Orange Ltd v Director of Telecoms (No 2)

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• The State (Lynch) v Cooney
• O'Neill v Beaumont Hospital Board
• R v Bow Street Metropolitan Stipendiary Magistrate, ex parte Pinochet Ugarte (No 2)

[See more]

• R v Gough

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Orange Communications v Director of Telecommunications Regulation & Meteor Mobile Communications Ltd

CONSIDERS

• Postal and Telecommunications Services Act, 1983
• European Communities (Mobile and Personal Communications) Regulations, 1996
• European Communities (Telecommunications Licences) Regulations, 1998

REVERSES

• Orange Communications v Director of Telecommunications Regulation & Meteor Mobile Communications Ltd

REFERS TO

• Anderton v Auckland City Council
• Anheuser Busch Inc. v Controller of Patents
• Balkan Tours Ltd v Minister for Communications

[See more]

• Courtney v Minister for the Marine
• Cronin v Competition Authority & Min Enterprise & Employment
• Dineen v Judge Delap
• William Dimes, - Appellant: The Proprietors of the Grand Junction Canal, T. E. Skidmore, A. Boham, and W. W. Martin, - Respondents
• Dodd and Others v Minister for Fisheries
• Dublin Wellwoman Centre Ltd v Ireland
• Dunne v Minister for Fisheries
• Ellis v Secretary of State for the Environment and another
• Flood v Garda Síochána Complaints Board
• Genmark Pharma Ltd v Minister for Health
• Gill v Connellan
• Golding v Labour Court
• Guiry v Minister for the Marine
• Henry Denny & Sons (Ireland) Ltd v Minister for Social Welfare
• Re Watson ex parte Armstrong
• Locobail (U.K.) Ltd v Bayfield Properties Ltd
• M. J. Gleeson Company v Competition Authority
• McNally v Martin
• Metropolitan Properties Company (F.G.C.) Ltd v Lannon
• Minister of National Revenue v Wrights' Canadian Ropes Ltd
• Needham v Western Regional Fisheries Board
• Ó Cléirigh v Minister for Agriculture, Food and Forestry
• O'Donoghue v an Bord Pleanála
• O'Keeffe v an Bord Pleanála
• O'Neill v Beaumont Hospital Board
• O'Reilly v Cassidy
• Ponnamma v Arumogam
• Radio Limerick One Ltd v Independent Radio and Television Commission
• R v Bow Street Metropolitan Stipendiary Magistrate and Others, ex parte Pinochet Ugarte (No. 1)
• Taylor and Another v Lawrence and Another
• R v Gough (Robert)
• R v Sussex Justices, ex parte McCarthy
• State (Creedon) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Tribunal
• State (Keegan & Lysaght) v Stardust Victims Compensation Tribunal
• State (Lynch) v Cooney
• The State (Sweeney) v Minister for the Environment

FOLLOWS

• McCormack v Garda Síochána Complaints Board

REFERRED in

• Joyce v Minister for Health
• Haverty v Financial Services Ombudsman & ACC Bank Plc
• Quinn Direct Insurance Ltd v Financial Services Ombudsman

[See more]

• Croke v Waterford Crystal Ltd and Irish Pensions Trust Ltd
• Nowak v Data Protection Commissioner
• The Minister for Education & Skills and Another v The Pensions Ombudsman and Another
• R.v (A Minor) v Secretary General of the Department of Education and Science
• Nowak v The Data Protection Commissioner (1)
• Jones v Coolmore Stud
• Agnieszka Nowak v The Data Protection Commissioner
• Nowak v The Data Protection Commissioner
• Redmond and Another v Commissioner for Environmental Information and Another
• McHugh v Kildare County Council
• O'Ceallaigh v Born Altranais & Fitness to Practise Committee of an Bord Altranais
• Meadows v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform
• Three Ireland (Hutchison) Ltd v Commission for Communications Regulation
• Maguire v Ardagh
• Kenny v Trinity College Dublin
• Chubb European Group S.E. v Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman
• Weavering Macro Fixed Income Fund Ltd v PNC Global Investment Servicing (Europe) Ltd (orse BNY Mellon Investment Servicing (International) Ltd)
• North East Pylon Pressure Campaign Ltd v an Bord Pleanála
• Murtagh v Minister for Defence
• Kennedy v DPP
• Chesnokov v an tArd-Chláraitheoir
• Ballyedmond v Commission for Energy Regulation and Ward
• O'Reilly v Commissioner of an Garda Síochána
• Ayadi v DPP
• Savage v Data Protection Commissioner and Another
• Ashford Castle Ltd v Services Industrial Professional Technical Union
• Kelly v Information Commissioner
• O'Flynn Capital Partners v Dún Laoghaire Rathdown County Council
• Rooney v Minister for Agriculture and Food (No 2)
• Lloyds Insurance Company SA v Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman
• Saqib Ahmed v The Fitness to Practise Committee of the Medical Council, The Medical Council, and, (by Order)
• Stanberry Investments Ltd v Commissioner of Valuation
• Adigun v McEvoy
• Houston v Doyle

