Specsavers International Healthcare Ltd and Others (Appellants/ Claimants) v Asda Stores Ltd (Respondent /Defendant)

Core Citations

---

ADOPTS

• Anheuser-Busch Inc. v Budejovicky Budvar Narodni Podnik (Application for Revocation); Bud and Budweiser Budrau Trade Marks

CONSIDERS

• L'Oréal SA and Others v Bellure NV (Case C-487/07)
• Norowzian v Arks Ltd (No 2)

[See more]

• Sabel BV v Puma AG (Case C-251/95)
• Designer Guild Ltd v Russell Williams (Textiles) Ltd (trading as Washington DC)
• Wingfield v Stratford and Osman
• Beautimatic International Ltd v Mitchell ; International Pharmaceuticals Ltd and Another
• O2 Holdings Ltd v Hutchison 3G UK Ltd (Case C-533/06) (No 3)

REFERS TO

• Nestlé SA's Trade Mark Application
• UK Channel Management Ltd v E! Entertainment Television Inc. and Another
• Whirlpool Corporation and Others v Kenwood Ltd

[See more]

FOLLOWS

• Adidas-Salomon AG and another v Fitnessworld Trading Ltd (Case C-408/01)
• June Perfect, Ltd v Saville Perfumery, Ltd, F. W. Woolworth and Company, Ltd v Saville Perfumery, Ltd (Consolidated Appeals)
• Phones 4u Ltd v Phone4u.Company uk Internet Ltd

CITES

• Decon Laboratories Ltd v Fred Baker Scientific Ltd and Another
• Designer Guild Ltd v Russell Williams (Textiles) Ltd (trading as Washington DC)

[See more]

• Slazenger & Sons v Feltham & Company
• Norowzian v Arks Ltd (No 2)
• British Sugar Plc v James Robertson & Sons Ltd
• Julius Samaan Ltd v Tetrosyl Ltd
• Premier Brands UK Ltd v Typhoon Europe Ltd
• Biogen Inc. v Medeva Plc

CONSIDERS

• O2 Holdings Ltd v Hutchison 3G UK Ltd (Application for Interim Injunction)
• United Biscuits (UK) Ltd v Asda Stores Ltd

[See more]

• O2 Holdings Ltd (formerly O2 Ltd) v Hutchison 3G Ltd (No 2)
• O2 Holdings Ltd v Hutchison 3G UK Ltd (No 1)
• Och-Ziff Management Europe Ltd and Another v Och Capital LLP and Others
• Trade Marks Act 1938
• Trade Marks Act 1994
• Trade Marks Act 1994 - Articles : S-46

DISTINGUISHES

CITED in

• The Queen (on the application of (1) South Tyneside Care Home Owners Association (2) Helen McArdle Care Ltd (3) Executive Care Group) v South Tyneside Council
• Interflora Inc. and another v Marks and Spencer Plc (No 2)
• Comic Enterprises Ltd v Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation

[See more]

• Champagne Louis Roederer (a company incorporated under the laws of France) v J Garcia Carrion S.A. (a company incorporated under the laws of Spain) and Others
• The Comptroller-General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks and Another v Intellectual Property Agency Ltd and Another
• Wxy v Henry Gewanter and Others
• IPC Media Ltd v Media 10 Ltd
• Specsavers International Healthcare Ltd and Others (Claimants / Appellants) v Asda Stores Ltd Registrar of Trade Marks (Intervener)
• Cranford Community College v Cranford College Ltd
• Eli Lilly and Company Ltd v Human Genome Sciences Inc. (No 2)
• Iconix Luxembourg Holdings SARL v Dream Pairs Europe Inc.
• Coreix Ltd v Coretx Holdings Plc and Others
• The Ukulele Orchestra of Great Britain v Erwin Clausen and Another
• TVIS Ltd v Howserv Services Ltd
• The London Taxi Corporation Ltd trading as the London Taxi Company v Frazer-Nash Research Ltd and Another
• Sas Institute Inc. v World Programming Ltd
• Jack Wills Ltd v House of Fraser (Stores) Ltd
• Walton International Ltd v Verweij Fashion BV
• Roger Maier and Another v ASOS Plc and Another
• Supreme Petfoods Ltd v Henry Bell & Company (Grantham) Ltd
• Interflora, Inc. and Another v Marks and Spencer Plc and Another
• Comic Enterprises Ltd v Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation
• Aveda Corporation v Dabur India Ltd

REFERRED in

• Comic Enterprises Ltd v Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation
• UK Trade Mark Application no. 2569771 British Shorinji Kempo Federation (stylised) in Classes 26, 35 and 41 in the name of British Shorinji Kempo Federation v Opposition No 102471 thereto by Shorinji Kempo Unity
• Gap (ITM) Inc. v British American Group Ltd

