Czarnikow Ltd v Koufos (Heron II)

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Rodocanachi v Milburn
• Horne v Midland Railway Company
• The Parana

[See more]

• Bookham v Potter; Re Rogers
• Hall (R & H.) Ltd v W. H. Pim (Junior) & Company 's Arbitration

REFERS TO

• Cory v The Thames Ironworks & Company
• Hammond & Company v Bussey
• Wertheim v Chicoutimi Pulp Company

[See more]

• Simpson v London and North Western Railway Company
• Hall, - Appellant; Boss, Esq., of Eossie, - Respondent
• Wilson v The Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway Company
• Horne v Midland Railway Company
• Elbinger Actien-Gesellschafft v Armstrong
• Livingstone v Rawyards Coal Company
• Smeed v Foord
• Jensen v Hollis Bros. & Company, Ltd
• British Columbia Saw Mill Company v Nettleship
• S.S. Ardennes (Cargo Owners) v S.S. Ardennes (Owners)
• The Arpad
• Robinson v Harman
• Watts, Watts & Company v Mitsui & Company
• Williams Brothers v Agius (Ed. T.)
• Collard v The South Eastern Railway Company
• Hobbs v London and South Western Railway Company
• Slater v Hoyle & Smith Ltd
• Banco De Portugal v Waterlow and Sons, Ltd (Rrspondents)

DOES NOT FOLLOW

• The Notting Hill
• The Parana

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Czarnikow Ltd v Koufos (Heron II)

APPLIES

• Hadley v Baxendale
• Dunn v Bucknall Brothers ; Dunn v Donald, Currie & Company

CITES

• Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v Miller Steamship Company Pty (Wagon Mound) (No. 2)
• Victoria Laundry (Windsor) v Newman Industries, Coulson & Company
• Overseas Tankship (U.K.) Ltd v Morts Dock and Engineering Company Ltd (The Wagon Mound)

CONSIDERS

• Hall (R & H.) Ltd v W. H. Pim (Junior) & Company 's Arbitration
• Monarch Steamship Company Ltd v Karlshamns Oljefabriker (A/B)

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1967] UKHL J1017-1
• [1967] 2 Lloyd's Rep 457
• [1967] 3 All ER 686

[See more]

• [1969] 1 AC 350
• [1967] 3 WLR 1491

CONSIDERED in

• Michael John Scaven Hitchens and Another v Karl Bacchus
• Barbour Builder Ltd (Appellant (Plaintiff) v Atrium Ltd (Respondent
• Omar Abdulghani Mira (male) and Others v Aylmer Square Investments Ltd and Others

[See more]

