Westminster City Council v Great Portland Estates Plc

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Newbury District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment
• East Barnet Urban District Council v British Transport Commission

REFERS TO

• Westminster City Council v British Waterways Board

APPLIES

• Newbury District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment
• East Barnet Urban District Council v British Transport Commission

APPROVES

• Re Poyser and Mills' Arbitration
• Bradley (Edwin H.) and Sons Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment

CONSIDERS

• Town and Country Planning Act 1971 - Articles : SCH-4
• Town and Country Planning (Local Plans for Greater London) Regulations 1974
• Town and Country Planning Act 1971 - Articles : S-244

[See more]

• Town and Country Planning (Amendment) Act 1972 - Articles : S-4
• Landlord and Tenant Act 1954

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1984] UKHL J1031-2
• [1985] AC 661
• [1984] 3 All ER 744

[See more]

• [1984] 3 WLR 1035
• [1985] AC 661

CITED in

• R Midcounties Co-operative Ltd v Swindon Borough Council Optimisation Developments Ltd (Interested Party)
• David Pearl v Maldon District Council
• F H Cummings v Weymouth & Portland Borough Council

[See more]

• Persimmon Homes (North East) Ltd v Newcastle City Council Bellway Homes Ltd (First Interested Party) Commercial Estates Group Ltd (Second Interested Party)
• The Welsh Ministers and Others v Davies
• R Swire v Canterbury City Council
• R Miller Homes Ltd v Leeds City Council
• R (Copeland) v Tower Hamlets London Borough Council
• McLean Bookmakers and North West Bookmakers’ Applications
• Dawn Developments Limited Against A Decision Of The Scottish Ministers
• In An Appeal Under Section 238 Of The Town And Country Planning (scotland) Act 1997 By The Cairngorms Campaign And Others
• Rooff Ltd v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and another
• Minister of the Environment v Barber and Scarborough Property Holdings Ltd 1994 Civil Appeal No. 23, Scarborough Property Holdings Ltd v Minister of the Environment and Barber 1994 Civil Appeal No. 26
• Kingston and St. Andrew Corporation v Ian Folkes, Collette Allegro Folkes & Andrew Willis
• Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council v Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities
• R (Cala Homes (South) Ltd) v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and another
• M.E.O. (Nigeria) v The International Protection Appeals Tribunal ; U.O. (Nigeria) v The International Protection Appeals Tribunal
• Desmond Mulholland and Donal Kinsella v an Bord Pleanála (No. 2)
• Virgin Islands Environmental Council v Attorney General

REFERRED in

• Edward Ware Homes Ltd v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government (First Defendant) Bath and North Somerset Council (Second Defendant)
• New Dawn Homes Ltd v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government (First Defendant) Tewksbury Borough Council (Second Defendant)
• Stephenson v Secretary of State for the Environment

[See more]

• Berkeley v Secretary of State for the Environment and Another (No. 2)
• Powys County Council v The Welsh Ministers (First Defendant) Res Uk & Ireland Ltd (Second Defendant)
• Watson v Essex County Council
• Timothy Steer v Shepway District Council
• The Noble Organisation Ltd v (1) Secretary of State for Transport, Local Government and The Regions (2) DARTFORD Borough Council
• Secondsite Property Holdings Ltd v Borough of Poole
• Forest of Dean District Council and Another v R Peter Wright
• Ayres, R v Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and Local Regions and Another
• Khaw Lay Eong v Majlis Perbandaran Pulau Pinang
• R John Hudson v Royal Borough of Windsor and Maidenhead
• In the matter of an application for Judicial Review by Bow Street Mall & Others
• New Forest District Council (Claimant) Mr Eric Owen and Another (Defendants HQ12X02365) (3) Mr Stephen Malem (Defendant HQ12X02423) (4) Mr Mark Greenshields and Another (Defendants HQ12X02424)
• The King (on the application of Transport Action Network Ltd) v Secretary of State for Transport
• Zipporah Lisle-Mainwaring v Niall Carroll
• Gemma Watton v The Cornwall Council
• The Queen (on the application of Scottishpower Energy Retail Ltd) v The Gas and Electricity Markets Authority
• Corporation of Hamilton v Minister of Environment, Planning and Natural Resources and Billings
• Thurrock Council v Martin Stokes
• Y.Y. v The Minister for Justice and Equality No.7
• Thomas Grealish v an Bord Pleanála
• R Neil Richard Spurrier v The Secretary of State for Transport
• Wheeler v JJ Saunders Ltd
• Development Control Authority v Rayneau Gajadhar
• Dover District Council v CPRE Kent
• R v Westminster City Council, ex parte Ermakov
• R Peter Day v Shropshire Council
• Transdev Ireland Ltd v Caplis
• R v Yorkshire Regional Health Authority, ex parte Baker
• R (on the application of Wright) v Resilient Energy Severndale Ltd and Forest of Dean District Council
• R (on the application of Holborn Studios Ltd) v The Council of the London Borough of Hackney GHL (Eagle Wharf Road) Ltd (Interested Party)
• Save Britain's Heritage v Number 1 Poultry Ltd

