R v Monopolies and Mergers Commission and Another ex parte South Yorkshire Transport Ltd and Others

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• R v Monopolies and Mergers Commission, ex parte South Yorkshire Transport Ltd and Another
• Palser v Grinling Property Holding Company Ltd; Property Holding Company Ltd v Mischeff

REFERS TO

• Edwards (Inspector of Taxes) v Bairstow
• Palser v Grinling Property Holding Company Ltd; Property Holding Company Ltd v Mischeff

CONSIDERS

• Transport Act 1985
• Fair Trading Act 1973 - Articles : S-64

RESUELVE RECURSO

• R v Monopolies and Mergers Commission, ex parte South Yorkshire Transport Ltd and Another

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1992] UKHL J1217-1
• [1993] 1 All ER 289
• [17/12/1992] TLR 4

[See more]

• [1993] 1 WLR 23

REFERRED in

• Crematoria Management Ltd v Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council
• Wong v Silkfield Pty Ltd
• R Nutricia Ltd v The Secretary of State for Health

[See more]

• Great Dunmow Estates Ltd v Crest Nicholson Operations Ltd
• Quintavalle v Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority
• Premier Oil UK Ltd v Shell International Trading and Shipping Company Ltd (for and on behalf of Shell Trading International Ltd)
• R Bluefin Insurance Services Ltd v Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd Wayne Lochner (Interested Party)
• Elliott Associates L.P v The London Metal Exchange
• R (on the application of Sarah Finch on behalf of the Weald Action Group) v Surrey County Council

CONSIDERED in

• Charles Robertson (Developments) Ltd v The Advertising Standards Authority
• R v Director General of Electricity Supply Dispersal Prisons and Others
• R Long v The Welsh Ministers Monmouthshire County Council (First Interested Party) Optimisation Developments Ltd (Second Interested Party)

[See more]

• R v The Secretary of State for Defence (ex parte) Maurice Wilkins and Others
• Buckinghamshire County Council v The Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions and Another
• R v The London Borough of Bromley and Another
• R the Green Transport Company Ltd v The West Midlands Integrated Transport Authority and Another
• The Mayor and Burgesses of the London Borough of Enfield v Secretary of State for Social Security
• Commissioner of State Revenue v Antonino Arrigo
• Charles Robertson (Developments) Ltd v The Advertising Standards Authority
• R v The Licensing Authority and Another
• R v Broadcasting Standards Commission and Another
• R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board and Others
• R v P. Borough Council, ex parte S
• R v The Director General of Fair Trading ex parte Benhams Ltd
• R v Medicines Control Agency and Another
• Australian Football League, Shane Maguire, Brian Le Brocq and David Shilbury v Carlton Football Club Ltd and Gregory Donald Williams
• Charles Robertson (developments) Ltd v The Advertising Standards Authority
• R (T-Mobile (UK) Ltd) v Competition Commission
• Perrin and another v Northampton Borough Council and Others
• R v Broadcasting Standards Commission and Another
• Government Actuaries Department v Pensions Ombudsman
• The Queen (on the Application of Wye Valley Action Association Ltd) (Respondent/Claimant) Herefordshire Council (Appellant/Defendant) The National Farmers' Union (Intervener)
• Queen on the Application of Nigel Coatman and andrew Golub v Council for Licensed Conveyancers
• R v The Secretary of State for The Home Department and Another
• The Queen (on the Application of Spitalfields Historic Trust Ltd) v Mayor of London London Borough of Tower Hamlets (First Interested Party) British Land Property Management Ltd (Second Interested Party)
• Braintree District Council Secretary of State for the Environment & Bovis Homes Ltd and Another Secretary of State for the Environment & Braintree DC and Another Secretary of State for the Environment & Braintree DC
• R Richard Lyon (Claimant) Cambridge City Council (Defendant) Hills Road Sixth Form College (Interested Party)
• R Save Woolley Valley Action Group Ltd v Bath and North East Somerset Council (1) Golden Valley Paddocks Ltd (Interested Parties) (2) Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
• Queen Mary University of London v Higher Education Funding Council for England
• Leonard Hille Marin Van Leeuwen v Secretary of State for the Environment and and Another
• Condron v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council
• R (Wye Valley Action Association Ltd) v Herefordshire Council
• R (Mullaney) v Adjudication Panel for England
• R London Christian Radio Ltd (1) (Claimants) Christian Communications Partnerships Ltd (2) Radio Advertising Clearance Centre (Defendant) Secretary of State for Culture, Olympics Media and Sport (Interested Party)
• R ((1) YUKOS OIL COMPANY (2) STICHTING ADMINISTRATIEKANTOOR YUKOS INTERNATIONAL) v (1) FINANCIAL SERVICES AUTHORITY (2) LONDON STOCK EXCHANGE and (1) OJSC ROSNEFT (2) OJSC ROSNEFTEGAZ Interested Parties
• MRS MINAXI PABARI v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions and NILESH PABARI/
• Greenwood (No. 2))
• R (Cherwell District Council) v First Secretary of State
• Data Base Corporate Pty Ltd v Strike Australia Pty Ltd
• Great Dunmow Estates Ltd v Crest Nicholson Operations Ltd
• Newspaper Licensing Agency v Marks & Spencer Plc
• The Queen (on the Application of Cathy Gardner and Fay Harris) v The Secretary of State for Health and Social Care
• Jeremy Cox v The Oil and Gas Authority
• R (Darboe)v Secretary of State for the Home Department
• R (Norwich and Peterborough Building Society) v Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd
• Rajan Marwaha v UK Border Revenue Agency (Cash and Compensation Team)
• R Warley v Wealden District Council
• R v Radio Authority, ex parte Bull
• R (ex parte London Borough of Greenwich) v Secertary of State for Health
• Premier Oil UK Ltd v Shell International Trading and Shipping Company Ltd (for and on behalf of Shell Trading International Ltd)
• R v Ministry of Defence, ex parte Walker
• Flowgroup Plc ((in Liquidation)) v Co-Operative Energy Ltd
• Sugar and another v British Broadcasting Corporation (No 1)
• Vodafone New Zealand Ltd v Telecom New Zealand Ltd
• Chorus Ltd v Commerce Commission& Ors
• R Mouring v West Berkshire Council
• The King v Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd
• R (Badger Trust) v The Welsh Ministers
• R Unison (Claimant) Monitor (Defendant) (1) The Secretary of State for Health (Interested Parties) (2) Foundation Trust Network
• R (British Union for Abolition of Vivisection) v Secretary of State for the Home Department
• Lai v The Attorney General
• Raymond Davis v The Premier of Bermuda E. David. G. Burt
• R (Al-Sweady and Others) v Secretary of State for Defence (No 2)
• Wilding v British Telecommunications
• Pembroke Road Association v an Bord Pleanála, The Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage
• R (on the application of Davies and another) v HM Revenue and Customs
• R (Goodman and Another) v Lewisham London Borough Council
• R v Broadcasting Standards Commission, ex parte British Broadcasting Corporation
• Devon Hewey v Legal Aid Committee
• Re Ogle Airport Inc.
• Ractabel Trinidad Ltd v Board of Inland Revenue and Atlantic Lng 2/3 Company of Trinidad and Tobago Unlimited
• R v Director General of Water Services and Others
• IBA Health Ltd v Office of Fair Trading
• British Broadcasting Corporation and another v Sugar (No 2)
• Marsha Ramlal v The Ministry of Labour

