Pyrene Company Ltd v Scindia Navigation Company Ltd

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1924 - Articles : S-1
• Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1924 - Articles : S-3
• Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1924 - Articles : SCH-1

[See more]

• Elder, Dempster & Company v Paterson, Zochonis & Company ; Griffiths Lewis Steam Navigation Company v Paterson, Zochonis & Company

DISTINGUISHES

• The Termagant

REFERS TO

• Argonaut Navigation Company Ltd v Ministry of Food, S.s. Argobec
• Les Affréteurs Réunis Société Anonyme v Leopold Walford (London) Ltd
• Wilson and Sons v Owners of Cargo ex Galileo; The Galileo

CITES

• Gilbert Stokes & Kerr Proprietary, Ltd
• Glengarnock Iron and Steel Company, Ltd, v Cooper & Company
• Goodwin Ferreira and Company Ltd v Lamport and Holt Ltd

[See more]

• Harris v Best
• Lickbarrow and Another against Mason and Others
• Sargent against Morris
• Smith and Snipes Hall Farm v River Douglas Catchment Board
• Waters v Monarch Fire & Life Assurance Company
• Waters Trading Company, Ltd v Dalgety & Company, Ltd
• White v John Warwick & Company Ltd
• Wimble, Sons & Company v Rosenberg & Sons
• Argonaut Navigation Company Ltd v Ministry of Food, S.s. Argobec
• Wilson and Sons v Owners of Cargo ex Galileo; The Galileo
• Smith and Snipes Hall Farm v River Douglas Catchment Board

FOLLOWS

• Harland & Wolff v Burns & Laird Lines

CONSIDERED in

• The Owners of Cargo Lately Laden on Board the Ship or Vessel "El Amria" (Plaintiffs v The Owners of The Ship or Vessel "El Amria" (Defendants
• Saffron v Societe Miniere Cafrika
• Jindal Iron and Steel Company Ltd and Others v Islamic Solidarity Shipping Company Jordon Inc.

[See more]

• Volcafe Ltd and Others v Compania Sud Americana de Vapores SA (t/a CSAV)
• MVV Environment Devonport Ltd v NTO Shipping GmbH & Company KG
• Jindal Iron and Steel Company Ltd and Others v Islamic Solidarity Shipping Company Jordon Inc.
• Carmichael Rail Network Pty Ltd v BBC Chartering Carriers GmbH & Company KG
• JI MacWilliam Company Inc. v Mediterranean Shipping Company Sa (the Rafaela S)
• Midland Silicones Ltd v Scruttons Ltd
• Homburg Houtimport BV v Agrosin Private Ltd (Starsin)
• Mohan Karnani v Bookers Shipping (Demerara) Ltd
• Robinson v Somers Isles Shipping Ltd
• Roger Carrington v The University of Trinidad and Tobago
• Karnani v Bookers Shipping (Demerara) Ltd

REFERRED in

• J.I. case (Australia) Pty. Ltd v Tasman Express Line Ltd (The Canterbury Express')
• Bart v British West Indian Airways Ltd
• Compania Sud American Vapores v MS ER Hamburg Schiffahrtsgesellschaft mbH & Company KG [QBD (Comm)]

[See more]

