Medcalf v Mardell (Wasted Costs Order)

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Actionstrength Ltd (trading as Vital Resources) v International Glass Engineering in.GL.EN SpA and another

REFERS TO

• Raylee Patricia Harley (Appellant) Robert McDonald (Respondent) Glasgow Harley (Appellant) Robert McDonald (Respondent)
• Parry-Jones v Law Society

[See more]

• Symphony Group Plc v Hodgson
• R v Derby Magistrates' Court, ex parte B
• Byrne v Sefton Health Authority
• Associated Leisure Ltd (Phonographic Equipment Company Ltd) v Associated Newspapers Ltd
• Ladd v Marshall
• Orchard v South Eastern Electricity Board
• Barratt v Ansell (t/a as Woolf Seddon); Arthur JS Hall & Company v Simons
• Kelly v London Transport Executive
• R v Commissioners of Inland Revenue, ex parte Taylor (No. 2)
• Myers v Elman
• General Mediterranean Holdings SA v Patel and Another
• Worsley v Tambrands Ltd
• Lillicrap v Nalder & Son (A Firm)
• Oldfield v Keogh
• Brown v Bennett (Wasted Costs) (No. 1)

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Medcalf v Mardell (Wasted Costs Order)

APPROVES

• Ridehalgh v Horsefield; Watson v Watson (Wasted Costs Orders)

REVERSES

• Medcalf v Mardell (Wasted Costs Order)

CONSIDERS

• Supreme Court (now known as Senior Courts) Act 1981 - Articles : S-51
• Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 - Articles : S-4
• Supreme Court (now known as Senior Courts) Act 1981

[See more]

• Prosecution of Offences Act 1985
• Magistrates' Courts Act 1980
• Courts and Legal Services Act 1990

REFERRED in

• Lumsdon and Another v Legal Services Board and Others
• Pjsc National Bank Trust v Boris Mints
• Lakatamia Shipping Company Ltd v Nobu Su (aka Su Hsin Chi; aka Nobu Morimoto)

[See more]

• Innes Keochan Berntsen and Another v Matthew Tait and Another
• Surrey Heath Borough Council v James Robb
• Gempride Ltd v Jagrit Bamrah
• Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd
• Ventures Food Ltd v Little Dessert Shop Limted
• Lex Foundation v Citibank N.A.
• Mrs Beverley Goldman & Others v Zurich Insurance Plc
• SAS Institute Inc. v World Programming Ltd
• Daniel Kenig v Thomson Snell & Passmore LLP
• The ECU Group Plc v HSBC Bank Plc
• Robert David Mackenzie v Rosenblatt Solicitors (A Firm)
• Anthony Douglas King v Barry Stiefel
• Jinxin Inc. v Aser Media Pte Ltd
• The Gleaner Company Ltd and another v Abrahams
• Yuanda (UK) Company Ltd v Multiplex Construction Europe Ltd (formerly known as Brookfield Multiplex Construction Europe Ltd)
• Bebenek v The Minister for Justice and Equality
• Maria Alessandra Foglia v The Family Officer Ltd
• Anthony Douglas King v Barry Stiefel

CONSIDERED in

• Majdabadi v Trustees of London Clinic &Another
• Re Boodhoo (Wasted costs order)
• Ghannouchi v Houni Ltd and Others

[See more]

