Merck Sharp & Dohme Corporation v Clonmel Healthcare Ltd

Core Citations

CONSIDERS

• American Cyanamid Company v Ethicon Ltd

REFERS TO

• N.W.L. Ltd v Woods
• Doherty v Allman
• Curust Financial Services Ltd v Loewe-Lack-Werk

[See more]

• Educational Company of Ireland Ltd v Fitzpatrick and Others
• Campus Oil Ltd v Minister for Industry and Energy (no 2)
• Dublin Port and Docks Board v Brittania Dredging Company Ltd
• Esso Petroleum Company (Ireland) Ltd v Fogarty
• SmithKline Beecham Plc v Apotex Europe Ltd
• Unilever v Frisa
• Metro International S.A. and Others v Independent News & Media Plc
• Allied Irish Banks Plc and Others v Diamond and Others
• Novartis AG v Hospira Uk Ltd
• Novartis AG v Hospira UK Ltd
• Okunade v Min for Justice and Others
• Allied Irish Banks Plc v Diamond
• Merck Sharp & Dohme Corporation v Clonmel Healthcare Ltd
• Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd v Mylan Teoranta t/a Mylan Institutional

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2019] 7 JIC 3102
• [2020] 2 IR 1

CONSIDERED in

• Neurim Pharmaceuticals (1991) Ltd v Teva UK Ltd
• Harte v Promontoria (Aran) Ltd and Others
• Plus Development LLC and Cooper Plus Holdings Ltd v Lens Media Ltd

[See more]