[See more]

• Hai Tong Company (Pte) Ltd v Ventree Singapore Pte Ltd
• Iconix Luxembourg Holdings Sarl v Dream Pairs Europe Inc.
• Urbanbubble Ltd v Urban Evolution Property Management Ltd
• Boxing Brands Ltd v Sports Direct International Plc and Others
• Juul Labs, Inc. v Quick Xuul Ltd
• KBF Enterprises Ltd v Gladiator Nutrition 3.0 Ltd (now dissolved)
• Prysmian Cables & Systems Ltd v M/S Apple International
• Argos Ltd v Argos Systems Inc.
• IPC Media Ltd (Claimant/Appellant) v Media 10 Ltd
• Industrial Cleaning Equipment (Southampton) Ltd v Intelligent Cleaning Equipment Holdings Company Ltd
• Easygroup Ltd v Easylife Ltd (Formerly Easylife Group Ltd)
• Combe International LLC (A company incorporated under the laws of the State of Delaware, USA) v Dr August Wolff GmbH & Company KG Arzneimittel (A company incorporated under the laws of Germany)
• Easygroup Ltd v Easyfundraising Ltd
• Bayerische Moteren Werke Aktiengesellschaft v Edward Ronayne t/a BMWcare)
• Athleta (ITM) Inc. v Sports Group Denmark A/S
• Property Renaissance Ltd T/A Titanic Spa v (1) Stanley Dock Hotel Ltd T/A Titanic Hotel Liverpool (2) Stanley Dock Properties Ltd T/A Titanic Hotel Liverpool (3) Titanic Trademark Ltd (4) Titanic Quarter Ltd
• Planetart LLC (incorporated under the laws of Delaware, USA) v Photobox Ltd
• Liverpool Gin Distillery Ltd v Sazerac Brands, LLC
• Lifestyle Equities CV v Royal County of Berkshire Polo Club Ltd
• Moroccanoil Isreal Ltd v Aldi Stores Ltd
• Lidl Great Britain Ltd v Tesco Stores Ltd
• Easygroup Ltd v Nuclei Ltd
• Match Group, LLC v Muzmatch Ltd
• Lifestyle Equities C.v v. Royal County of Berkshire Polo Club Ltd
• Glaxo Wellcome UK Ltd v Sandoz Ltd
• Enterprise Holdings, Inc. v Europcar Group UK Ltd and Another
• Easygroup Ltd v Easy Live (Services) Ltd
• Montres Breguet S.A. v Samsung Electronics Company Ltd
• Evegate Publishing Ltd v Newsquest Media (Southern) Ltd
• Lidl Great Britain Ltd v Tesco Stores Ltd
• JW Spear & Sons Ltd and Others v Zynga Inc. (a corporation incorporated under the law of the State of Delaware in the United States of America)
• Marussia Communications Ireland Ltd v Manor Grand Prix Racing Ltd and Others
• Lonsdale Sports Ltd v Erol

CONSIDERED in

• Total Ltd v Youview TV Ltd
• Beauty Bay Ltd v Benefit Cosmetics Ltd
• Skyscape Cloud Services Ltd v Sky Plc and Others

[See more]

• A & E Television Networks Llc and Another v Discovery Communications Europe Ltd
• The Sofa Workshop Ltd v Sofaworks Ltd
• Luen Fat Metal and Plastic Manufactory Company Ltd v Funko UK, Ltd
• Acedes Holdings, LLC v Clive Sutton Ltd
• Roger Maier and Another v Asos Plc and Another
• British Amateur Gymnastics Association v UK Gymnastics Ltd
• Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft (a company incorporated under the laws of Germany) v Technosport London Ltd and Another
• Lifestyle Equities CV v The Copyrights Group Ltd
• Juul Labs, Inc. v Quick Xuul Ltd
• Intercity Group (NZ) Ltd v Nakedbus Nz Ltd
• Intercity Group (Nz) Ltd v Nakedbus Nz Ltd
• The Co-Operative Bank Ltd v Anderson
• The Coca-Cola Company v Frucor Soft Drinks Ltd
• Specsavers International Healthcare Ltd and Others (Appellants/Claimants) v Asda Stores Ltd (Respondent/Defendant)
• Société Anonyme Des Bains De Mer Et Du Cercle Des Étrangers À Monaco v Anglofile International Limitedtrading as Monte Carlo Casino Entertainment
• Iconix Luxembourg Holdings SARL v Dream Pairs Europe Inc.
• (1) Lifestyle Equities C.v v (1) Santa Monica Polo Club Ltd
• Red Bull Gmbh v Sun Mark Ltd and Another
• TVIS Ltd v Howserv Services Ltd
• Jadebay Ltd and Another v Clarke-Coles Ltd Trading as Feel Good UK
• TVIS Ltd v Howserv Services Ltd
• E-Accounting Solutions Ltd T/as Advancetrack v Global Infosys Ltd T/as GI Outsourcing
• Thomas Pink Ltd v Victoria's Secret UK Ltd
• Sazerac Brands, LLC v Liverpool Gin Distillery Ltd
• Shorts International Ltd v Google LLC
• Gnat and Company Ltd (a company incorporated under the laws of the British Virgin Islands) v West Lake East Ltd
• Gama Healthcare Ltd v Pal International Ltd
• Easygroup Ltd v Beauty Perfectionists Ltd
• Thatchers Cider Company Ltd v Aldi Stores Ltd
• W3 Ltd v Easygroup Ltd
• Comic Enterprises Ltd (claimant/respondent) Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation (Defendant/Appellant)
• Sky Plc v Skykick UK Ltd
• Marks and Spencer Plc v Interflora Inc. (A Company Incorporated Under the laws of the State of Michigan, USA) and Another

