Vestwin Trading Pte Ltd and Another v Obegi Melissa and Others

Core Citations

---

DISTINGUISHES

• Malone v Metropolitan Police Commissioner

REFERS TO

• Attorney General v Guardian Newspapers Ltd and Others (No. 2)
• Cascade Shipping Inc. v Eka Jaya Agencies (S) Pte Ltd
• Pollard v Photographic Company

[See more]

• Susan Thomas v Elizabeth Pearce and Another
• Tipping v Clarke
• Tan Chor Thing v Tokyo Investment Pte Ltd and Another
• Cray Valley Ltd v Deltech Europe Ltd
• English and American Insurance Company Ltd v Herbert Smith
• Francome v Mirror Group Newspapers Ltd
• Hellewell v Chief Constable of Derbyshire
• Erskine Communications Ltd and Another v Worthington and Others
• Between His Royal Highness Prince Albert, Plaintiff; and William Strange, Jasper Tomsett Judge, Jasper A. F. Judge, and HM Attorney General, Defendants

CONSIDERS

• Hadley v Baxendale
• Stroms Bruk Aktie Bolag v John and Peter Hutchison (A Firm)
• Ashburton (Lord) v Pape

[See more]

• Re Simms. ex parte Trustee
• British Transport Commission v Gourley
• Duchess of Argyll v Duke of Argyll
• Goddard v Nationwide Building Society
• Stephens v Avery
• Douglas v Hello! Ltd (No 1)

CITES

• Malone v Metropolitan Police Commissioner
• Attorney General v Guardian Newspapers Ltd and Others (No. 2)

FOLLOWS

• Williams v Phillips
• X Pte Ltd and Another v CDE
• Coco v an Clark (Engineers) Ltd

REFERRED in

• Geh Thuan Hooi v Serene Lim Paik Yan and Others

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2006] SGHC 107
• [2006] 3 SLR 573
• [2007] 2 LRC 154

FOLLOWED in

• QB Net Company Ltd v Earnson Management (S) Pte Ltd and Others

APPEAL RESOLVED in

• Vestwin Trading Pte Ltd and Another v Obegi Melissa and Others

REVERSED in

• Vestwin Trading Pte Ltd and Another v Obegi Melissa and Others

This document cites

---

• British Transport Commission v Gourley
• Douglas v Hello! Ltd (No 1)
• Malone v Metropolitan Police Commissioner
• Cray Valley Ltd v Deltech Europe Ltd
• Francome v Mirror Group Newspapers Ltd



See all quotations

• Goddard v Nationwide Building Society
• Attorney General v Guardian Newspapers Ltd and Others (No. 2)
• Attorney General v Guardian Newspapers Ltd and Others (No. 2)
• Attorney General v Strange and Others
• Re Simms. ex parte Trustee
• Tipping v Clarke
• Between His Royal Highness Prince Albert, Plaintiff; and William Strange, Jasper Tomsett Judge, Jasper A. F. Judge, and HM Attorney General, Defendants
• Pollard v Photographic Company
• Ward v Smith
• Hadley v Baxendale
• English and American Insurance Company Ltd v Herbert Smith
• Ashburton (Lord) v Pape
• Moon and Another, Assignees of Fisher, a Bankrupt, v Raphael and Another
• Williams v Phillips
• Stroms Bruk Aktie Bolag v John and Peter Hutchison (A Firm)
• Malone v Metropolitan Police Commissioner
• Stephens v Avery
• Duchess of Argyll v Duke of Argyll
• Erskine Communications Ltd and Another v Worthington and Others
• Coco v an Clark (Engineers) Ltd
• Susan Thomas v Elizabeth Pearce and Another
• Hellewell v Chief Constable of Derbyshire
• Smith Kline & French Laboratories (Australia) Ltd and Others v Secretary, Department of Community Services and Health ; Smith Kline & French Laboratories (Australia) Ltd and Others v Secretary, Department of Community Services and Health and Another
• X Pte Ltd and Another v CDE
• Cascade Shipping Inc. v Eka Jaya Agencies (S) Pte Ltd
• Tan Chor Thing v Tokyo Investment Pte Ltd and Another