• Patrick Connolly v O'Dwyer Solicitors LLP
• Coughlan v O'Brien
• Madden v Louth County Council
• Stephen Tennant v Thomas Reidy and Catherine Reidy
• Downes and Howard Ltd v Everyday Finance DAC
• Biogen MA Inc. v Laboratorios Lesvi SL
• Macray Properties Ltd v Sheridan
• Whitemountain Quarries Ltd v Donegal County Council
• Brendan O'Reilly and Darren O'Reilly v Promontoria (Finn) Ltd, Paul McCleary, Jimmy Murphy and Damien Harper
• Creaby v Allied Irish Banks Plc
• David Langan v Promontoria (Oyster) DAC, Damien Harper and Link Asset Services DAC
• Macray Properties Ltd v Sheridan
• EC v Health Service Executive
• Donal O'Donovan v Over-C Technology Ltd and Over-C Ltd
• Patrick Hennessy v Ken Tyrell and Everyday Finance Designated Activity Company
• Ewins v Promontoria Scariff Designated Activity Company and Another
• Scriven v Scriven and Another
• Three Ireland (Hutchison) Ltd v Commission for Communications Regulation
• Farrington v Promontoria (Oyster) DAC
• Burke v O Longain and Others
• Buttimer v Oak Fuel Supermarket Ltd Trading as Costcutter Rathcormac
• McGirr v Everyday Finance DAC
• Friends of the Irish Environment Clg v Roscommon County Council Ireland and The Attorney General
• CHC Ireland DAC v The Minister for Transport
• Owens v Kildare County Council
• M & J Duddy Developments Ltd v Everyday Finance DAC and Others
• Pat Ryan v Dengrove Dac
• Fox v Walshe and Others
• Aviareto Ltd v Global Closing Room Ltd
• Dowdall and Another v O'Caoimh and Others
• Gregory Heffernan v Mater Private
• Downey v Everyday Finance DAC
• Bristol-Myers Squibb Holdings Ireland Company v Norton (Waterford) Ltd Trading as TEVA
• O'Reilly and Another v Promontoria (Finn) Ltd and Others
• Byrne and Others v Arnold
• Everyday Finance DAC v Gleeson
• Monkswood Investments Ltd v Everyday Finance DAC
• Monkswood Investments Ltd v Everyday Finance DAC
• O'Connor v Promontoria [Aran] Ltd ; M&F Finance (Ireland) Ltd v Promontoria [Aran] Ltd
• Campbell v The Irish Prison Service and Another
• O'Donovan v Over-C Technology Ltd and Another
• Coulston v Doyle
• Ryanair Designated Activity Company v Skyscanner Ltd and Others
• Tyrrell and Another v Govan
• Miceal Sammon and Cathy Sammon v Ken Tyrrell and Everyday Finance Dac
• Creganna Ltd v Cullen and Another
• McLoughlin and Another v Fennell and Others
• Duddy Hospitality Ireland Holdings Ltd and Others v Propiteer Ireland Holdings Ltd and Others
• Nolan v Science Foundation Ireland
• Rajpal v HSE
• Word Perfect Translation Services Ltd v The Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform
• Emer Lally v Board of Management of Rosmini Community School
• Wendy Jennings v an Bord Pleanala, Ireland and The Attorney General
• Dunne v Board of Management of Little Angels
• Rory Mason v ILTB Ltd T/A Gillen Markets and Dermot Browne
• Claddagh Jewellers Ltd v Companies Act 2014
• Foot Locker Retail Ireland Ltd v Percy Nominees Ltd
• Oysters Shuckers Ltd T/A Klaw v Architecture Manufacture Support (EU) Ltd
• Farrell v Everyday Finacnce DAC and Others
• Nihill v Everyday Finance DAC
• Eircom Ltd v Commission for Communications Regulation
• Construgomes & Carlos Gomes SA v Dragados Ireland Ltd, BAM Civil Engineering and Banco BPI SA
• Construgomes v Dragados Ireland Ltd and Ors
• Fennell v Slevin
• Claddagh Jewellers Ltd v Companies Act 2014
• Phoenix Rock Enterprises t/a Frank Pratt & Sons v Hughes
• Michael Hoey v Waterways Ireland
• Ryan v Dengrove DAC
• Martin Casey and David Casey v Everyday Finance Dac and David O'Connor
• Patrick Hennessy v Ken Tyrell and Everyday Finance Designated Activity Company
• Kelly v Gerard Murphy Purported Liquidator of Kelly Trucks Ltd ((in Liquidation)) No.1
• O'Brien and Another v Markham and Others
• Hafeez v CPM Consulting Ltd
• Start Mortgages Designed Activity Company v Kavanagh and Others
• Rogers and Another v Allied Irish Banks Plc and Others
• Mahon v Yeronga Ltd and Others
• The Alfred Beit Foundation v Egar
• Start Mortgages DAC v Noel Rogers and Una Rogers
• Sutton v Salumi Grazing Ltd T/A Salumi Grazing and Others
• K.W. Investment Funds ICAV v Lorgan Leisure Ltd
• Leahy and Another v Bank of Scotland Plc and Others
• Biogen MA Inc. v Laboratorios Lesvi SL
• Novartis Pharma AG v Eli Lilly Nederlands B.v
• MD v The Board of Secondary School
• Merck Sharp & Dohme LLC v Mylan Ire Healthcare Ltd and Mylan Ireland Ltd and McDermott Laboratories T/A as Gerard Laboratories T/A as Mylan Dublin
• Cavernbell Ltd v Padraig Walsh
• Aer Lingus and Others v Irish Aviation Authority
• Gradual Investments v Grant
• Doran v Charleton
• Beades v Keegan and Another
• Gary Keville Transport Ltd v MSC (Mediterranean Shipping Company) Ltd
• QQ v Board of Management of a School
• Bristol Myers Squibb Holdings Ireland Unlimited Company v Norton (Waterford) Ltd
• McKenna v Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC and Another
• Remcoll 2 Ltd v Walsh
• Paddy Burke (Builders) Ltd ((in Liquidation) and (in Receivership)) v Tullyvaraga Management Company Ltd
• Board of Management of Wilson's Hospital School v Burke
• Merck Sharp & Dohme LLC v Mylan IRE Healthcare Ltd and Others
• Munnelly v Cooke and Another
• Enright v Ballybeggan Park Company Ltd
• Byrne and Others v Arnold
• O'Hagan v Harper and Another
• Cahill v Beacon Hospital Sandyford Ltd
• Flogas Ireland Ltd v North West Gas Company Ltd
• H.A. O'Neil Ltd v Unite the Union and Others
• Thompson v Tennant
• McCarthy v McCarthy
• Jean Connors v Daniel Kinsella
• O'Brien v Murphy
• Foy v University of Limerick
• Everyday Finance DAC and Another v Gormley
• Rm v Shc
• Bristol-Myers Squibb Holdings Ireland v Norton (Waterford) Ltd T/A Teva Pharmaceuticals Ireland
• Murphy v McKeown
• Fennell v Reilly and Another
• Lindat Ltd v The PW Plaza Café Bar Ltd
• Emerald Sky 2 DAC and Others v Victoria Homes Ltd and Others
• DRM Contract Administration Ltd v Proton Technologies AG
• Benson Fuels Ltd v Flogas Ireland Ltd
• Waterford City and County Council v Centz retail Holdings Ltd
• Kelly v Murphy and Another (No. 2)
• Connolly v BRGA Ltd T/A BRG Gibson Auctions and Others
• Betty Martin Financial Services Ltd v EBS DAC
• Cluid Housing Association v Anthony Whelan and Sylvia Whelan
• O'Flaherty's (Nassau Street) Ltd v Setanta Centre Unlimited Company
• Sheehan v Breccia Irish Agricultural Development Company and Ors
• First Modular Gas Systems Ltd v Citibank Europe Plc and Others
• Fried v Fried (2)