• Kuwait Airways Corporation (Plaintiff) v Iraqi Airways Company (body Corporate)
• Barbara Marie Berryman v London Borough of Hounslow
• Marie Georgina McGregor v Genco (FC) Ltd
• Horwood (Claimant) London Regional Transport (Defendant) London Regional Transport (Claimant) Horwood (Defendant)
• Naresh Bathija v Lloyds TSB Bank Plc
• Simkins Partnership v Reeves Lund & Company Ltd
• Charles Einar Anderson v John B. Benson
• Strategic Property Ltd v O'Se and Others
• Derek Leonard Rumsey (Plaintiff) v Owen White & Catlin
• Andre Cayman Islands Trading Company v Stolt Nielsen
• Alan Charles Kemp v Intasun Holidays Ltd
• Hyblewski v Bellerive Homes Pty Ltd
• Findlay v Cantor Index Ltd and Others
• James Jackson and Another v The Royal Bank of Scotland
• William Turner and Jijila Jane Turner v Kwikshift Pty Ltd
• Carr and Another v Fischer and Others
• Oxley County Council v Macdonald and Others; Brambles Holdings Ltd v Macdonald and Others
• National Australia Bank Ltd v Nemur Varity Pty. Ltd
• Stuart Pty Ltd v Condor Commercial Insulation Pty Ltd
• IOOF Building Society Pty Ltd (formerly IOOF Building Society Ltd) (ACN 087 652 104) v Kenneth Taylor and Janet Taylor
• Terry Anne Downie v Gio General Insurance Ltd
• Palasty v Parlby
• Zeng v Leeda Projects Pty Ltd
• Australian Telecommunications Commission v Elmec Pty Ltd and Klaus Queisser
• Rosa & Sons Investments Pty Ltd (Acn 008 645 743) v Frances Stow and Harold Gordon Stow
• Territory Sheet Metal Pty Ltd (ACN 009 634 333) v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ACN 005 357 522)
• Cripps and Another v G & M Dawson Pty Ltd and Another; G & M Dawson Pty Ltd and Another v Cripps and Another
• Philip Walton trading as Pitcher Walton & Company v Efato Pty Ltd
• El Ali v Tritton
• Edwin Davey Pty Ltd v Boulos Holdings Pty Ltd
• Castle Constructions Pty Ltd v Fekala Pty Ltd and Others
• ICAP Australia Pty Ltd v BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd
• Mitsubishi Electric Australia Pty. Ltd v Victorian Workcover Authority
• White v Malco
• Assafiri v The Shell Company of Australia Ltd
• Macrocom v City West
• Ryding v Miles and Others
• Cubic Metre Pty Ltd v C & E Critharis Constructions Pty Ltd
• ACT Land Pty Ltd ((in Liquidation))
• Griffiths as trustee for the Griffiths HWL Practice Trust v Martinez as trustee for the Martinez HWL Practice Trust as representative of the partners trading as HWL Ebsworth Lawyers
• Terrence Stephen Pritchard v Trius Constructions Pty Ltd
• Liggins and Another v Park Trent Properties Group Pty Ltd and Another (No. 2)
• Julie Patricia Edwards v Endeavour Energy
• Boulos Holdings Pty Ltd v Edwin Davey Pty Ltd
• Richardson and Another v McKinnon
• Lori Ann Nelson v Lynette Marie Bellamy
• Connections Total Fitness for the Family Pty Ltd (ACN 134 011 091) v Selkirk Pastoral Company Pty Ltd (ACN 085 917 059)
• Murray v Duddy
• Mulvenna and Royal Bank of Scotl and Plc
• Smith v Ventia Pty Ltd
• Jennifer Cuthbert (Executrix of the Estate of Derek Barry Cuthbert, deceased) v Taylor Woodrow Construction Holdings