• Abbar and Another v Saudi Economic & Development Company Real Estate Ltd and Others
• Financial Services Authority v Sinaloa Gold Plc and 2 Others
• Findel Plc and Others v White Arrow Express Ltd and Another
• Lady Archer v Williams
• Paul Anthony King and Jayne Lesley King v Technology Piling Ltd and Pearce Rougier (CIVILS) Ltd (T/A Pearce Rougier Associates) and Harold A Pearce and Excess Insurance Company Ltd
• PCCEF Pty Ltd v Geelong Football Club Ltd (No 2)
• Marsh v Sofaer
• D v H
• Foenander v Bond Lewis & Company
• Rybak and Others v Langbar International Ltd
• Ragny Sharma and Another v Hunters
• MSM and Others (Wasted Costs, Effect of S.29(4))
• Beck Peppiatt Ltd v Norwest Holst Construction Ltd
• Rybak v Langbar International Ltd (Wasted Costs)
• James Laferla v Messrs Cridlands Lawyers
• Eurobodalla Shire Council v Wells & 2 Ors
• Dexter Ltd v Vlieland-Boddy
• Lorraine Campbell as legal representative of the Estate of Robert George Monckton (Deceased) v Rebecca Goodwin
• Ramkarun Bushan Deepchand v Anbananden Sooben
• Djz Constructions Pty Ltd v Paul Pritchard trading as Pritchard Law Group and Ors
• Bechara v Jawhar
• Katherine Jane Lumsdon and Others v Legal Services Board General Council of the Bar (acting by the Bar Standards Board) and Others (Interested Parties)
• Koo Golden East Mongolia v Bank of Nova Scotia
• Glen Dimplex Home Applicances Ltd v Shelagh Ann Smith and Others
• Gill v Humanware Europe Plc
• Fitzhugh Gates (A Firm) v Sherman
• Minister of Finance (Incorporated) v Aabar Investments PJS
• Darkwah Awuah, SJ, TN and Khadija Musu Momoh v The Secretary of State for the Home Department
• European Hire Cars Pty Ltd v Beilby Poulden Costello
• Via Sanantonio Pty Ltd v Walker Corporation Pty Ltd and Another
• RDCW Diamond (Pty) Ltd v Da Gloria
• Treadwell v Hickey
• Hannam v State of New South Wales (No 11)
• Gsd Law Ltd v Craig Wardman of St Gobain Building Distribution and Others
• CMCS Common Market Commercial Services AVV v Taylor (Wasted Costs)
• Isaacs Partnership v Umm Al-Jawaby Oil Service Company Ltd
• Surrey Heath Borough Council v James Robb
• XJ (China) v The Secretary of State for the Home Department
• Harrison v Harrison
• Persaud and Others v Persaud and Others
• Ventures Food Ltd v Little Dessert Shop Limted
• Lex Foundation v Citibank N.A.
• Law Society v Sephton & Company (A Firm)
• Roy Mortimer Boschat v The Chief Officer of the States of Jersey Police
• Niall Iain MacFirbhisigh (as Curator of Barry Lional Ching) and Barbara Mary Marvell Ching v C.I. Trustees and Executors Ltd and Steven Gidley and Gary Killmister
• Sharlane Perczynski v Andrzej Percsynski, Warren Trustees Ltd, Elysium Trustees Ltd and Gollop
• Caitriona Mary Fogarty v St Martin's Cottage Ltd
• (1) C.I. Trustees and Executors Ltd v (1) Sinels Advocates
• David Banks v Sanne Holdings Ltd
• BNP Paribas Jersey Trust Corporation Ltd v Camilla de Bourbon des deux Siciles
• Dominion Finance Group Ltd ((in Receivership) and Liquidation) v Sade Developments Ltd
• Practitioner Y v Foulkes and Others
• Hersi & Company Solicitors v The Lord Chancellor (as Successor to the Legal Services Commission)
• Wagstaff v Colls
• Global Steel Holdings Ltd (a company registered in the Isle of Man) v Prasan (PTC) Ltd (a company registered in the British Virgin Islands)
• Thornhill (David) (Trustee in Bankruptcy of Clive William Atherton) v (1) Atherton (Clive William) (2) Atherton (Linda Margaret) (3) Myerson (Geoffrey)
• Gokani v Visvalingam Pty Ltd
• Anthony King v DWF LLP
• Ramac Holdings Ltd v Brachers
• Re-Source America International Ltd (Claimants) Platt Site Services Ltd (Defendant and Part 20 Claimant) Barkin Construction Ltd (Defendant to Part 20 Claim)
• Hedrich v Standard Bank London Ltd
• Nationwide Building Society v Dunlop Haywards Ltd
• Smartway Brasil S.A v Registrar of International Business Companies
• AO Alfa Bank v Kipford Ventures Ltd
• Joseph Aaron v The Law Society (The Office for The Supervision of Solicitors)/
• John Hunt v Annolight Ltd
• Dempsey v Johnstone
• The Section 92 of the Companies Act (2022 Revision) and Global Cord Blood Corporation
• The Section 92 of the Companies Act (2022 Revision) and Global Cord Blood Corporation
• Michael Stallard v Mark Bishop, Gillian Bishop and MB & GB Holdings Ltd
• St John's Trust Company (PVT) Ltd v James Watlington
• Jinxin Inc. v Aser Media Pte Ltd
• Hussain and Another v Sarkar and Another
• St John's Trust Company (PVT) Ltd v James Watlington
• June Turner v William Guy Norton
• Powell v Boladz
• Willers v Joyce (No 1)
• Fisher Meredith LLP v JH, PH
• Joan Mary Nolan; Richard James Nolan; Seamus Patrick Nolan; Patricia Mary Nolan; Ann Mary Nolan; Elizabeth Mary Nolan; Raymond John Nolan; John Martin Nolan; Brendan Joseph Nolan; Sally Ann Nolan; Oliver Nicholas Nolan; Kevin Patrick Nolan; Noel Patrick Nolan; Serene Investments Ltd; Bilberry Investments Holdings Ltd; Nolan Transport Retirement Benefit Scheme v Minerva Trust Company Ltd; Michael Thomas Cordwell; Peter James Nicolle; Stephen Andrew Morgan
• Clovis Doreen Collymore v Sandra Marcelle Collymore
• Lemoto v Able Technical Pty Ltd & 2 Ors
• Manek and Others v 360 One Wam Ltd and Others
• Wrexham Association Football Club v Crucialmove Ltd
• Murtland Watterton v Nigel Smith
• Ao Alfa Bank v Kipford Ventures Ltd
• Juliet Rosales v Judy Thomas
• Allied Fort Insurance Services Ltd and Others v Munawar Ahmed and Another (Defendants (but not Appellants) Creation Consumer Finance Ltd (trading as 'Premium First') (Respondent/Claimant)
• Detective Sergeant David Bhagwan v Stephen Corbishley
• Bradley Mckenzie and Joseph Morris v Michael Baker et Al
• Dr Craig Steven Wright v Coinbase Global, Inc.
• Paul Gerard Weston in his capacity as Special Purpose Liquidator of One.Tel Ltd (in Liquidation) v Peter John Macourt
• Andrew William Shaw and Another v Geoffrey Collins Logue
• Martin Coyne and Another v DRC Distribution Ltd and Another