• Ceval International Ltd v Cefetra BV
• Balli Trading Ltd v Afalona Shipping Company Ltd (Coral)
• Sunrise Maritime Inc. v Uvisco Ltd (Hector)
• Ngo Chew Hong Edible Pte. Ltd v Scindia Steam Navigation Company Ltd (Jalamohan)
• Filikos Shipping Corporation of Monrovia v Shipmair B.v
• Yuzhny Zavod Metall Profil LLC v EEMS Beheerder BV (The MV "EEMS SOLAR")
• Saudi Prince, The (No. 2) (Al Dhahran)
• Green v Russell. McCarthy (Third Party)
• Rambler Cycle Company Ltd v P. & O. Steam Navigation Company (Chusan.)
• Trengganu Forest Products Sdn Bhd v Cosco Container Lines
• Metaltex Intl Sdn Bhd v MIF Services Sdn Bhd
• The Rosa S
• Kyokuyo Company Ltd v A.P. Møller — Maersk A/S trading as "Maersk Line"
• Subiaco (S) Pte Ltd v Baker Hughes Singapore Pte
• KMA Abdul Rahim and Another v The Lexa Maersk (Owners) and Others
• PT Soonlee Metalindo Perkasa v Synergy Shipping Pte Ltd (Freighter Services Pte Ltd, Third Party)
• Thermo Engineers Ltd v Ferrymasters Ltd
• Hispanica de Petroleos S.A. v Vencedora Oceanica Navegacion S.A. (No. 2) (Note) (Kapetan Markos N.L., Santillana)
• Scottish & Newcastle International Ltd v Othon Ghalanos Ltd
• Trafigura Beheer BV and Another v Mediterranean Shipping Company SA (The "MSC Amsterdam")
• Pacific Electric Wire & Cable Co Ltd and Another v Neptune Orient Lines Ltd (Toko Kaiun Kaisha Ltd, Third Party)
• Deep Sea Maritime Ltd v Monjasa A/S
• Ismail v Polish Ocean Lines (Ciechocinek)
• Fimbank p.l.c. v KCH Shipping Company, Ltd
• Nori Holding Ltd and Others v Public Joint-Stock Company 'Bank Otkritie Financial Corporation'
• Fimbank Plc v KCH Shipping Company Ltd “Giant Ace”
• AP Moller-maersk A/S Trading as Maersk Line v Kyokuyo Ltd
• Trafigura Beheer BV v Mediterranean Shipping Company SA
• D/S A/S Idaho v Peninsular and Oriental Steam Navigation Company (Strathnewton)
• Datec Electronic Holdings Ltd v United Parcels Service Ltd
• Glencore Grain Rotterdam B.v v Lebanese Organisation for International Commerce (Lorico)
• Parsons Corporation v C v Scheepvaartonderneming Happy Ranger
• Volcafe Ltd and Others v Compania Sud Americana de Vapores SA (t/a CSAV)
• A P Moller-Maersk A/S (Trading as Maersk Line) v Sonaec Villas Cen Sad Fadoul & Others
• Albacora S.R.L. v Westcott & Laurance Line Ltd (The Albacora)
• Fothergill v Monarch Airlines Ltd

CITED in

• Heilbrunn v Lightwood Plc
• Leigh and Sillavan Ltd v Aliakmon Shipping Company Ltd (Aliakmon)
• Seafood Imports Pty Ltd v Anl Singapore Pte Ltd

[See more]

• Parsons Corporation v C v Scheepvaartonderneming Happy Ranger
• N v Handel My J Smits Import-Export v English Exporters (London) Ltd
• SOCIETE DE DISTRIBUTION DE TOUTES MERCHANDISES EN COTE D’IVOIRE, TRADING as "SDTM-CI" and Others v CONTINENTAL LINES NV and ANOTHER (THE "SEA MIROR")
• Mayhew Foods Ltd v Overseas Containers Ltd (Benalder)
• Glencore Grain Rotterdam B.v v Lebanese Organisation for International Commerce (Lorico)
• Sunrise Maritime Inc. v Uvisco Ltd ('The Hector') [QBD (Comm)]
• Hispanica de Petroleos S.A. v Vencedora Oceanica Navegacion S.A. (Kapetan Markos N.L., Santillana)
• Burke (Raymond) Motors Ltd v Mersey Docks and Harbour Company (Manchester Challenge)
• McKAY MASSEY HARRIS PROPRIETARY, Ltd v IMPERIAL CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES of AUSTRALIA & NEW ZEALAND, Ltd, and UNITED STEVEDORING PROPRIETARY, Ltd (THE "MAHIA" (No. 2).)*
• Blandy Brothers & Company, Lda. v Nello Simoni, Ltd
• Wilson v Darling Island Stevedoring and Lighterage Company, Ltd*
• Yuzhny Zavod Metall Profil Llc v Eems Beheerder Bv (The Mv "Eems Solar")
• Societe De Distribution De Toutes Merchandises En Cote D'Ivoire Trading as "Sdtm-Ci" and Others v Continental Lines N.v and Another
• Volcafe Ltd and Others v Compania Sud Americana De Vapores Sa (trading as "CSAV")
• Lewy v Lord Chancellor's Department
• J I MacWilliam Company Inc. v Mediterranean Shipping Company SA ('The Rafaela S') [QBD (Comm)]
• Blandy Brothers & Company, Lda. v Nello Simoni, Ltd
• Bermuda Forwarders Ltd v Wales
• C.H.Z. ‘Rolimpex’C.H.Z. v Eftavrysses Compania Naviera S.A. (Panaghia Tinnou)
• The Arawa
• Evergreen Marine Corporation v Aldgate Warehouse (Wholesale) Ltd
• Saudi Prince, The (No. 2) (Al Dhahran)
• J I MacWilliam Company Inc. v Mediterranean Shipping Company SA
• Compania Sud America Vapores v Hamburg and another
• Renton (G H) & Company Ltd v Palmyra Trading Corporation of Panama (Caspiana)
• Midland Silicones Ltd v Scruttons Ltd
• The "El Amria" and "El Minia"
• Adler v Dickson (Himalaya.)
• Bart v British West Indian Airways Ltd
• Bermuda Forwarders Ltd v Wales
• Bart v British West Indian Airways Ltd