• Eian Tauber Pritchard v Peter Cook Red Ltd (Third Party)
• Raphael Wiseman v Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd
• John Grimes Partnership Ltd v Gubbins
• Silvey v Pendragon Plc
• Bence Graphics International Ltd v Fasson UK Ltd
• Maxhaven Healthcare Ltd v Bothma and another (trading as DAB Builders)
• Paros Plc v Worldlink Group Plc
• European Bank Ltd v Robb Evans of Robb Evans & Associates
• Robb Evans of Robb Evans& Associates v European Bank Ltd
• Six Continents Retail Ltd v Hone
• Emma Jane White v Secretary of State for Health and Social Care
• Russell v The Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Archdiocese of Sydney
• New Island Developments Pty Ltd v New Island Investments One Pty Ltd
• Hoho Property Pty Ltd v Bass Finance No 37 Pty Ltd
• Shell Tankers UK Ltd and Another v Jeromson and Another
• Abraham v G Ireson & Son Ltd and Another
• Snell v Beadle
• Do Yay Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v WEI and Lodge Food Ltd
• Northwest Developments Ltd v Zhang, Jung and So
• Borealis AB v Geogas Trading SA
• (1) Richard Conway v Prince Arthur Ikpechukwu Eze
• Hamann v Taleb
• Smith v Owners — Strata Plan No. 3004
• Flynn v PPK Mining Equipment Pty Ltd (No 3)
• Rubenstein v HSBC Bank Plc
• Mrs Gillian Harrison Mr Michael Harrison Mr Nigel Harrison v (1) Technical Sign Company Ltd (First Defendant) (2) Maison Blanc Ltd (Second Defendant) (3) Active Commercial Interiors Ltd (Third Defendant) (4) Cluttons LLP (Fourth Defendant) (5) R&J Building Services Ltd (Fifth Defendant)
• Territory Sheet Metal Pty Ltd (ACN 009 634 333) v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ACN 005 357 522)
• Hunter Area Health Service and Another v Presland
• Essa v Laing Ltd
• Keybridge Capital Ltd v Bell Potter Securities Ltd
• Johnson v Gore Wood & Company (No 2)
• Rubenstein v HSBC Bank Plc
• Currabubula Holdings & Paola Holdings v State Bank of NSW
• Wellesley Partners LLP v Withers LLP
• Lynn Armbrister v Bahamas Supermarkets Ltd
• Rhine Shipping DMCC v Vitol S.A.
• Boys v Chaplin
• Delroy Chandler v Downsound Records Ltd
• Ali v the Guyana Teachers Union
• Grains Jamaica Ltd v The Peppersource Ltd
• Sans Souci Ltd.v VRL Services Ltd
• Walters (Winston) v Jose Cartellone Construcciones Civiles S.A. (No. 2)
• Geotechvision Enterprises Ltd v E-Learning Jamaica Company Ltd
• Devcon Ltd v Cap Juluca Properties Ltd (d/b/a Cap Juluca Resort
• Mister Tee Donuts Ltd v K.R Hunte & Company Ltd et Al
• Maguire v Harland & Wolff Plc
• Mr Brian James Lear v Hickstead Ltd and Another
• Davies v Taylor
• NRMA Ltd and Others v Morgan and Others
• British & Commonwealth Holdings Plc and and Others v British & Commonwealth Holdings Plc and and Others
• Raldon Construction Company Ltd v National Quarries Company Ltd
• Bear Stearns Bank Plc v Forum Global Equity Ltd
• Thake v Maurice
• The Attorney General of the Virgin Islands v Global Water Associates Ltd
• Attia v British Gas Plc
• Parsons (H.) (Livestock) Ltd v Uttley Ingham & Company Ltd
• Waterford Harbour Commissioners v British Railways Board
• London v Collins
• Knightley v Johns

