Trollope & Colls Ltd v North West Metropolitan Regional Hospital Board

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Luxor (Eastbourne) Ltd v Cooper
• Whitworth Street Estates (Manchester) Ltd v James Miller and Partners Ltd
• R v The Inhabitants of Buckingham

REFERS TO

• Luxor (Eastbourne) Ltd v Cooper
• Reigate v Union Manufacturing Company (Ramsbottom) Ltd
• Whitworth Street Estates (Manchester) Ltd v James Miller and Partners Ltd

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Trollope & Colls Ltd v North West Metropolitan Regional Hospital Board

CONSIDERS

• Dodd v Churton

DISTINGUISHES

• Bickerton (T A.) & Son Ltd v North West Metropolitan Regional Hospital Board
• Nelson v Dahl

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1973] UKHL J0410-2
• [1973] 2 All ER 260
• 9 Build LR 60

[See more]

• [1973] 1 WLR 601

REFERRED in

• Integrated Container Service Inc. v British Traders Insurance Company Ltd
• Astilleros Canarios S.A. v Cape Hatteras Shipping Company Inc. (Cape Hatteras)
• Richard Ellis v Pipe-Chem (Holdings) Ltd

[See more]

• Southern Water Authority v Carey
• St. Albans City and District Council v International Computers Ltd
• Chaffe v Kingsley
• Gladman Commercial Properties v Fisher Hargreaves Proctor and Others
• Rutherford v Seymour Pierce Ltd
• Fyffes Group Ltd v Reefer Express Lines Pty. Ltd (Kriti R)
• Decoma UK Ltd v Haden Drsys International Ltd
• Walter Lilly & Company Ltd v Jean Francois Clin
• Nigel Witham Ltd v (1) Mrrobert Leslie Smith (2) Miss Jacqueline Isaacs
• Guthrie Landscaping Sdn Bhd v Hasrat Usaha Sdn Bhd
• Chong Yoon Huat v Tokio Marine Life Insurance (Malaysia) Bhd
• Juang Setia Sdn Bhd v Tindak Murni Sdn Bhd
• Richallenge Corporation Sdn Bhd v Poteck Enterprise Sdn Bhd
• Mech-Power Generators Pte Ltd v MMC Engineering & Construction Sdn Bhd and Another
• Oriental Bank Berhad v Uniphoenix Corporation Berhad
• Datuk Mohd Sari Datuk Hj Nuar v Norwich Winterthur Insurance (M) Sdn. Bhd
• Badan Pengurusan Bersama Kompleks Pandan Safari Lagoon v Paradise Boulevard Sdn Bhd
• Perbadanan Kemajuan Negeri Selangor v Selangor Country Club Sdn Bhd
• Lee Ming Chong Sdn Bhd v Prudential Properties Sdn Bhd
• Sim Chio Huat v Wong Ted Fui
• Leong Ah Kew v Prisma Suria Sdn Bhd
• Spm Membrane Switch Sdn Bhd v Kerajaan Negeri Selangor
• M/v Pacific Pearl Company Ltd v Osios David Shipping Inc.
• Western Bank Ltd v Schindler
• Jean-François Clin v Walter Lilly & Company Ltd
• Port of Tilbury (London) Ltd v Stora Enso Transport & Distribution Ltd
• Compania de Navegacion Pohing S.A. v Sea Tanker Shipping (PTE) Ltd (Buena Trader)
• Norfolk Homes Ltd v North Norfolk District Council
• BP Gas Marketing Ltd v La Societe Sonatrach and Another
• Teekay Tankers Ltd (a company incorporated in the Marshall Islands) v Stx Offshore & Shipbuilding Company Ltd (a company incorporated in the Republic of Korea)
• Basanta-Henry, Audrey and Others v National Commercial Bank Jamaica Ltd
• S & T Distributors Ltd v CIBC Jamaica Ltd and Others
• Teo Seng Kee Bob v Arianecorp Ltd
• Energy Shipping Company Ltd v UDL Shipping (Singapore) Pte Ltd
• Wildgust (& Others) v Bank of Ireland (& Others)
• Marks and Spencer Plc v BNP Paribas Securities Services Trust Company (Jersey) Ltd
• Sembcorp Marine Ltd v PPL Holdings Pte Ltd
• Sembcorp Marine Ltd v PPL Holdings Pte Ltd
• Harcus Sinclair LLP v Your Lawyers Ltd
• Le Chatelaine Thudichum Ltd (in Voluntary Liquidation) v Conway
• Jani-King (GB) Ltd v Pula Enterprises Ltd and Others
• Socimer International Bank Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Standard Bank London Ltd
• Raymond Bieber & Others (Appellants/Claimants) v Teathers Ltd ((in Liquidation)) (Respondent/Defendant)