FOLLOWED in

• Peninsular & Oriental Steam Navigation Company Ltd and Others v Rambler Cycle Company Ltd
• Shun Cheong Steam Navigation Company Ltd v Wo Fong Trading Company
• Malaysia Borneo Finance Corporation (M) Bhd v Malayan Produce Company Sdn Bhd

[See more]

• Rapiscan Asia Pte Ltd v Global Container Freight Pte Ltd
• Jindal Iron and Steel Company Ltd and Others v Islamic Solidarity Shipping Company Jordon Inc.
• Edward Robinson v Somers Isles Shipping Ltd

DISTINGUISHED in

• Shivnath Rai Harnarain (India) v The Owners of The Ship or Vessel MV 'Win Moony' (LR 8204846) of The Port of Valletta, Malta
• Ocean Projects Inc v Ultratech Pte Ltd

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1954] 2 All ER 158
• [1954] 1 Lloyd's Rep 321
• 21 ILR 297

[See more]

• [1954] 2 QB 402
• [1954] 2 WLR 1005

APPLIED in

• Alize 1954 and CMA CGM SA v Allianz Elementar Versicherungs AG and 16 Ors
• Renton (G H) & Company Ltd v Palmyra Trading Corporation of Panama (Caspiana)

This document cites

---

• Elder, Dempster & Company v Paterson, Zochonis & Company ; Griffiths Lewis Steam Navigation Company v Paterson, Zochonis & Company
• White v John Warwick & Company Ltd
• Wilson and Sons v Owners of Cargo ex Galileo; The Galileo
• Argonaut Navigation Company Ltd v Ministry of Food, S.s. Argobec
• Waters Trading Company, Ltd v Dalgety & Company, Ltd



See all quotations

• Gilbert Stokes & Kerr Proprietary, Ltd
• The Termagant
• Lickbarrow and Another against Mason and Others
• Sargent against Morris
• Smith and Snipes Hall Farm v River Douglas Catchment Board
• Smith and Snipes Hall Farm v River Douglas Catchment Board
• Harris v Best
• Wilson and Sons v Owners of Cargo ex Galileo; The Galileo
• Argonaut Navigation Company Ltd v Ministry of Food, S.s. Argobec
• Goodwin Ferreira and Company Ltd v Lamport and Holt Ltd
• Parker v North British Railway Company
• Glengarnock Iron and Steel Company, Ltd, v Cooper & Company
• Harland & Wolff v Burns & Laird Lines
• Wimble, Sons & Company v Rosenberg & Sons
• Waters v Monarch Fire & Life Assurance Company
• Les Affréteurs Réunis Société Anonyme v Leopold Walford (London) Ltd
• Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1924