CONSIDERED in

• Go Ahead Transport Services (Dublin) Ltd (Represented by Stratis Consulting) v Mr Thomas Gifford (Represented by National Bus & Rail Union)
• Michelle Gabriel and Another v Financial Services Ombudsman and Another
• Nicholas Smith and Another v Financial Services Ombudsman and Another

[See more]

• J. v D. v v Refugee Appeals Tribunal and Others
• Vincent Gormley and Another v Minister for Agriculture, Food and Marine (No.2)
• O'Connell v Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman (2)
• De Spáinn v an Coimisiún Um Chosaint Sonraí
• North Wall Property Holding Company Ltd v Dublin Docklands Development Authority
• Murphy v Director of Public Prosecutions
• Nowak v Data Protection Commissioner
• Nowak v The Data Protection Commissioner (1)
• Sandyford Environmental Planning and Road Safety Group Ltd v Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council
• Patrick Kelly v The Visitors of the College of the Holy and Undivided Trinity of Queen Elizabeth near Dublin
• Agnieszka Nowak v The Data Protection Commissioner
• Quinn v Financial Services Ombudsman
• Harry Langley v Teaching Council
• Leslie Buckley v Richard Fleck
• L.C. v K.C.
• Gráinne Ní Mhathuna v Financial Services Ombudsman and Another
• Allied Irish Banks, Plc (and by Order Dated 17th September 2018) Everyday Finance DAC v Seamus McQuaid
• Adegbuyi v Minister for Justice and Law Reform
• Brady v Board of Management of Castleblayney Infant National School and Others
• Director of Public Prosecutions v Kelly & McGrath
• Teoranta v Cafferkey and Others
• Fitzgibbon v Law Society
• Fox v The Data Protection Commissioner
• Three Ireland (Hutchison) Ltd v Commission for Communications Regulation
• Ulster Bank Ireland DAC v Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman
• Lyons and Anor v Financial Services Ombudsman
• Burke v O Longain and Others
• Bula Ltd v Tara Mines Ltd (No. 6)
• M.B. v Minister for Justice
• Fox v The Data Protection Commissioner
• Shannon LNG Ltd and Another v Commission for Energy Regulation and Others
• Nowak v Data Protection Commissioner
• Sandyford Environmental Planning v Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council
• O'Driscoll and Another v Law Society of Ireland and Another
• Right to Know CLG (“RTK”) v Commissioner for Environmental Information
• M. D. [Identity Protected] v Minister for Social Protection
• O'Sullivan v Chief Executive of the Irish Prison Service and Others
• M50 Skip Hire & Recycling Ltd v Commissioner for Environmental Information
• Doolin v The Data Protection Commissioner
• Nurendale Ltd t/a Panda Waste Services v Dublin City Council
• Allied Irish Banks Plc v AIB Mortgage Bank and Others
• Callely v Moylan and Others
• Emer Lally v Board of Management of Rosmini Community School
• Kelly v Trinity College Dublin
• Vodafone Ireland Ltd v Commission for Communications Regulation
• N.I. [A Person of Unsound Mind Not So Found Suing Through His Mother and Next Friend, J.M.] v Minister for Social Protection and Others
• Utmost Paneurope DAC v Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman
• A.R v Child and Family Agency
• Barry Sheehan Practising Under the Style of Barry Sheehan, Solicitor v Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal
• The Trustees of the Vodafone Ireland Pension Plan v Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman
• P (A) v Judge McDonagh
• Baskaran v Financial Services
• Aer Rianta v Aviation Commissioner
• Lloyds Insurance Company SA v Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman
• Lloyd's Insurance Company SA v Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman
• Re Managh International Transport Ltd
• The Data Protection Commissioner v Cormac Doolin
• Esat Digifone Ltd v South Dublin County Council
• Vidette Molyneaux v Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman
• Jerry Beades Construction Ltd v The Right Honourable Lord Mayor Alderman and Burgesses of the City of Dublin and Others
• Allman v Minister for Justice
• Kelly v Minister for Agriculture
• O'Ceallaigh v Bord Altranais & The Fitness to Practise Committee of an Bord Altranais
• Ross v Bank of Scotland Plc
• Irish Life and Permanent Plc v Financial Services Ombudsman
• FBD Insurance Plc v Financial Services Ombudsman & Mongan
• McCormack v Mccormack
• The Marine Survey Office v D'Amico Societá Di Navigazione t/a MV Cielo Di Monaco
• Martin v Coroner for the County of Dublin (Geraghty)
• Clark v Financial Services Ombudsman & Ulster Bank Ltd
• Robert Edward Barry v The Minister for Education and Skills

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2000] 5 JIC 1802
• [2000] 4 IR 159

