Reardon Smith Line Ltd v Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (Agostino Bertani, Cape Rodney, Queen City, Riverton)

Core Citations

---

DISAPPROVES

• Alvion Steamship Corporation Panama v Galban Lobo Trading Company S.A. of Havana

CONSIDERS

• Alvion Steamship Corporation Panama v Galban Lobo Trading Company S.A. of Havana

REFERS TO

• South African Dispatch Line v Owners of the Panamanian Steamship Niki
• Robert Dollar Company v Blood, Holman & Company
• Cochran v Retberg et alt

[See more]

• Hain Steamship Company Ltd v Tate and Lyle Ltd
• Leonis S.S. Company Ltd v Joseph Rank Ltd (No. 2)
• Nielsen & Company v Wait James & Company
• George Barkworth, Plaintiff; Emma Young, Spinster, Defendant
• The Katy

FOLLOWS

• The "India."
• Branckelow Steamship Company v Lamport & Holt

DOES NOT FOLLOW

• Mein v Ottman

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Reardon Smith Line Ltd v Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (Agostino Bertani, Cape Rodney, Queen City, Riverton)

APPLIES

• British and Mexican Shipping Company v Lockett Brothers & Company Ltd
• James Nelson & Sons Ltd v Nelson Line (Liverpool) Ltd

CITES

• ‘Z’ Steamship Company Ltd v Amtorg, New York
• James Nelson & Sons Ltd v Nelson Line (Liverpool) Ltd
• Maatschappij (N. v) Zeevart v M. Friesacher Soehne (Leto.)

[See more]

• Hain Steamship Company Ltd v Sociedad Anonima Comercial de Exportacion e Importacion (Louis Dreyfus & Company Ltd)
• Verren v Anglo-Dutch Brick Company (1927) Ltd
• South African Dispatch Line v Owners of the Panamanian Steamship Niki
• Nielsen v Wait
• Pearson and Craig v Tudor-Rees
• Bunge y Born Company v Brightman & Company

CONSIDERS

• Verren v Anglo-Dutch Brick Company (1927) Ltd
• Compania Naviera Azuero S.A. v British Oil & Cake Mills Ltd (Azuero.)
• Burnett Steamship Company Ltd v Danube and Black Sea Shipping Agencies

[See more]

• Stephens v Harris & Company
• Love & Stewart Ltd v Rowtor Steamship Company Ltd
• Bennetts & Company v Rrown

DISTINGUISHES

• Bunge y Born Company v Brightman & Company

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1963] UKHL J0207-1
• [1963] 1 All ER 545
• [1963] 1 Lloyd's Rep 12

[See more]

• [1963] 2 WLR 439
• [1963] AC 691

CITED in

• Gulf Shippings Lines Ltd v Compania Naviera Alanje S.A. (Aspa Maria)
• The Stamatios G. Embiricos
• A/S Uglands Rederi v President of India (Danita)

[See more]

• Atlantic Lines & Navigation Company Inc. v Didymi Corporation (Leon)
• Gebr. Broere B.v v Saras Chimica S.p.A.
• European Grain & Shipping Ltd v J. H. Rayner & Company Ltd (Rostok.)
• Seabridge Shipping Ltd v Antco Shipping Ltd (Furness Bridge)
• Bremer Handelsgesellschaft mbH v Vanden Avenne-Izegem PVBA
• Zeeland Navigation Company Ltd v Banque Worms (Foresight Driller II)
• ED&F Man Sugar Ltd v Unicargo Transportgesellschaft mbH and Another (The Ladytramp)
• Dow Chemical (Nederland) B.v v B.P. Tanker Company Ltd (Vorras)
• The Mosfield
• Vitol S.A. v Phibro Energy A.G. (Mathraki)
• Excomm Ltd v Guan Guan Shipping (Pte.) Ltd (Golden Bear)
• High Seas Venture Ltd Partnership v Sinom (Hong Kong) Ltd (The "Newforest")
• Richard Pease v Henderson Administration Ltd
• Libyan Arab Foreign Bank v Bankers Trust Company

CONSIDERED in

• E. D. & F. Man Sugar Ltd (Claimants/ Charterers) v Unicargo Transportgesellschaft Mbh (Defendant/ Owners)
• KRITI AKTI SHIPPING Company S.A. and PETROLEO BRASILIERO S.A. [CA (Civil), 20/02/2004]
• Petroleo Brasileiro S.A. v Kriti Akti Shipping Company S.A.

[See more]

• Northstar Land Ltd v Brooks and Another
• Northstar Land Ltd v Brooks and Another
• MUR Shipping BV v RTI Ltd
• Seadrill Ghana Operations Ltd v Tullow Ghana Ltd
• Crosstown Music Co 1, LLC v Rive Droite Music Ltd and Others
• RTI Ltd v MUR Shipping BV

REFERRED in

• E D and F Man Sugar Ltd v Unicargo Transportgesellschaft GmbH Polska Zegluga Morska PP (Interested Party)
• Kin Kwok Daily News Sdn Bhd and Another; Percetakan Solai Sdn Bhd
• Skyworld Development Sdn Bhd v Zalam Corporation Sdn Bhd & Other Cases

[See more]

• MUR Shipping BV v RTI Ltd
• Essex County Council v UBB Waste (Essex) Ltd

APPLIED in

• BP Oil International Ltd v Target Shipping Ltd [QBD (Comm)]

DISTINGUISHED in

• MUR Shipping BV v RTI Ltd

This document cites

---

• South African Dispatch Line v Owners of the Panamanian Steamship Niki
• Bunge y Born Company v Brightman & Company
• Alvion Steamship Corporation Panama v Galban Lobo Trading Company S.A. of Havana
• Verren v Anglo-Dutch Brick Company (1927) Ltd
• British and Mexican Shipping Company v Lockett Brothers & Company Ltd



See all quotations

• James Nelson & Sons Ltd v Nelson Line (Liverpool) Ltd
• Robert Dollar Company v Blood, Holman & Company
• Bunge y Born Company v Brightman & Company
• Nielsen & Company v Wait James & Company
• Verren v Anglo-Dutch Brick Company (1927) Ltd
• South African Dispatch Line v Owners of the Panamanian Steamship Niki
• ‘Z’ Steamship Company Ltd v Amtorg, New York
• The "India."
• Cochran v Retberg et alt
• The Katy
• Love & Stewart Ltd v Rowtor Steamship Company Ltd
• Mein v Ottman
• Hain Steamship Company Ltd v Tate and Lyle Ltd
• James Nelson & Sons Ltd v Nelson Line (Liverpool) Ltd
• Bennetts & Company v Rrown
• Leonis S.S. Company Ltd v Joseph Rank Ltd (No. 2)
• Branckelow Steamship Company v Lamport & Holt
• Hain Steamship Company Ltd v Sociedad Anonima Comercial de Exportacion e Importacion (Louis Dreyfus & Company Ltd)
• Maatschappij (N. v) Zeevart v M. Friesacher Soehne (Leto.)
• Burnett Steamship Company Ltd v Danube and Black Sea Shipping Agencies
• George Barkworth, Plaintiff; Emma Young, Spinster, Defendant
• Alvion Steamship Corporation Panama v Galban Lobo Trading Company S.A. of Havana
• Compania Naviera Azuero S.A. v British Oil & Cake Mills Ltd (Azuero.)
• Nielsen v Wait
• Stephens v Harris & Company
• Pearson and Craig v Tudor-Rees