CITED in

• Ex Christmas Islanders Association Inc. v Attorney-General for the Commonwealth (No 2)
• R v Maya Devani
• Kumar v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (No 2)

[See more]

• Kuek
• Modra v State of Victoria
• Dunwell & Dunwell and Ors
• Carpathian Resources Ltd v Hendriks
• Mulugeta Guadie Mengiste and Another v Endowment Fund for the Rehabilitation of Tigray and Others Rylatt Chubb
• Benvinda Aura Nunes Xabregas v Owner's Corporation, SP 79205
• Scuderia Prestige Automobile Ltd v Mr Imran Malik
• TL v A Trust and A K and FMcC
• George Yu v Ping Cao
• Solicitors Regulation Authority Ltd v George Fahim Sa'id
• Jones v Kaney
• Alastair Brett v The Solicitors Regulation Authority
• Hill v Spread Trustee Company Ltd and another
• Manek and Others v 360 One Wam Ltd and Others
• Eric Evans and Others v The Serious Fraud Office

APPLIED in

• Dr Morteza Rajabieslami v Mr Sam Tariverdi
• Katherine Lumsdon and Others v Legal Services Board General Council of the Bar (acting by the Bar Standards Board) and Others (Interested Parties)
• Ernesto Garcia Cancino v Secretary of State for the Home Department

FOLLOWED in

• Konstantin Kagalovsky and Another v Balmore Invest Ltd and Others
• Banks (John and Lynne) v Martin and Gill Geddis - Costs
• Kirsty Williams-Henry (by her mother and litigation friend Christel Williams) v Associated British Ports

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2002] 3 All ER 721
• 27/06/2002 Daily Cases
• [2002] PNLR 43

[See more]

• [28/06/2002] TLR 1
• [2002] 3 WLR 172
• [2003] 1 AC 120

DISTINGUISHED in

• The Persons Identified in Schedule 1 to the Re-Amended Particulars of Claim v Standard Chartered Plc
• Dr Craig Steven Wright v Coinbase Global, Inc.

This document cites

---

• Convenio Europeo para la Protección de los Derechos Humanos y de las Libertades Fundamentales
• Parry-Jones v Law Society
• R v Derby Magistrates' Court, ex parte B
• Byrne v Sefton Health Authority
• Barratt v Ansell (t/a as Woolf Seddon); Arthur JS Hall & Company v Simons



See all quotations

• Lillicrap v Nalder & Son (A Firm)
• Kelly v London Transport Executive
• Orchard v South Eastern Electricity Board
• Associated Leisure Ltd (Phonographic Equipment Company Ltd) v Associated Newspapers Ltd
• Ridehalgh v Horsefield; Watson v Watson (Wasted Costs Orders)
• Actionstrength Ltd (trading as Vital Resources) v International Glass Engineering in.GL.EN SpA and another
• Symphony Group Plc v Hodgson
• Ladd v Marshall
• Worsley v Tambrands Ltd
• General Mediterranean Holdings SA v Patel and Another
• R v Commissioners of Inland Revenue, ex parte Taylor (No. 2)
• Raylee Patricia Harley (Appellant) Robert McDonald (Respondent) Glasgow Harley (Appellant) Robert McDonald (Respondent)
• Oldfield v Keogh
• Brown v Bennett (Wasted Costs) (No. 1)
• Medcalf v Mardell (Wasted Costs Order)
• Myers v Elman
• Supreme Court (now known as Senior Courts) Act 1981
• Courts and Legal Services Act 1990
• Prosecution of Offences Act 1985
• Magistrates' Courts Act 1980