CITED in

• Transworld Oil Ltd v North Bay Shipping Corporation (Rio Claro)
• Mallozzi v Carapelli S.p.a. (Italmotor)
• Israel (Jack L.) Ltd v Ocean Dynamic Lines S.A. (Ocean Dynamic)

[See more]

• Peters (Allan) (Jewellers) Ltd v Brocks Alarms Ltd
• Darmody v National Centre Automotive
• Glencore Grain Ltd v Goldbeam Shipping Inc.; Goldbeam Shipping Inc. Navios International Inc. (MV 'Mass Glory') [QBD (Comm)]
• Brown v Kmr Services Ltd Sword Daniels v Pitel and Others
• Skeggs v Lloyds Bank Plc (executors of the estate of Brian Woodrow deceased); British Credit Trust Ltd v Skeggs
• Kenny & Good Pty Ltd v Mgica (1992) Ltd
• Wilson v Citibank International Plc
• LOUIS DREYFUS TRADING Ltd v RELIANCE TRADING Ltd
• Farley v Skinner
• Malyon v Lawrence Messer and Company
• Brown v Services Ltd (formerly H G Poland (Agencies) Ltd)
• Fyffes Group Ltd v Reefer Express Lines Pty. Ltd (Kriti R)
• Stinnes Interoil G.m.b.H. v A. Halcoussis & Company (No. 2) (Yanxilas)
• Aruna Mills Ltd v Dhanrajmal Gobindram
• Hill (Christopher) Ltd v Ashington Piggeries Ltd (Description)
• Andre Cayman Islands Trading Company v Stolt Nielsen BV ('The Sun Sapphire') [QBD (Comm)]
• Mowlem Plc v Phi Group Ltd
• International Bulk Carriers (Beirut) S.A.R.L. v Evlogia Shipping Company S.A. (Mihalios Xilas)
• North Sea Energy Holdings N.v v Petroleum Authority of Thailand
• Compania Financiera "Soleada" SA v Hamoor Tanker Corporation Inc. ; The Borag
• Blackgold Trading Ltd of Monrovia v Almare S.p.A. di Navigazione of Genoa (Almare Quinta, Almare Seconda)
• Islamic Republic of Iran Shipping Lines v Ierax Shipping Company of Panama (Forum Craftsman)
• British & Commonwealth Holdings Plc v Quadrex Holdings Inc.
• New South Wales v Fahy (266)
• Papera Traders Company Ltd v Hyundai Merchant Marine Company Ltd (No 2)
• Robertson Quay Investment Pte Ltd v Steen Consultants Pte Ltd and Another
• MFM Restaurants Pte Ltd and Another v Fish & Company Restaurants Pte Ltd (FKAOB Singapore Operations Pte Ltd); and other appeals
• Yamashita Shinnihon Steamship Company Ltd v Elios S.p.A. (Lily Prima)
• Jennifer Cuthbert (Executrix of the Estate of Derek Barry Cuthbert, deceased) v Taylor Woodrow Construction Holdings
• Australian Coastal Shipping Commission v Green
• O'Brien v White-Spunner
• Siemens Building Technologies FE Ltd v Supershield Ltd
• Pacific Basin Ihx Ltd v Bulkhandling Handymax as
• London Trocadero (2015) LLP v Henry Anthony Shinners
• Greenwich Millennium Village Ltd v Essex Services Group Plc (formerly Known as Essex Electrical Group Ltd) (1st Defendant/Part 20 Claimant) Hs Environmental Services Ltd ((in Administration)) (3rd Party) W T Partnership Ltd (4th Party) Hoare Lea (A Firm)(5th Party/2nd Defendant) D G Robson Mechanical Services Ltd (6th Party)
• Bates and Others v Robert Barrow Ltd and Others, Ansell and Others v Same
• Brown v K.M.R Services Ltd
• Satef-Huttenes Albertus S.p.A. v Paloma Tercera Shipping Company S.A. (Pegase)
• Sylvia Shipping Company Ltd v Progress Bulk Bonding Ltd
• Justin Burke v The College of Law and Another
• Tor Line A.B. v Alltrans Group of Canada Ltd (TFL Prosperity)
• Seven Seas Transportation Ltd v Pacifico Union Marina Corporation (Oceanic Amity, Satya Kailash)
• John Yapp v Foreign and Commonwealth Office
• Aneco Reinsurance Underwriting Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Johnson & Higgins Ltd
• Lambert v Lewis
• King v Victor Parsons & Company
• Hi-Lite Electrical Ltd v Wolseley Uk Ltd Dab Pumps Spa (Third Party)
• Mohamed Ali v Guyana Teachers' Union
• Figureido v Laws
• Curtis-Thomas v Bermuda Hospitals Board and Chiappa
• Figureido v Laws
• McFarlane v Wilkinson and Another ; Hegarty v E E Caledonia Ltd
• Balfour Beatty Construction (Scotland) Ltd v Scottish Power Plc
• G.K.N. Centrax Gears Ltd v Matbro Ltd
• Jayesh Shah and Another v HSBC Private Bank (UK) Ltd
• Petrochemical Industries Company (K.S.C) v The Dow Chemical Company
• Henry Kendall & Sons (A Firm) v William Lillico & Sons Ltd and Others
• Geogas S.A. v Trammo Gas Ltd (Baleares)
• Philmore Davis Claimant v Martinus Jn Phillip Joan Jn Phillip Defendants [ECSC]
• Ennia General Insurance Company Ltd Appellant v J. Astaphan & Company (1970) Ltd Respondent [ECSC]
• Transfield Shipping Inc. v Mercator Shipping Inc. (The Achilleas)
• Transfield Shipping Inc. v Mercator Shipping Inc. (The Achilleas)
• Transfield Shipping Inc. v Mercator Shipping Inc. (The Achilleas)
• Yapp v Foreign and Commonwealth Office
• Saatchi & Saatchi Pte Ltd and Others v Tan Hun Ling (Clarke Quay Pte Ltd, Third Party)
• Jackson and another v Royal Bank of Scotland Plc
• Wellesley Partners Llp v Withers Llp
• Db v Dlj
• ARB v Ivf Hammersmith Ltd R (Third Party)
• Hill (Christopher) Ltd v Ashington Piggeries Ltd (Description)
• Farley v Skinner (No 2)
• Sempra Metals (formerly Metallgesellschaft Ltd) v Commissioners of Inland Revenue
• Hill (Christopher) Ltd v Ashington Piggeries Ltd (Description)

REFERRED in

• Consort Express Lines Ltd v J-Mac Pty Ltd (No 2)
• Roger Leggett and 42 Others v Giambrone Law LLP ((in Liquidation))
• Transfield Shipping Inc. of Panama v Mercator Shipping Inc. of Monrovia (The Achilleas)

[See more]