APPLIED in

• APT Training & Consultancy Ltd v Birmingham & Solihull Mental Health NHS Trust
• Redd Solicitors LLP v Red Legal Ltd and Another
• Frank Industries Pty Ltd v Nike Retail BV

[See more]

• Montres Breguet S.A. v Samsung Electronics Company Ltd (a company incorporated in South Korea)
• Easygroup Ltd v Easy Live (Services) Ltd
• J.W. Spear & Sons Ltd and Others v Zynga Inc. (a corporation organised under the laws of the State of Delaware in the United States of America)

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2012] FSR 19
• [2012] ETMR 17

RELIED UPON in

• Interflora Inc. (a company incorporated under the laws of Michigan, United States) and Another v Marks and Spencer Plc

FOLLOWED in

• Thatchers Cider Company Ltd v Aldi Stores Ltd

This document cites

---

• Anheuser-Busch Inc. v Budejovicky Budvar Narodni Podnik (Application for Revocation); Bud and Budweiser Budrau Trade Marks
• Phones 4u Ltd v Phone4u.Company uk Internet Ltd
• Biogen Inc. v Medeva Plc
• Och-Ziff Management Europe Ltd and Another v Och Capital LLP and Others
• Designer Guild Ltd v Russell Williams (Textiles) Ltd (trading as Washington DC)



See all quotations

• Designer Guild Ltd v Russell Williams (Textiles) Ltd (trading as Washington DC)
• Julius Samaan Ltd v Tetrosyl Ltd
• O2 Holdings Ltd v Hutchison 3G UK Ltd (No 1)
• O2 Holdings Ltd v Hutchison 3G UK Ltd (Application for Interim Injunction)
• L'Oréal SA and Others v Bellure NV (Case C-487/07)
• UK Channel Management Ltd v E! Entertainment Television Inc. and Another
• Nestlé SA's Trade Mark Application
• June Perfect, Ltd v Saville Perfumery, Ltd, F. W. Woolworth and Company, Ltd v Saville Perfumery, Ltd (Consolidated Appeals)
• O2 Holdings Ltd (formerly O2 Ltd) v Hutchison 3G Ltd (No 2)
• Whirlpool Corporation and Others v Kenwood Ltd
• Slazenger & Sons v Feltham & Company
• Beautimatic International Ltd v Mitchell ; International Pharmaceuticals Ltd and Another
• Adidas-Salomon AG and another v Fitnessworld Trading Ltd (Case C-408/01)
• Norowzian v Arks Ltd (No 2)
• Wingfield v Stratford and Osman
• Norowzian v Arks Ltd (No 2)
• British Sugar Plc v James Robertson & Sons Ltd
• Biogen Inc. v Medeva Plc
• Sabel BV v Puma AG (Case C-251/95)
• United Biscuits (UK) Ltd v Asda Stores Ltd
• Decon Laboratories Ltd v Fred Baker Scientific Ltd and Another
• O2 Holdings Ltd v Hutchison 3G UK Ltd (Case C-533/06) (No 3)
• Premier Brands UK Ltd v Typhoon Europe Ltd
• Trade Marks Act 1938
• Trade Marks Act 1994
• Medion AG v Thomson multimedia Sales Germany & Austria GmbH.
• Die BergSpechte Outdoor Reisen und Alpinschule Edi Koblmüller GmbH v Günther Guni and trekking.at Reisen GmbH.
• Interflora Inc. and Interflora British Unit v Marks & Spencer plc and Flowers Direct Online Ltd.
• Marca Mode CV contra Adidas AG y Adidas Benelux BV.
• Société des produits Nestlé SA v Mars UK Ltd.