CONSIDERED in

• Decoma Uk Ltd and Another v Haden Drysys International Ltd
• Gladman Commercial Properties v Fisher Hargreaves Proctor and Others
• Wimpole Theatre (A Firm) v J. J. Goodman Ltd

[See more]

• Ultraframe (UK) Ltd v Tailored Roofing Systems Ltd
• R v Andrew Denney
• Holding & Management (Solitaire) Ltd v Ideal Homes North West Ltd and Others
• P C Partitions Ltd v Canary Wharf Contractors Ltd and Another
• Auriema Ltd (Respondents - Plaintiffs) Ronald Kirkwood McNeill (Appellant - 1st Defendant) Forecourt Aftermarket Ltd
• Chemco Leasing SpA (Plaintiffs/Appellants) v Rediffusion Plc
• Fin Soft Holding Sa v Rowil Interim Management by and Others
• Patricia Ann Jones and Another v Timothy Paul Oven and Another
• Philips Electronique Grand Public SA Philips Electronics UK Ltd (Plaintiffs (Respondents) British Sky Broadcasting Ltd Defendants (Appellants) - and - Philips International BV Philips Electronics UK Ltd Philips Electronique Grand Public SA (Plaintiffs (Respondents) British Satellite Broadcasting Ltd Sky Television Plc (Defendants (Appellants)
• Percy Bilton Ltd (Respondents (Plaintiffs) v Greater London Council (Appellants
• Donington Park Leisure Ltd v Wheatcroft & Son Ltd
• Texas Eastern Corporation (Delaware) and Others v Enterprise Oil Plc and Others
• John Paul Johnsen v Gunnar Johnsen (Part 19 Applicant) Mrs Rosemary Wilson and Another
• Hampshire CC v Beazer Homes Ltd
• LE CHATELAINE THUDICHUM (in Liquidation) Ltd v CONWAY
• Iceland Foods Ltd v Aldi Stores Ltd
• Western Bank Ltd (Plaintiffs) Kurt Schindler (Defendants)
• Medenta Finance Ltd v Hitachi Capital (UK) Plc
• Filobake Ltd v Rondo Ltd and Another
• Wuhan Ocean Economic & Techincal Cooperation Company Ltd and Another v Schiffahrts-Gesellschaft 'Hansa Murcia' MBH & Company KG
• HTA Architects Ltd v Countryside Properties Plc
• Stellite Construction Ltd v Vascroft Contractors Ltd
• Enterprise Inns Plc v The Forset Hill Tavern Public House Ltd
• Jis (1974) Ltd v McP Investment Nominees I Ltd and Another
• Bovis Group Pension Fund Ltd v G.C. Flooring and Furnishing Ltd
• M/v Pacific Pearl Company Ltd v Osios David Shipping Inc.
• Franbar Holdings Ltd v Casualty Plus Ltd and Another
• Dominion Corporate Trustees Ltd and Another v Capmark Bank Europe Plc (formerly Gmac Commercial Mortgage Bank Europe Plc)(now Known as Capmark Management Plc)
• Jack Thomas Baylis (Respondent (First Plaintiff) J.T. Baylis & Company Ltd (Second Plaintiff) Peter Charles Barnett (Appellant (First Defendant) Joan Olive Barnett (Appellant (Second Defendant) Yeo Barnett (Third Defendant)
• Hayfin Opal Luxco 3 SARL and another company v Windermere VII CMBS Plc and other companies
• Crescent Ltd v Jones,
• University of Wales v London College of Business Ltd
• Cyril Lawrence Spencer and Another v The Secretary of State for Defence
• Hickman and Others v Turn and Wave Ltd
• Tsg Building Services Plc v South Anglia Housing Ltd
• Rohan James et Al v Tyrone Robinson
• Martin Grant & Company Ltd v Sir Lindsay Parkinson & Company Ltd
• Filobake Ltd v Rondo Ltd and Another