CONSIDERED in

• The Inner London Education Authority v The Secretary of State for the Environment and Another Eight Related Appeals
• Anscomb v Secretary of State for Transport and Another
• Blue Circle Industries Plc v West Midlands County Council (Acquiring Authority)

[See more]

• Coal Contractors Ltd (Applicants) The Secretary of State for the Environment (First Respondent) Northumberland County Council (Second Respondent)
• Greater London Council (Applicant (Appellant), ) The Secretary of State for the Environment (First Respondent (Respondent) London Docklands Development Corporation (Second Respondent (Respondent) Cablecross Projects Ltd (Third Respondent(Respondent)
• R v Vale of Glamorgan Borough Council and Associated British Ports ex parte James
• Welsh Development Agency v Carmarthenshire County Council
• Charles John Cadogan v The Secretary of State for The Environment and Others
• Leslie Isadore Don and Benita Don (t/a as Northern Markets) The Secretary of State for the Environment Manchester City Council
• Black Country Development Corporation Sandwell Mbc The Secretary of State for the Environment and Another Sandwell MBC and the Secretary of State for the Environment
• R McCarthy and Stone Retirement Lifestyles Ltd v The Mayor of London on Behalf of the Greater London Authority
• R v Vale of Glamorgan Dc and Another
• James Douglas Stewart v The Secretary of State for The Environment and Another
• K. Vasiliou v Secretary of State for Transport and Another
• Mobasim Ali (Applicant Mashuk Miah (Applicant Abdul Monaf (Applicant v London Borough of Tower Hamlets (Respondent
• Mobil Oil Company Ltd v The Secretary of State for the Environment and Others
• Edwin Alan Woodfield v The Secretary of State for the Environment
• Test Valley Borough Council v Hampshire County Council and Others
• Vasilou v Secretary of State for Transport and Ladbroke City and Country Land Company
• Christchurch Borough Council v The Secretary of State for the Environment and Others
• Western Aggregates v The Hereford and Worcester County Council
• West Midlands Probation Committee v Secretary of State for the Environment and Another
• Mjt Securities Ltd v Secretary of State for The Environment
• WILLIAM MONTAGUE SWAN v (1) THE SECRETARY of STATE for THE ENVIRONMENT (2) RHYS EVANS and Others
• Centre 21 Ltd and Another (Applicant/ v The Secretary of State for The Environment and Another (Respondents/
• Gilbert Stirk and Others v Bridgnorth District Council
• Alfred McAlpine Homes (North) Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment and Another
• Rupert Michael Stephenson v The Secretary of State for the Environment (First Respondent) The Council of the Borough of St. Edmundsbury (Second Respondent)
• Guildford Borough Council v Secretary of State for the Environment and Another
• Terry Adams Ltd and The Secretary of State for The Environment and Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council
• Burgars' Application for and Others
• The Queen v Monopolies and Mergers Commission and and Another
• Blue Circle Industries Plc v Secretary of State for Wales Cardiff-Wales Airport
• Miller and Others v Wycombe District Council (Appellent)
• R J A Pye (Oxford)Ltd Bellway Homes Ltd and The Housebuilders Federation and Oxford City Council
• R v (1) The Parole Board (2) The Secretary of State for the Home Department and Another
• Basil Peter Tyler v Avon County Council David William Shopland Avon County Council
• Alfred Mcalpine Homes (North) Ltd v Secretary of State for Environment
• Proudfoot Properties v The Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and Another
• R v Vale of Glamorgan DC and Another
• Application in Jerry
• Michael Kingsley The Secretary of State for The Environment, and Another Cheshire County Council
• R (Grant-Nicholas) v Bromsgrove District Council
• Basil Peter Tyler v Avon County Council
• The Queen The Planning (listed and Others v The Secretary of State for The and Others
• Coal Contractors Ltd (Applicants) The Secretary of State for the Environment (First Respondent) Northumberland County Council (Second Respondent)
• Leser Landau (Appellant .) v The Secretary of State for The Environment and Others (Respondents (First Respondents) (4) The Tyne and Wear Development Corporation (Respondents (Second Respondents) (5) Newcastle Quayside Developments Plc
• David John Webb Secretary of State for the Environment Salisbury District Council
