PJ Carroll & Company Ltd v Minister for Health and Children

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Rules of the Superior Courts (Commercial Proceedings), 2004
• Taylor v Clonmel Healthcare Ltd
• Heaney v Ireland

RESUELVE RECURSO

• PJ Carroll & Company Ltd v Minister for Health and Children

REVERSES

• PJ Carroll & Company Ltd v Minister for Health and Children

REFERS TO

• Housing (Private Rented Dwellings) Bill, 1981

CITES

• Ryan v Attorney General
• Enright v Ireland

FOLLOWS

• Brooks Thomas Ltd v Impac Ltd

AFFIRMS

• P J Carroll & Company Ltd and Others v Minister for Health and Children and Others (No. 3)

CONSIDERED in

• Caffrey v Borton & Sheridan
• BAM PPP PGGM Infrastructure Cooperatie UA v National Treasury Management Agency & Min for Education & Skills
• Jones v Grove Turkeys Ltd

[See more]

• Keane v Aer Rianta
• John M. Harrington v Greenway Properties Ltd, Greenway Holdings Ltd and Others, Limbal Ltd, You're Secure Solutions Ltd, Peter Fitzgerald, John Carmody, James Barrett and Martin Barrett
• Coughlan v ESB Wind Development Ltd
• Ryanair DAC v SC Vola.Ro Srl
• Evalve Inc. v Edwards Lifesciences Ireland Ltd

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2006] 6 JIC 0101
• [2006] 3 IR 431

REFERRED in

• Sister Mary Christian and Others v Dublin City Council (No 1)
• Meegan v Times Newspapers Ltd
• Kelland Homes Ltd v Ballytherm Ltd

[See more]

• Boehringer Ingelheim Pharma GmbH v Norton (Waterford) Ltd
• Re Astrazeneca AB
• Hire Services Ltd (E) v an Post
• Dunnes Stores and Another v McCann
• O'Doherty v The Minister for Health
• Miggin (A Minor) v Health Service Executive (HSE) & Gannon

CITED in

• Brady v Wicklow County Council
• Dylan Evans v University College Cork
• IBB Internet Services Ltd v Motorola Ltd

[See more]

• Mustardside - v - Tacre
• Trafalgar Developments Ltd v Mazepin

APPLIED in

• Carol Morrissey and Another v National Asset Management Agency Ltd and Others
• Roche v Roche

DISTINGUISHED in

• Mulholland v an Bord Pleanála

This document cites

---

• Taylor v Clonmel Healthcare Ltd
• P J Carroll & Company Ltd and Others v Minister for Health and Others
• Heaney v Ireland
• Housing (Private Rented Dwellings) Bill, 1981
• Enright v Ireland



See all quotations

• PJ Carroll & Company Ltd v Minister for Health and Children
• P J Carroll & Company Ltd and Others v Minister for Health and Children and Others (No. 3)
• Brooks Thomas Ltd v Impac Ltd
• Ryan v Attorney General
• European Communities (Manufacture, Presentation and Sale of Tobacco Products) Regulations, 2003
• Rules of the Superior Courts (Commercial Proceedings), 2004
• Civil Procedure Rules 1998
• The Rules of the Superior Courts 1986