• Lomas and Others v JFB Firth Rixson Inc. and Others (International Swaps and Derivatives Association intervening)
• Aspect Contracts (Asbestos) Ltd v Higgins Construction Plc
• Harold Percy Chaffe v Michael Kingsley
• Norfolk Homes Ltd v North Norfolk District Council
• Barrak Corporation Pty Ltd v Jaswil Properties Pty Ltd
• Cosmetic Warriors Ltd and Another v Andrew Gerrie and Another
• Rohan James v Tyrone Robinson
• Bathurst Resources Ltd and another v L & M Coal Holdings Ltd
• Pentium Holdings Ltd v Bryan Morris
• Everoy Chin v Silver Star Motors Ltd
• Hansraj Ramlal v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago
• Ennia General Insurance Company Ltd v Astaphan & Company (1970) Ltd
• Ennia General Insurance Company Ltd v J Astaphan & Company Ltd
• St. Croix v Ambrose
• Cariblue Hotels Ltd v McAllister Contracting (1970) Company Ltd
• Standard Chartered Bank (Switzerland) S.A. v UBS (Bahamas) Ltd
• Geotechvision Enterprises Ltd v E-Learning Jamaica Company Ltd
• S&T Distributors Ltd.and S&T Ltd v CIBC Jamaica Ltd and Royal & Sun Alliance
• T.O.C. Ltd v Range Resources Trinidad Ltd (Previously Called Trincan Oil Ltd)
• The Procter & Gamble Company and Others v Svenska Cellulosa Aktiebolaget Sca and Another
• James v Wenzel et Al
• The Creative Foundation v Dreamland Leisure Ltd and Others
• Grace Stanneveld v Lemuel Nelson
• Meridian Communications Ltd v Eircell Ltd
• Smith v Statutory Authorities Service Commission
• Moloney v Cashel Taverns Ltd (in Voluntary Liquidation)
• Clarion Quay Management Company Ltd by Guarantee v Dublin City Council, Pierce Contracting Unlimited Company, John McCormack, Brian McCormack, Niall McCormack, Alan McCormack and Patrick Kelly
• Spiritus Ltd v Conway
• St Albans City and District Council (Plaintiff v International Computers Ltd (Defendant
• Evangelistic Temple v Lauriette Lightfoot
• Torre Asset Funding Ltd and another v Royal Bank of Scotland Plc [Ch D]
• Barry Wassim Ramdeen v Muslim Credit Union Co-Operative Society Ltd
• Tesco Stores Ltd v Costain Construction Ltd and Others
• Epsilon Global Equities Ltd v Paul Hoo
• Riad Tawfiq AL Sadik Plaintiff v (1) Investcorp Bank B.S.C. (2) Investcorp Investment Advisers Ltd (3) Shallot Iam Ltd (4) Blossom Iam Ltd (5) Investcorp Nominee Holder Ltd (6) Investcorp Trading Ltd Defendants
• Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v Algoo
• Brent Mc Fee v Irla Marchan
• David Small v Niquan Energy Trinidad Ltd
• Hillcote Enterprises Ltd v Hope
• Leslie Dacosta Williams v Teleith Evelyn Williams
• Smith v Statutory Authorities Service Commission
• Weavering Macro Fixed Income Fund Ltd (in Official Liquidation) Plaintiff v Ernst & Young Chartered Accountants (A Firm) First Defendant Ernst & Young Ltd Second Defendant Ernst & Young (A Firm) Third Defendant
• Social Security Board v Herrera (d/b/a Belmopan Cleaning and Sanitation Services)
• Paymaster (Jamaica) Ltd and another v Grace Kennedy Remittance Services Ltd (Jamaica)
• Kayran Crosdale v Barry's Engineering Company Ltd
• Chong and Others v Alexander and another
• Joseph-Olivetti v Mitchell
• Deutsche Bank Ag v Sebastian Holdings Inc.

