Addie (Robert) and Sons (Collieries) Ltd v Dumbreck

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Coffee v McEvoy and Another
• Cooke v Midland Great Western Railway Company of Ireland

REFERS TO

• Coffee v McEvoy and Another
• Thompson v North British Railway Company
• Mackenzie v Fairfield Shipbuilding and Engineering Company, Ltd

[See more]

• Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada v Barnett
• Cummings v Darngavil Coal Company, Ltd
• Latham v Johnson (R) & Nephew
• Devlin v Jeffray's Trustees
• Boyd v Glassgow Iron and Steel Company
• Holland v Lanarkshire Middle Ward District Committee
• Haughton v North British Railway Company
• Reilly v Greenfield Coal & Brick Company, Ltd

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Addie (Robert) and Sons (Collieries) Ltd v Dumbreck

APPROVES

• Hardy v Central London Ry. Company

REVERSES

• Addie (Robert) and Sons (Collieries) Ltd v Dumbreck

DISTINGUISHES

• Cooke v Midland Great Western Railway Company of Ireland
• Lowery v Walker

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1929] UKHL J0225-2
• 45 TLR 267
• 1929 SC HL 51

[See more]

• 45 TLR 267
• 1929 SC HL 51
• [1929] AC 358

CONSIDERED in

• Elizabeth Shitk Cunningham (suing as Widow and Administratrix of Alexander Cunningham deceased) v The Mayor, Aldermen and Burgesses of Workington
• Southern Portland Cement Ltd v Cooper
• Kirton v Rogers

[See more]

• Commissioner for Railways (Nsw) v Cardy
• Munnings v Hydro-Electric Commission
• Penny and Ors. (Appellants - Plaintiffs) v The Mayor, Aldermen and Burgesses of the County Borough of Northampton (Respondents - Defondants)
• Symonette v The Bahamas Hotel Catering & Allied Workers Union
• Brigitta Seymour, Kendra Seymour, Jeanne Swann v Karen G. Rigby
• Miller v South of Scotland Electricity Board
• McGlone v British Railways Board
• Glasgow Corporation v Muir
• Re Oliver, inquest into death of Ojo Moyo
• Minors v Simon et Al
• Kirton v Rogers
• Royal Dublin Society v Yates
• Alcan Jamaica and Universal Fencing Ltd v Nicholson
• Lucayen Country Clubs Ltd v Eavre
• British Railways Board v Herrington
• Tomlinson v Congleton Borough Council and another
• Donoghue v Folkestone Properties Ltd
• Ratcliff v McConnell
• British Railways Board v Herrington
• Neezam Mohammed v Samdai Sooknanan
• Monique James-Roberts v ABI Insurance Company Ltd et Al
• Walsh v Kilkenny County Council
• Effie Jane Sherman Wallis v Winton Wellington Roberts
• Montague Investments Ltd v Westminster College Ltd
• The People (Director of Public Prosecutions) v J.C.

CITED in

• Hawkins v Thames Stevedore Company and Union Cold Storage Company
• Gould v McAuliffe
• London Graving Dock Company Ltd v Horton

[See more]

• Pearson v Lambeth Borough Council
• Rich v Commissioner for Railways (Nsw)
• Public Transport Commission (Nsw) v Perry
• Bint v Lewisham Borough Council
• Horton v London Graving Dock Company, Ltd
• Liddle v Yorkshire (North Riding) County Council
• Donovan v Union Cartage Company
• Jennings v Ellerman's Wilson Line, Ltd
• Transport Commissioners Ofnew South Wales v Barton
• Weigall v Westminster Hospital
• Campbell v Shelbourne Hotel Ltd
• Salisbury v Blue Star Line, Ltd
• London Graving Dock Company Ltd v Horton
• Minors v Simon and Douglas
• See Toh Siew Kee v Ho Ah Lam Ferrocement (Pte) Ltd and others
• Breslin v Brennan
• Leanne Colette Mary Burke and Southern Education and Library Board and N K Fencing Limited
• Haseldine v Daw & Son Ltd
• Anthony Martin v Eric Bucknor and Another
• Smith v Central Asbestos Company Ltd
• London Graving Dock Company Ltd v Horton
• Donovan v Landy's Ltd
• Edwards v Railway Executive

REFERRED in

• Sutton v Bootle Corporation
• Williams v Cardiff Corporation
• Adams v Naylor

[See more]

• Thompson v Bankstown Corporation
• Watson v George
• Schiller v Mulgrave Shire Council
• Ellis v Fulham Borough Council
• Davis v St. Mary's Demolition Company Ltd
• Phipps v Rochester Corporation
• Mourton v Poulter
• Lipman v Clendinnen
• Rokayah Haji Abdul Rahman v Abdul Rahman bin Abu Bakar
• Metroplex Development Sdn Bhd v Mohd Mastana bin Makaddas and Another
• Mohd Hero v Yap Weng Ken and Another (Besraya (M) Sdn Bhd and Another - Third Parties)
• Bukit Lenang Development Sdn Bhd v Penduduk-penduduk Yang Menduduki Atas Tanah HS(D)151079 û HS(D)151601, Mukim Plentong, Daerah Johor Bahru
• Kajima-Taisei Joint Venture; Yeap Cheng Hock
• Boylan v.Dublin Corporation
• Hawkins v Coulsdon and Purley Urban District Council
• James Pannett (an Infant) by his father and next friend James Pannett (Plaintiff Respondent) P. Mcguinness & Company, Ltd (Defendants Appellants)
• Braithwaite v South Durham Steel Company Ltd
• Ivan O'Neal Claimant v Cable & Wireless (WI) Ltd Bernard Mascoll Defendants [ECSC]
• Khoo Ting Hong and Another v Sim Guan Soon and Another
• Harris v Birkenhead Corporation
• Videan v British Transport Commission
• Revill v Newberry
• Swift v Westport Urban District Council
• Fitzleet Estates Ltd v Cherry
• White v Blackmore
• Randall v Tarrant
• Broome v Cassell & Company Ltd
• President of India v La Pintada Compania Navigacion S.A. (La Pintada)

FOLLOWED in

• Southern Portland Cement Ltd v Cooper
• Segar Restu (M) Sdn Bhd v Wong Kai Chuan and Another
• Malayan Railway Administration; Tan Lian Chye

[See more]

• Tan Lian Chye v Malayan Railway Administration

APPLIED in

• Perry v Thomas Wrigley Ltd
• Commissioner for Railways v Quinlan

DISTINGUISHED in

• Buckland v Guildford Gas Light and Coke Company

NOT APPLIED in

• McNamara v Electricity Supply Board

This document cites

---

• Mackenzie v Fairfield Shipbuilding and Engineering Company, Ltd
• Cummings v Darngavil Coal Company, Ltd
• Boyd v Glassgow Iron and Steel Company
• Thompson v North British Railway Company
• Lowery v Walker



See all quotations

• Haughton v North British Railway Company
• Holland v Lanarkshire Middle Ward District Committee
• Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada v Barnett
• Addie (Robert) and Sons (Collieries) Ltd v Dumbreck
• Latham v Johnson (R) & Nephew
• Devlin v Jeffray's Trustees
• Hardy v Central London Ry. Company
• Reilly v Greenfield Coal & Brick Company, Ltd
• Cooke v Midland Great Western Railway Company of Ireland
• Coffee v McEvoy and Another
• Coffee v McEvoy and Another
• Cooke v Midland Great Western Railway Company of Ireland