Tibbles v SIG Plc (trading as Asphaltic Roofing Supplies)

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Stephen Edwards v Paul Golding Simon Darby Nicholas Griffin Third
• Ellis v Lambeth London Borough Council
• Kojima v HSBC Bank Ltd

REFERS TO

• Roult v North West Strategic Health Authority
• Lloyds Investment (Scandinavia) Ltd v Christen Ager-Hanssen
• Fritz v Hobson

DOES NOT FOLLOW

• Stephen Edwards v Paul Golding Simon Darby Nicholas Griffin Third

CITES

• Kojima v HSBC Bank Ltd
• Gudmundur Kristjansson v R Verney & Company Ltd
• Re Inchcape (Earl)

[See more]

• Business Environment Ltd v Deanwater Estates Ltd

CONSIDERS

• Simms v Carr
• Latimer Management Consultants Ltd and Others v Ellingham Investments Ltd and another

DISTINGUISHES

• Collier v Williams

CONSIDERED in

• R Gregory v City University London
• Gloria Ngozi Haastrup v Leverton & Sons Ltd and Others
• Newland Shipping & Forwarding Ltd v Toba Trading Fzc & Others

[See more]

• The Criminal Justice Act 1988
• BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana S.A. and Others
• Lakeminster Park Ltd and Another v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and Another
• Sir Keith Barron MP and Anr v Caven Vines
• C (A Child)
• Alan Coates v The Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and Another
• Galina Fortunatova v Dmitri Fortunatova Borex Property
• Mr Sayed Asadullah Abdul Wahid and Another (Claimants/Appellants) v Skanska UK Plc and Another
• London Metrocity College v Secretary of State for the Home Department
• Michael Wilson & Partners Ltd v John Forster Emmott
• Apex Global Management and Others (Petitionesr) v Global Torch Ltd and Others
• Alison Virginia Ashcroft v Rupert Jolyon Richard St John Webster
• Maria Gauquelin Des Pallieres v Bertrand Gauquelin Des Pallieres
• Richard Michael Edmund Wilmot v Viki Natasha Maughan
• Vannin Capital PCC (a Jersey Protected Cell Company incorporated in accordance with the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991) v Rbos Shareholders Action Group Ltd
• Vannin Capital PCC (a Jersey Protected Cell Company incorporated in accordance with the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991) v Rbos Shareholders Action Group Ltd
• Nax (A Protected Party, Suing by His Wife and Litigation Friend, Jax) v Max
• Iraqi Civilians v Ministry of Defence
• Re Dinglis Properties Ltd (No 3); Dinglis v Dinglis and Others (No 3)
• R v James Oulton
• Dr Meera Kailash Dal v Dr Marcus Bicknell
• John Riordan v Moon Beever Solicitors (A Firm)
• Hearst Holdings Inc. and Another (Respondents/Claimants) v A.v.E.L.A. Inc. and Others
• Pittville Ltd (as Assignee of the Rights of Mastercigars Direct Ltd) v Hunters & Frankau Ltd and Another
• Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc and Others v Baglan Abdullayevich Zhunus and Others
• Pauline Mavis Patricia Lomax v Stuart Andrew Lomax
• BC Penthouse Ltd v Sheikha Hind Salim Homoud AL-Jaber AL-Sabah
• Saint-Gobain v 3M
• National Investment Bank Ltd v Eland International (Thailand) Company Ltd
• Owen Oyston v David Rubin
• A and B (Through their solicitor, James Alexander Netto) v F
• Conversant Wireless Licensing S.à.r.l (a company incorporated under the laws of Luxembourg) v Huawei Technologies Company, Ltd (a company incorporated under the laws of the People's Republic of China)
• Geoffrey Carton-Kelly (as Liquidator of CGL Realisations Ltd) v Darty Holdings SAS
• Plymouth City Council v ABC
• Create Financial Management LLP v Roger Lee
• Mr Justyn James Page v RGC Restaurants Ltd
• Joseph Benkel (trustee in bankruptcy of Eliezer Fishman) v East-West German Real Estate Holding
• The Tintometer Ltd v Pitmans (A Firm)
• Lloyds Developments Ltd ((in Administration)) v Accor HotelServices UK Ltd
• Tina Norman (the wife) v Robert Norman (the husband)
• Invest Bank P.S.C. v Ahmad Mohammad El-Husseini
• Motorola Solutions, Inc. v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd
• Prompt Motor Ltd v HSBC Bank Plc