CITED in

• Joyce v Minister for Health and Children & Others
• O'Regan v Financial Services Ombudsman
• Ivkovic and Another v The Minister for Justice Equality and Law Reform and Another

[See more]

• Craig v Bord Pleanála
• Verschoyle-Greene v Bank of Ireland Provate Banking Ltd
• Kennedy v Courts Service
• Caledonian Life v Financial Services Ombudsman :
• Patrick Gorman and Another v Ombudsman for Defence Forces and Others
• HUME and Others v Judge O'Donnell
• Carrickdale Hotel Ltd v Controller of Industrial & Commercial Property & Phonographic Performance (Ireland) Ltd
• Goode Concrete v CRH Plc
• Efe (A Minor) and Others v Min for Justice and Others
• Conor O'Donoghue v Financial Services Ombudsman and Another
• Hanrahan Farms Ltd v Environmental Protection Agency and Others
• John Higgins v Governor and Company of Bank of Ireland
• O'Driscoll v Hurley and Health Service Executive
• E.P.I. and Others v Minister for Justice Equality and Law Reform
• Weavering Macro Fixed Income Fund Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v PNC Global Investment Servicing (Europe) Ltd
• Diesel SpA v Controller of Patents, Designs and Trademarks

APPLIED in

• Carrickdale Hotel Ltd v Controller of Patents
• King & Others (plaintiffs/ appellants) v Minister for Finance and Civil and Public Service Union (defendant/ respondents) & Minister for Justice, Equality & Law Reform (Notice parties)
• CORCORAN v HOLMES & an GARDA Síochána COMPLAINTS BOARD

[See more]

• R v Child and Family Agency
• De Spáinn v an Coimisiún Um Chosaint Sonraí
• Mary Carty-Doyle v Financial Services Ombudsman and Another
• O'Callaghan and Others v Judge Alan Mahan and Others
• Chesnokov v an tÁrd-Chláraitheoir
• Ulster Bank Investment FundsLimited v Financial Services Ombusdman
• Millar v Financial Services Ombudsman
• The Data Protection Commissioner v Cormac Doolin
• Manorcastle Ltd v Commission for Aviation Regulation
• Ross v Bank of Scotland Plc
• Vehicle Tech Ltd v Commissioner of an Garda Siochana
• Pudliszewski v District Judge John Coughlan & DPP

DISTINGUISHED in

• Glancré Teoranta v Seamus Cafferkey
• Galway City Council v Samuel Kingston Construction Ltd and Another

APPROVED in

• CORCORAN v HOLMES & an GARDA Síochána COMPLAINTS BOARD

FOLLOWED in

• O'Callaghan v Mahon
• Spin Communications Ltd v The Independent Radio and Television Commission

DEPARTED in

• Kelly v Minister for Agriculture

COMMENTED in

• Bluzwed Metals Ltd v Transworld Metals S.A.

This document cites

---

• Convenio Europeo para la Protección de los Derechos Humanos y de las Libertades Fundamentales
• Director of Investigation and Research, Competition Act v. Southam Inc. et al., (1997) 209 N.R. 20 (SCC)
• Locobail (U.K.) Ltd v Bayfield Properties Ltd
• Taylor and Another v Lawrence and Another
• Orange Communications v Director of Telecommunications Regulation & Meteor Mobile Communications Ltd



See all quotations

• R v Bow Street Metropolitan Stipendiary Magistrate, ex parte Pinochet Ugarte (No 2)
• O'Reilly v Cassidy
• Balkan Tours Ltd v Minister for Communications
• State (Creedon) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Tribunal
• Metropolitan Properties Company (F.G.C.) Ltd v Lannon
• Radio Limerick One Ltd v Independent Radio and Television Commission
• The State (Lynch) v Cooney
• O'Neill v Beaumont Hospital Board
• O'Neill v Beaumont Hospital Board
• Gill v Connellan
• State (Lynch) v Cooney
• Dublin Wellwoman Centre Ltd v Ireland
• Needham v Western Regional Fisheries Board
• Golding v Labour Court
• Genmark Pharma Ltd v Minister for Health
• Anheuser Busch Inc. v Controller of Patents
• O'Donoghue v an Bord Pleanála
• McNally v Martin
• Flood v Garda Síochána Complaints Board
• O'Keeffe v an Bord Pleanála
• Guiry v Minister for the Marine
• Cronin v Competition Authority & Min Enterprise & Employment
• R v Gough
• Henry Denny & Sons (Ireland) Ltd v Minister for Social Welfare
• Ellis v Secretary of State for the Environment and another
• R v Sussex Justices, ex parte McCarthy
• Ó Cléirigh v Minister for Agriculture, Food and Forestry
• State (Keegan & Lysaght) v Stardust Victims Compensation Tribunal
• Courtney v Minister for the Marine
• William Dimes, - Appellant: The Proprietors of the Grand Junction Canal, T. E. Skidmore, A. Boham, and W. W. Martin, - Respondents