FOLLOWED in

• Ong Chong Wah and Another v Seyhuat Sdn Bhd
• Jallcon (M) Sdn Bhd v Nikken Metal (M) Sdn Bhd (No 2)
• Sumbangan Aneka Sdn Bhd v Knk Development Sdn Bhd and Others

[See more]

• Cold Storage Holdings Plc and Others v Overseas Assurance Corporation Ltd and Another
• Chng Heng Tiu and Another v Sime Darby
• Jet Holding Ltd and Others v Cooper Cameron (Singapore) Pte Ltd and Another

CITED in

• Lisnave Estaleiros Navais Sa v Chemikalien Seetransport Gmbh
• Manor Asset Ltd v Demolition Services Ltd
• Champion Homes Sales Pty Ltd ACN 082 497 247 v DCT Projects Pty Ltd ACN 116 379 616

[See more]

• Rosserlane Consultants Ltd and Another v Credit Suisse International
• Multiplex Constructions (UK) Ltd v Honeywell Control Systems Ltd (No. 2)
• Sutherland Professional Funding Ltd v Bakewells (A Firm)and Others
• Kingate Global Fund Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Kingate Management Ltd
• Stevensdrake Ltd (Trading as stevensdrake solicitors) v Stephen Hunt and Another
• TYC Investment Pte Ltd v Tay Yun Chwan Henry
• Kingate Global Fund Ltd and Another v Kingate Management Ltd and Others
• RBTT Bank Jamaica Ltd v YP Seaton and Others
• Jamaica Public Service Company Ltd v All Island Electricity Appeal Tribunal and Others
• Mediterranean Salvage & Towage Ltd v Seamar Trading & Commerce Inc. (The Reborn)
• Felton Construction Ltd v Liverpool City Council
• Ennia General Insurance Company Ltd Appellant v J. Astaphan & Company (1970) Ltd Respondent [ECSC]
• Adyard Abu Dhabi v SD Marine Services
• Ouais Group Engineering & Contracting v Saipem Spa and Others
• Rita Joseph-Olivetti Claimant v Dickon Mitchell Defendant [ECSC]
• AET Inc. Ltd v Arcadia Petroleum Ltd (The Eagle Valencia)
• O'Connor v McNamara
• Bank of New York Mellon (International) Ltd v Cine-UK Ltd

APPROVED in

• Carna Foods Ltd v Eagle Star Insurance Company (Ireland) Ltd

APPLIED in

• Attorney General of Belize and Others v Belize Telecom and another

This document cites

---

• Whitworth Street Estates (Manchester) Ltd v James Miller and Partners Ltd
• Luxor (Eastbourne) Ltd v Cooper
• R v The Inhabitants of Buckingham
• Whitworth Street Estates (Manchester) Ltd v James Miller and Partners Ltd
• Bickerton (T A.) & Son Ltd v North West Metropolitan Regional Hospital Board



See all quotations

• Holme v Guppy
• Dodd v Churton
• Reigate v Union Manufacturing Company (Ramsbottom) Ltd
• Nelson v Dahl
• Luxor (Eastbourne) Ltd v Cooper