CITED in

• Andrew Donald McPhee and Another v South Downs National Park Authority Mr and Miss T Leddra and Jones (Interested Party)
• R Fleet Maritime Services (Bermuda) Ltd v The Pensions Regulator
• R v Medicines Control Agency, ex parte Pharma Nord Ltd

[See more]

• R v Broadcasting Standards Commission, ex parte British Broadcasting Corporation
• R v Ministry of Defence, ex parte Walker
• Mercury Communications Ltd v Director General of Telecommunications
• The King v Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd
• Australian Vintage Ltd v Belvino Investments No. 2 Pty Ltd (as trustee of the McGuigan Simeon Trust)
• Société Coopérative de Production SeaFrance S.A. v Competition and Markets Authority and another
• R (Conway) v The Secretary of State for Justice
• R (on the application of ABS Financial Planning Ltd and Others) v Financial Services Compensation Scheme Ltd
• R Chancery (UK) LLP v The Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd Sir Ian Robinson (Interested Party)

COMMENTED in

• R Pratima Das v Secretary of State for the Home Department Mind and Another (Interveners)

DISTINGUISHED in

• R London Christian Radio Ltd and Another (1st Appellant) Christian Communications Partners (2nd Appellant) v Radio Advertising Clearance Centre Secretary of State for Culture Media and Sport (Interested Party)

This document cites

---

• R v Monopolies and Mergers Commission, ex parte South Yorkshire Transport Ltd and Another
• Palser v Grinling Property Holding Company Ltd; Property Holding Company Ltd v Mischeff
• Edwards (Inspector of Taxes) v Bairstow
• Palser v Grinling Property Holding Company Ltd; Property Holding Company Ltd v Mischeff
• DPP v Denning



See all quotations

• R v Silcott ; R v Braithwaite ; R v Raghip
• Transport Act 1985
• Fair Trading Act 1973