REFERRED in

• Harte v Promontoria (Aran) Ltd and Others
• Promontoria (Finn) Ltd and Another v O'Neill and Others
• Donal O'Donovan v Over-C Technology Ltd and Over-C Ltd

[See more]

• Clare County Council v McDonagh
• Trinity College Dublin v Kenny
• Krikke v Barranafaddock Sustainability Electricity Ltd
• CHC Ireland DAC v The Minister for Transport
• Owens v Kildare County Council
• Pat Ryan v Dengrove Dac
• Fennell v Slevin and Others
• Campbell v The Irish Prison Service and Another
• Creganna Ltd v Cullen and Another
• Foot Locker Retail Ireland Ltd v Percy Nominees Ltd
• Word Perfect Translation Services Ltd v The Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform
• Roderic O'Beirne v Bank of Scotland Plc
• Foot Locker Retail Ireland Ltd v Percy Nominees Ltd
• Michael Hoey v Waterways Ireland
• Rogers and Another v Allied Irish Banks Plc and Others
• Connors v Kinsella
• Tennant v Reidy
• Start Mortgages DAC v Noel Rogers and Una Rogers
• Biogen MA Inc. v Laboratorios Lesvi SL
• MD v The Board of Secondary School
• Cavernbell Ltd v Padraig Walsh
• Gradual Investments v Grant
• The Board of Management of Wilson's Hospital School v Enoch Burke
• Bristol Myers Squibb Holdings Ireland Unlimited Company v Norton (Waterford) Ltd
• Byrne and Others v Arnold
• Bristol-Myers Holdings Ireland Unlimited Company v Norton (Waterford) Ltd
• Murphy v McKeown
• Betty Martin Financial Services Ltd v EBS DAC
• Ryanair Designated Activity Company v Skyscanner Ltd, Skyscanner Holdings Ltd, and Skyscanner 2018 Ltd

CITED in

• Three Ireland (Hutchison) Ltd v Commission for Communications Regulation
• Bristol Myers Squibb Holdings Ireland Unlimited v Patents Acts 1992 to 2019; Bristol Myers Squibb Holdings Ireland Unlimited v Norton (Waterford) Ltd T/A Teva Pharmaceuticals Ireland
• Blythe v The Commissioner of an Garda Slochána

[See more]

• Wendy Jennings and Adrian O'Connor v an Bord Pleanála, Ireland and The Attorney General
• Tyrrell and Another v Govan
• First Modular Gas Systems Ltd v Citibank Europe Plc and Others

APPLIED in

• Rajpal v HSE
• Farrell v Everyday Finacnce DAC and Others
• Phoenix Rock Enterprises t/a Frank Pratt & Sons v Hughes

[See more]

• Clare County Council v Bernard McDonagh and Helen McDonagh
• Plus Development LLC v Lens Media Ltd

This document cites

• SmithKline Beecham Plc v Apotex Europe Ltd
• Allied Irish Banks Plc and Others v Diamond and Others
• American Cyanamid Company v Ethicon Ltd
• R and Another v Birmingham City Council
• SmithKline Beecham Plc v Apotex Europe Ltd



See all quotations

• Curust Financial Services Ltd v Loewe-Lack-Werk
• Metro International S.A. and Others v Independent News & Media Plc
• Merck Sharp & Dohme Corporation v Clonmel Healthcare Ltd
• Okunade v Min for Justice and Others
• Warner-Lambert Company Llc v Teva UK Ltd and Others
• Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd v Mylan Teoranta t/a Mylan Institutional
• Novartis AG v Hospira Uk Ltd
• Warner-lambert Company Llc v Sandoz Gmbh and Others
• N.W.L. Ltd v Woods
• Allied Irish Banks Plc v Diamond
• Unilever v Frisa
• Esso Petroleum Company (Ireland) Ltd v Fogarty
• Campus Oil Ltd v Minister for Industry and Energy (no 2)
• Dublin Port and Docks Board v Brittania Dredging Company Ltd
• Educational Company of Ireland Ltd v Fitzpatrick and Others
• Novartis AG v Hospira UK Ltd
• Doherty v Allman
• Directive 2001/83/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 6 November 2001 on the Community code relating to medicinal products for human use
• Directive 2001/82/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 6 November 2001 on the Community code relating to veterinary medicinal products
• Note In The Cause (first) Astrazeneca Ab And (second) Astrazeneca Uk Limited Against Teva Uk Limited