• National Crime Agency v Westminster Magistrates' Court
• Advinia Care Homes Ltd v Bupa Care Homes Investments (Holdings) Ltd
• Craig Wright v Peter McCormack
• Catalyst Management Services v Libya Africa Investment Portfolio
• Daniel Terry v BCS Corporate Acceptances Ltd
• Crypto Open Patent Alliance v Craig Steven Wright
• Owen Oyston v David Rubin
• Owen Oyston v David Rubin
• Illumina, Inc. v TDL Genetics Ltd
• Reuben Barney-Smith and Another v Tonbridge and Malling Borough Council
• John O'Driscoll v Vincent Raymond Clayton (Junior)
• Ilyas Khrapunov v JSC BTA Bank
• London Borough of Enfield v Persons Unknown
• London Borough of Enfield v Persons Unknown
• Michael Wilson & Partners, Ltd v Michael John Short
• Twin Benefits Ltd v Lain Paul Barker and Another
• Murli Mirchandani v Alka Gheewala
• Pharmagona Ltd v Sayed Mostafa Taheri
• Melson McMillan v Zoe Walcott-McMillan
• Ruth Helen Irish v No Defendant
• Diana Loson v Brett Stack
• AB/X v Ministry of Justice
• Sophie Coulthard v Secretary of State
• The Companies Act (2021 Revision) Padma Fund L.P.
• Vneshprombank LLC (a company registered and (in Liquidation) in the Russian Federation) v Georgy Ivanovich Bedzhamov
• The Section 92 of the Companies Act (2022 Revision) and Global Cord Blood Corporation
• The Section 92 of the Companies Act (2022 Revision) and Global Cord Blood Corporation
• Onyeari v Churchil
• Exporien Mining Private Ltd Company v Aggreko International Projects Ltd
• David John Standish v Lindsay Adolphus Cumberbatch
• The Exempted Ltd Partnership Act (2021 Revision) and the Companies Act (2021 Revision) and the Partnership Act (2013 Revision) New Silk Route Advisors, L.P.
• Between: (1) Lea Lilly Perry (2) Tamar Perry Plaintiffs v (1) Lopag Trust R (2) Private Equity Services (Curacao) NV (3) Fiduciana Verwaltungsanstalt (4) Gal Greenspoon (5) Yael Perry (6) Dan Greenspoon (7) Ron Greenspoon (8) Mia Greenspoon (9) Admintrust Verwaltungsanstalt Defendants
• Sofia Arif (Petitioner) v Arif Anwar Zar (First Respondent) Raziz Rehan (Second Respondent)
• Select Properties Ltd v CL Financial Ltd
• Lawrence Anthony Mollenthiel v Meredith Mottley-Haynes
• Between: (1) Lea Lilly Perry (2) Tamar Perry Plaintiffs v (1) Lopag Trust R (2) Private Equity Services (Curacao) NV (3) Fiduciana Verwaltungsanstalt (4) Gal Greenspoon (5) Yael Perry (6) Dan Greenspoon (7) Ron Greenspoon (8) Mia Greenspoon (9) Admintrust Verwaltungsanstalt Defendants
• Fairfield Sentry Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Farnum Place LLC
• Fairfield Sentry Ltd v Farnum Place Llc
• Michael Wilson & Partners Ltd v John Foster Emmott
• Tatiana Akhmedova v Farkhad Teimur Ogly Akhmedov
• BETWEEN: Dianne Patrice Fleiger Petitioner v Frank George Fleiger (Deceased) Respondent Michele Lenore Fleiger as Administratrix of the Estate of Frank George Fleiger (Deceased) Applicant
• An Application for a Disclosure Order Between Arcelormittal North America Holdings Llc Plaintiff v (1) Essar Global Fund Ltd (2) Essar Capital Ltd Defendants
• Between: Fortunate Drift Ltd Plaintiff v Canterbury Securities, Ltd Defendant
• Neurim Pharmaceuticals (1991) Ltd (a company incorporated under the laws of Israel) v Generics UK Ltd (trading as Mylan)
• Pt Ventures, Sgps, S.A. v Vidatel Ltd
• Tenaga Nasional Berhad v Frazer-Nash Research Ltd
• The Processing Centre Ltd v Pitney Bowes Ltd
• Petrojam Ltd v Sea Ventures Shipping Ltd and Others
• Michael Spence v Olive Maud Forbes
• Between: Dianne Patrice Fleiger Petitioner v Frank George Fleiger (Deceased) Respondent Michele Lenore Fleiger as Administratrix of the Estate of Frank George Fleiger (Deceased) Applicant
• PT Ventures, SGPS, S.A. v Vidatel Ltd
• Bidzina Ivanishvili v Credit Suisse Life (Bermuda) Ltd
• Samuel Collingwood Smith v Sonia Poulton
• Oasis Investments II Master Fund Ltd v Jardine Strategic Holdings Ltd
• Williams v Williams
• A.M.1. Consulting Ltd v SS Technology Consultancy Ltd
• Melson McMillan v Zoe Walcott-McMillan
• Ceredigion Recycling & Furniture Team v Clifford Pope