• Jackson v Royal Bank of Scotland
• Total Transport Corporation v Arcadia Petroleum Ltd
• Pacific Basin IHX Ltd v Bulkhandling Handymax as [QBD (Comm)]
• Unique Dimension Sdn Bhd v Secure Parking Corporation Sdn Bhd
• Datuk Eric Taylor; Lim Foo Yong & Sons Realty Sdn Bhd
• Datuk Eric Taylor v Lim Foo Yong & Sons Realty Sdn Bhd
• Critical System Specialist Sdn Bhd v CLLS Power System Sdn Bhd
• Trade Mode Sdn Bhd v AC Property Development Sdn Bhd
• Milicent Rosalind Danker v Malaysia-Europe Forum Bhd
• Pharmmalaysia Bhd v Dinesh Kumar Jashbhai Nagjibha Patel
• Bank Pertanian Malaysia Berhad v Koperasi Permodalan Melayu Negeri Johor
• Goo Sing Kar v Dato' Lim Ah Chap
• Lee Tiow Kee and Another v Ng Geok Hwa
• Associated Pan Malaysia Cement Sdn Bhd v Syarikat Teknikal & Kejuruteraan Sdn Bhd
• Projek Lebuh Raya Utara-Selatan Sdn Bhd v Kim Seng Enterprise (Kedah) Sdn Bhd
• Tan Sri Khoo Teck Puat v Plenitude Holdings Sdn Bhd, SC
• Orchard Plaza Management Company Ltd v Balfour Beatty Regional Construction Ltd
• Prakash Industries Ltd v Peter Beck Und Partner
• Attorney General of the Virgin Islands v Global Water Associates Ltd (British Virgin Islands)
• Mitsui & Company (USA) Inc. v Asia-Potash International Investment (Guangzhou) Company Ltd
• DENNEY v HODGE and TANGUY [CA (Jersey)]
• Sprint Electric Ltd v Buyer's Dream Ltd
• Adrian Rubenstein v Hsbc Bank Plc
• 125 OBS (Nominees1) and Another v Lend Lease Construction (Europe) Ltd and Another
• Hughes-Holland v BPE Solicitors and another
• Out of the Box Pte Ltd v Wanin Industries Pte Ltd
• Euro-Asian Oil SA (formerly Euro-Asian Oil AG) v Credit Suisse AG
• Sagicor Bank Jamaica Ltd v YP Seaton and Others

APPLIED in

• Gec Marconi Systems Pty Ltd v Bhp Information Technology Pty Ltd
• Lehman Brothers Finance AG ((in Liquidation)) v Klaus Tschira Stiftung GmbH

FOLLOWED in

• Koh Siak Poo v Med-Bumikar Mara Sdn Bhd
• Popular Industries Ltd v The Eastern Garment Manufacturing Company Sdn Bhd,

RELIED UPON in

• Knights and Others v Townsend Harrison Ltd

This document cites

---

• Monarch Steamship Company Ltd v Karlshamns Oljefabriker (A/B)
• Banco De Portugal v Waterlow and Sons, Ltd (Rrspondents)
• Hall (R & H.) Ltd v W. H. Pim (Junior) & Company 's Arbitration
• Livingstone v Rawyards Coal Company
• The Notting Hill



See all quotations

• Simpson v London and North Western Railway Company
• Elbinger Actien-Gesellschafft v Armstrong
• Cory v The Thames Ironworks & Company
• Robinson v Harman
• Collard v The South Eastern Railway Company
• Hadley v Baxendale
• Hall (R & H.) Ltd v W. H. Pim (Junior) & Company 's Arbitration
• Hobbs v London and South Western Railway Company
• Smeed v Foord
• Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v Miller Steamship Company Pty (Wagon Mound) (No. 2)
• Watts, Watts & Company v Mitsui & Company
• Williams Brothers v Agius (Ed. T.)
• Horne v Midland Railway Company
• Jensen v Hollis Bros. & Company, Ltd
• Hall, - Appellant; Boss, Esq., of Eossie, - Respondent
• S.S. Ardennes (Cargo Owners) v S.S. Ardennes (Owners)
• The Parana
• Bookham v Potter; Re Rogers
• Wertheim v Chicoutimi Pulp Company
• British Columbia Saw Mill Company v Nettleship
• The Parana
• Rodocanachi v Milburn
• The Arpad
• Dunn v Bucknall Brothers ; Dunn v Donald, Currie & Company
• Slater v Hoyle & Smith Ltd
• Victoria Laundry (Windsor) v Newman Industries, Coulson & Company
• Wilson v The Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway Company
• Horne v Midland Railway Company
• Overseas Tankship (U.K.) Ltd v Morts Dock and Engineering Company Ltd (The Wagon Mound)
• Hammond & Company v Bussey