• R v North Yorkshire Family Health Service Authority ex parte Dr George Malcolm James White
• R (D'Cunha) v The Parole Board
• John Davies v Welsh Ministers and Others
• R (Sainsbury's Supermarkets Ltd) v First Secretary of State
• Menteri Sumber Manusia and Another v Association of Bank Officers, Peninsular Malaysia
• Sugumar Balakrishnan v Pengarah Imigresen Negeri Sabah and Another
• Bolton Metropolitan District Council & Others v Secretary of State for the Environment & Others
• Masu Financial Management P/L v FICS and Julie Wong (No 2)
• British Coal Corporation v Gwent County Council
• Save Britain's Heritage v The Secretary of State for The Environment and Others
• South Buckinghamshire District Council v Porter (No 2)
• R (Derwent Holdings Ltd) v Trafford Borough Council
• The Queen (on the application of Peter Wright) v Forest of Dean District Council Resilient Energy Severndale Ltd (Interested Party)
• North Wiltshire District Council v The Secretary of State for The Environment and Another
• Malahide Community Council Ltd v Fingal County Council
• Gateshead MBC v Northumbrian Water Group Plc
• R v Westminster City Council, ex parte Monahan
• 1) Simplex G.E. (Holdings) Ltd and Another (Plaintiffs) Appellants) v 1) The Secretary of State for the Environment and Another Respondents)
• Good Energy Generation Ltd v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
• Uprichard v Scottish Ministers
• Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and another v Welwyn Hatfield Council
• Blackstone v Minister for Planning and Environment
• London Borough of Lambeth v Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities
• R Paul Rogers v Wycombe District Council Jonathan Smare (Interested Party)
• Gateshead Metropolitan Borough Council v Secretary of State for the Environment (First Respondent)
• The Queen (on the application of Scottishpower Energy Retail Ltd) v The Gas and Electricity Markets Authority
• KEANE & NAUGHTON v Bord Pleanála & COMMISSIONERS of IRISH LIGHTS
• The King (on the application of Cindy Jones) v Cornwall Council
• Re Niles (No 2)
• The Public Service Union v Permanent Secretary of Ministry of National Security
• R Frack Free Balcombe Residents Association v West Sussex County Council
• The King (on the application of Chala Alice Fiske) v Test Valley Borough Council
• Michael Douglas Trollope Loup and Ors v Secretary of State for the Environment and Salisbury District Council
• Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council v Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities
• Rika Shasha, Toni Shasha and Rownamoor Trustees Ltd as Trustees of the Placement Pension Fund v Westminster City Council Portman Mansions Residents Company Ltd (Interested Party)
• Re Errol E. Niles (No.2)
• The Queen(on the application of Oletunde Adetoro) v Secretary of State for Justice
• Orange Communications v Director of Telecommunications Regulation & Meteor Mobile Communications Ltd
• Kingston and St. Andrew Corporation v Folkes et Al
• The Public Service Union v Permanent Secretary of Ministry of National Security
• Tosl Engineering Ltd v Minister of Labour and Small Micro Enterprise Development
• Transdev Ireland Ltd v Caplis
• R v London Borough of Islington ex parte Gerald Hinds
• Brentwood Borough Council v Ball & Others
• South Buckinghamshire DC v Porter (No 1)

FOLLOWED in

• Majlis Perbandaran Pulau Pinang v Syarikat Bekerjasama-sama Serbaguna Sungai Gelugor Dengan Tanggungan
• R Rama Chandran v Industrial Court of Malaysia and Another

APPLIED in

• South Bucks District Council v Secretary of State for Transport, Local Government and the Regions and another

This document cites

---

• Westminster City Council v British Waterways Board
• Newbury District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment
• Newbury District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment
• East Barnet Urban District Council v British Transport Commission
• East Barnet Urban District Council v British Transport Commission



See all quotations

• Bradley (Edwin H.) and Sons Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment
• Re Poyser and Mills' Arbitration
• Landlord and Tenant Act 1954
• Town and Country Planning (Amendment) Act 1972
• Town and Country Planning Act 1971
• Town and Country Planning (Local Plans for Greater London) Regulations 1974