ADOPTED in

• Earthworks Environment and Resources Ltd (Defendant/Applicant) v Philip Beale

REFERRED in

• Maurice Hutson & Others v Tata Steel UK Ltd (formerly Corus UK Ltd, Successors in title and holders of the liabilities of British Steel Corporation and its predecessor companies)
• Jaswant Singh Dhillon and Another v Bagga Singh Sandhu
• Anthony James Cole v Liam Paul Paris Howlett and Others

[See more]

• Tf v Pj (Reversal of Judgment)
• Massimo Osti S.r.l (a company incorporated under the laws of Italy) v Global Design and Innovation Ltd
• SXK (by JXK her Mother and Litigation Friend) v West Hertfordshire Hospitals NHS Trust
• Amanda Clutterbuck and Another v A
• Thavatheva Thevarajah v John Riordan and Others
• Vneshprombank LLC (a company registered and (in Liquidation) in the Russian Federation) v Georgy Ivanovich Bedzhamov
• Maria Gauquelin Des Pallieres v Bertrand Gauquelin Des Pallieres
• Falmouth House Ltd v Micha'al Kamel Abou-Hamdan
• A v R
• Sc Dg Petrol Srl v Vitol Broking Ltd and Others
• Victor Lilley (Claimant) Euromoney Institutional Investor Plc and Another (Defendant) Victor Lilley (Claimant) The Chartered Insitute of Management Accountants (Defendant) Victor Lilley (Claimant) Aspermont UK Ltd (Defendant)
• Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc and Others v Baglan Abdullayevich Zhunus and Others
• VB Football Assets v Blackpool Football Club (Properties) Ltd (formerly Segesta Ltd)
• Edwards Lifesciences LLC v Boston Scientific Scimed, Inc.
• Mr Paul Cooper v VB Football Assets
• National Investment Bank Ltd v Eland International (Thailand) Company Ltd
• Nicholas Prinse v Landmasters (Overseas) Ltd
• Owen Oyston v David Rubin
• Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs v Smart Price Midlands Ltd
• Geoffrey Carton-Kelly (as Liquidator of CGL Realisations Ltd) v Darty Holdings SAS
• Joseph Benkel (trustee in bankruptcy of Eliezer Fishman) v East-West German Real Estate Holding
• The Tintometer Ltd v Pitmans (A Firm)
• Suez Fortune Investments Ltd and Another v Talbot Underwriting Ltd and Others
• Lloyds Developments Ltd ((in Administration)) v Accor HotelServices UK Ltd
• Invest Bank P.S.C. v Ahmad Mohammad El-Husseini
• Motorola Solutions, Inc. v Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd
• Kirsty Amanda Mary Louise Cadogan v Kevin Andrew Cadogan
• Advinia Care Homes Ltd v Bupa Care Homes Investments (Holdings) Ltd
• Owen Oyston v David Rubin
• BT v CU
• John O'Driscoll v Vincent Raymond Clayton (Junior)
• Libyan Investment Authority and Others v King and Others
• Peter Singh Sangha v Amicus Finance Plc ((in Administration))
• Craig Wright v Peter McCormack
• Pharmagona Ltd v Sayed Mostafa Taheri
• Newland Shipping & Forwarding Ltd v Toba Trading FZC
• AB/X v Ministry of Justice
• JSC BTA Bank v Ablyazov
• Vneshprombank LLC (a company registered and (in Liquidation) in the Russian Federation) v Georgy Ivanovich Bedzhamov
• Exporien Mining Private Ltd Company v Aggreko International Projects Ltd
• Adam Robert Giaquinto v ITI Capital Ltd (formerly “Walbrook Capital Markets Ltd” and “FXCM Securities Ltd”)
• Amanda Stephanie Clutterbuck v William Cleghorn (Sued as Judicial Factor to the Estate of Elliot Nichol Deceased)
• M v P (Queen's Proctor intervening)
• Deutsche Bank AG v Sebastian Holdings Inc.
• Michael Wilson & Partners Ltd v CJSC Kazsubton
• E (Children: Reopening Findings of Fact)
• Michael Wilson & Partners, Ltd (Claimant/ Appellant) v Thomas Ian Sinclair and Others John Forster Emmott (Part 20 Defendant)
• ZU v LT
• Athena Capital Fund Sicav-FIS S.C.A v Crownmark Ltd
• Geoffrey Alan Salt v Stratstone Specialist Ltd T/A Stratstone Cadillac Newcastle
• Thevarajah v John Riordan and Others
• Thavatheva Thevarajah (Appellant/Claimant) v John Riordan and Others (Respondents/Defendants)
• Mitchell v News Group Newspapers Ltd
• Natalia Nikolaevna Potanina v Vladimir Olegovich Potanin
• Barbara Mary Hewson v Bar Standards Board

