchell Appellant v Ephraim Georges (Sole Commissioner of the Ottley Hall Commission of Inquiry) Respondent [ECSC]
• Honourable Gaston Browne (The Leader of the Opposition) Claimant v Attorney General of Antigua and Barbuda First Respondent Mr. Juno Samuel, Mr. Nathaniel James, Mr. Jack Kelsick Mr. Anthonyson King, Mrs. Glendina McKay, Mrs. Paula Lee (members of the Antigua and Barbuda Electoral Commission under the Provisions of The Representation of the People (Amendment) Act No. 12 of 2011) Other Respondents [ECSC]
• Honourable Gaston Browne (The Leader of The Opposition) Claimant v Attorney General of Antigua and Barbuda First Respondent Mr. Juno Samuel, Mr. Nathaniel James, Mr. Jack Kelsick Mr. Anthonyson King, Mrs. Glendina Mckay, Mrs. Paula Lee (members of the Antigua and Barbuda Electoral Commission under the Provisions of The Representation of the People (Amendment) Act No. 12 of 2011) Other Respondents [ECSC]
• Hugh Wildman Appellant v The Judicial and Legal Services Commission of the Eastern Caribbean States Respondent [ECSC]
• William Andrew Chang v Commissioner of Taxpayer Appeals
• The Queen v Andre Penn
• The Attorney General v Kublalsingh and Others
• Gonzalez v Director General of Statistical Institute of Belize et Al
• Young v Frederick; Stephenson v Director of Public Prosecutions (Williams) and Chief Magistrate (Young); Frederick v Director of Public Prosecutions (Williams) and Chief Magistrate (Young); Chance v Director of Public Prosecutions (Williams); Lewis v Director of Public Prosecutions (Williams) and Chief Magistrate (Young)
• Spiers (Procurator Fiscal) v Ruddy
• Owen Clunie v General Legal Council
• Police Service Commission and Others v Donovan O'Connor
• Belize Electricity Ltd v Public Utilities Commission
• Carlton Bedminister Careem Bedminister Claimants v DPP Attorney General Defendants [ECSC]
• NH International (Caribbean) Ltd v Urban Development Corporation of Trinidad and Tobago Ltd
• Amory v Sharpe et Al
• Porter v Magill
• Bahall v Roopchand
• Martha Perch and Others v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago

CITED in

• Bangs v Connex South Eastern Ltd
• In the matter of an application by John Tiernan for Judicial Review
• Simpson v AG

[See more]

• Cannonier v DPP; Isaac and Others v DPP
• Snelling v Bolton
• Bank of Bermuda Ltd v Minister of Community Affairs & Sport
• China North Industries Investment Management Ltd v China North Industries Investment Ltd
• Annette Tuitt v Abi Bank Ltd
• AWG Group Ltd v Morrison
• Westminster City Council v Porter and another
• "R" v HM Advocate and Another
• Attorney General's Reference (No. 2 of 2001); R v J

DISTINGUISHED in

• Barrington Earl Frankson v General Legal Council

APPEAL RESOLVED in

• Porter v Magill

COMMENTED in

• R v David Michael Shayler
• R v Spear; R v Hastie; R v Boyd; R v Williams and nine other defendants (Conjoined appeals)

This document cites

---

• R (Pretty) v DPP
• R v Lambert
• R (Alconbury Developments Ltd) v Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions
• R v Kansal (Yash Pal) (Change of Law) (No 2)
• Millar v Dickson; Payne and Others v Heywood