North Star Shipping Ltd and Others v Sphere Drake Insurance Plc and Others

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Compania de Navegacion Pohing S.A. v Sea Tanker Shipping (PTE) Ltd (Buena Trader)
• Bank of China v NBM LLC
• Nedlloyd Lines UK Ltd and Another v Cel Group Ltd

REFERS TO

• Insurance Corpn of the Channel Islands v Royal Hotel Ltd
• Container Transport International Inc. v Oceanus Mutual Underwriting Association (Bermuda) Ltd
• Pan Atlantic Insurance Company Ltd v Pine Top Insurance Company Ltd

[See more]

• Brotherton v Aseguradora Colseguros SA [QBD (Comm)]
• R v Lucas (Ruth)

APPLIES

• Lamb Head Shipping Company Ltd v Jennings (Marel)
• Rhesa Shipping Company S.A. v Edmunds (Popi M)
• Glowrange Ltd v CGU Insurance (The Moana)

CITES

• Brotherton and Others v Aseguradora Colseguros SA and Another
• Container Transport International Inc. v Oceanus Mutual Underwriting Association (Bermuda) Ltd
• Pan Atlantic Insurance Company Ltd v Pine Top Insurance Company Ltd

DISTINGUISHES

• Chris O'kane (for and on Behalf of Himself, Syndicate 2020 and all Other and Another v Jonathan Jones (for and on Behalf of Himself, Syndicate 329 and all Other Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Policy No. Aa111350t) and Others

CONSIDERS

• Companies Act 1985
• Malicious Damage Act 1861 - Articles : S-58
• Malicious Damage Act 1861

[See more]

• Companies Act 1985
• Marine Insurance Act 1906 - Articles : S-53
• Marine Insurance Act 1906 - Articles : S-18

APPEAL RESOLVED in

• North Star Shipping Ltd and Others v Sphere Drake Insurance Plc and Others

CITED in

• Axa Versicherung AG v Arab Insurance Group (B.S.C.)
• AC Ward & Son Ltd v Caitlin (Five) Ltd and Others
• Sean Robert Delaney v Secretary of State for Transport

APPLIED in

• Meisels and another v Norwich Union Insurance Ltd [Q]

CONSIDERED in

• Niramax Group Ltd v Zurich Insurance Plc
• Atlas Navios-Navegacao Lda v Navigators Insurance Company Ltd; The B Atlantic
• Christopher Simon Jones v Zurich Insurance Plc

[See more]

• Delos Shipholding S.A. v Allianz Global Corporate and Specialty S.E.

REFERRED in

• James Richard Scott Brearley v Higgs & Sons (A Firm)
• Involnert Management Inc. v Aprilgrange Ltd & Others Ais Insurance Services Ltd (First Third Party) Oamps Special Risks Ltd (Second Third Party)
• Persimmon Homes Ltd and Another v First Assist Insurance Service Ltd

[See more]

• Christopher Simon Jones v Zurich Insurance Plc
• Synergy Health (UK) Ltd v CGU Insurance Plc & 3 others
• Lexi Holdings Plc ((in Administration)) v Luqman
• Atlasnavios-Navegacao Lda (formerly Bnavios-Navagacao Lda) v Navigators Insurance Company Ltd and Others

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2005] 1 All ER 112
• [2005] Lloyd's Rep IR 404
• [2005] 2 Lloyd's Rep 76

FOLLOWED in

• Newcastle International Airport Ltd v Eversheds LLP

This document cites

---

• Container Transport International Inc. v Oceanus Mutual Underwriting Association (Bermuda) Ltd
• Chris O'kane (for and on Behalf of Himself, Syndicate 2020 and all Other and Another v Jonathan Jones (for and on Behalf of Himself, Syndicate 329 and all Other Lloyd's Underwriters Subscribing to Policy No. Aa111350t) and Others
• R v Lucas (Ruth)
• Bank of China v NBM LLC
• Nedlloyd Lines UK Ltd and Another v Cel Group Ltd



See all quotations

• Compania de Navegacion Pohing S.A. v Sea Tanker Shipping (PTE) Ltd (Buena Trader)
• Lamb Head Shipping Company Ltd v Jennings (Marel)
• Rhesa Shipping Company S.A. v Edmunds (Popi M)
• Brotherton and Others v Aseguradora Colseguros SA and Another
• Brotherton v Aseguradora Colseguros SA [QBD (Comm)]
• Pan Atlantic Insurance Company Ltd v Pine Top Insurance Company Ltd
• Glowrange Ltd v CGU Insurance (The Moana)
• Pan Atlantic Insurance Company Ltd v Pine Top Insurance Company Ltd
• Container Transport International Inc. v Oceanus Mutual Underwriting Association (Bermuda) Ltd
• Insurance Corpn of the Channel Islands v Royal Hotel Ltd
• Marine Insurance Act 1906
• Malicious Damage Act 1861
• Companies Act 1985