DISTINGUISHED in

• Ministry of Defence v Blythe
• Liaqat Malik and Others v Manchester and Salford Magistrates' Court and Others
• Samir Ramzi Samara (Claimant and Respondent) v (1) MBI & Partners UK Ltd (t/a M.B.I. International & Partners Co) (1) First Defendant and Applicant) (2) Ajwa Rmti Company (t/a Ajwa Group for Food Industries) (2) Second Defendant)

CITED in

• Wells v Serco Ltd
• Evesham and Pershore Housing Association Ltd (Claimant and Respondent) v Timothy Werrett (Defendant and Appellant)
• Anas v The King Fahad Academy Ltd

[See more]

• Energy Venture Partners Ltd v Malabu Oil and Gas Ltd
• Phonographic Performance Ltd v John Nash (Trading as Charlie Wright International)
• Michael Wilson & Partners Ltd v John Forster Emmott
• Emerald Supplies Ltd and Others v British Airways Plc Air Canada and Others (Third Parties) Japan Airlines Company Ltd and Others (Fourth Parties)
• Apple Retail UK Ltd and Others v Qualcomm (UK) Ltd and Others
• QRS (on behalf of himself and in a representative capacity for all the individuals identified in Confidential Annex 1 to the Amended Claim Form in these proceedings) v Daniel Charles Beach and Another
• Nihal Mohammed Kamal Brake v The Chedington Court Estate Ltd
• Mrs June Bawden v WM Morrison Supermarkets Plc
• Actial Farmaceutica LDA v Professor Claudio De Simone and Others
• GM v KZ
• BC Penthouse Ltd v Sheikha Hind Salim Homoud AL-Jaber AL-Sabah
• Maritime Investment Holdings Inc. v Underwriting Members of Syndicate 1183 at Lloyd's and Others (Third Defendants)
• Starbibi Raja (Administratrix of the Estate of Mohammed Sabir Raja, Deceased) v Nicholas Van Hoogstraten
• Stephen Pincus v Sandeep Singh Johal
• Andrew Mitchell MP v News Group Newspapers Ltd
• CS v ACS and Another
• Anthony James Cole v Liam Paul Paris Howlett and Others
• HRH Prince Abdulaziz Bin Mishal Bin Abdulaziz Al Saud v Apex Global Management Ltd and Another
• Salts Healthcare Ltd v Pelican Healthcare Ltd
• Allsop v Banner Jones Ltd (trading as Banner Jones Solicitors) and another
• Mark Byers v Samba Financial Group
• Energy Venture Partners Ltd v Malabu Oil and Gas Ltd
• Robert Derek Smailes and Another v John McNally and Another
• Mr Mashood Iqbal (Appellant/Claimant) v Dean Manson Solicitors and Others (No 2) (Respondent/Defendant)
• NEALE IAN HALEY (Claimant and Appellant) v ZAHRA ITRAT SIDDIQUI & 3 OTHERS (Defendants and Respondents)
• HRH Prince Abdulaziz Bin Mishal Bin Abdulaziz Al Saud v Apex Global Management Ltd
• Deutsche Bank AG and Others v Unitech Global Ltd and Another

APPLIED in

• Robert Derek Smailes and Another v John Henry Johally and Others
• Rawlinson & Hunter Trustees Sa (in Its Capacity as Trustee of the Tchenguiz Settlement) v Itg Ltd and Another
• Gerardo Moreno De La Hija v Christopher Frank Carandini Lee

[See more]

• Plymouth City Council v ABC
• Middlesbrough Football & Athletic Company (1986) Ltd v Earth Energy Investments LLP ((in Liquidation))
• Islamic Investment Company of the Gulf (Bahamas) Ltd v Symphony Gems NV and Others (Defendants/Applicant)

RELIED UPON in

• Anna Timokhina v Alexander Timokhin

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2012] 4 All ER 259
• [2012] 1 WLR 2591

This document cites

---

• Michael Peter Hicks v Russell Jones & Walker
• Stephen Edwards v Paul Golding Simon Darby Nicholas Griffin Third
• Lloyds Investment (Scandinavia) Ltd v Christen Ager-Hanssen
• Collier v Williams
• Roult v North West Strategic Health Authority



See all quotations

• Kojima v HSBC Bank Ltd
• Simms v Carr
• Kojima v HSBC Bank Ltd
• Stephen Edwards v Paul Golding Simon Darby Nicholas Griffin Third
• Latimer Management Consultants Ltd and Others v Ellingham Investments Ltd and another
• Business Environment Ltd v Deanwater Estates Ltd
• Fritz v Hobson
• Ellis v Lambeth London Borough Council
• Gudmundur Kristjansson v R Verney & Company Ltd
• Re Inchcape (Earl)