McDonald v Horn

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Supreme Court (now known as Senior Courts) Act 1981 - Articles : S-51

REFERS TO

• Chapman and Others v Chapman and Others
• Re Charge Card Services Ltd
• Re Dallaway, decd

[See more]

• Davies (Joy Rosalie) v Eli Lilly & Company
• Re Evans, decd
• Re Exchange Securities & Commodities Ltd
• Smith v Croft
• Re Vauxhall Motors Pension Fund
• Ritter v Godfrey
• Re Buckton. Buckton v Buckton
• Civil Service Co-operative Society v General Steam Navigation Company
• Beddoe, Re, Downes v Cottam
• Re Mills' Estate, ex parte Commissioners of Works and Public Buildings
• Imperial Group Pension Trust Ltd and Others v Imperial Tobacco Ltd and Others

APPLIES

• Interbulk Ltd (Appellants) Aiden Shipping Company Ltd (Respondents) I.C.C.O. International Corn Company N.v (Respondents) Interbulk Ltd (Appellants)
• William Kurt Wallersteiner (Plaintiff Appellant) M. J. G Moir (Defendant Respondent) M. J. G Moir (Plaintiff on counterclaim) William Kurt Wallersteiner Hartley Baird Ltd and Another (Defendants on counterclaim)

CONSIDERED in

• Charlesworth Nominees Pty Ltd v Charlesworth
• Diamond v Mansfield
• Sir Arthur David Chessels and Others v British Telecommunications Plc and Others

[See more]

• Reading Entertainment Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 070 893 908) and Anor v Whitehorse Property Group Pty Ltd (Provisional Liquidator Appointed (ACN 074 074 150)) and Ors
• Machin (Plaintiff) v National Power Plc and Others
• Kation Pty Ltd v Lamru Pty Ltd; Lewis v Nortex Pty Ltd (in Liquidation)
• National Westminster Bank (Applicant/Claimant) v Luke Lucas and Others (Respondent/Defendant)
• Vanta Pty Ltd v Mantovani [No 2]
• Barrett v Barrett
• AvSuper Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Managed Investments Ltd
• Tony Arida v Sid Arida
• Rattigan v Hanly
• An v Joo (No 2)
• Axa Equity and Law Life Assurance Society Plc Axa Sun Life Plc the Insurance Companies Act 1982
• Hitesh Gandesha v Narendra Gandesha
• Eweida v British Airways Plc
• Mary Kathryn Leslie (in her personal capacity and as a trustee of the Mary Lawrence Childrens Settlement) v Robert James Ball
• Thakbar v Johal and Freakley
• Abdullah v Abdullah
• Jadavji Ramji Hirani and Others v Manji Jina Hirani and Others
• David Anthony James(First Appellant) v Marea Gilbert ((First Respondent)
• Wilton UK Ltd (Suing on Behalf of Itself as Shareholder in Banks Mount Oswald Ltd, The Fifth Defendant) v John Michael Shuttleworth
• Delta Electricity v Blue Mountains Conservation Society Inc.
• Cristiana Crociani; A (by her Guardian ad Litem, Nicholas Delrieu); B (by her Guardian ad Litem, Nicholas Delrieu) v Edoarda Crociani; Paul Foortse; BNP Paribas Jersey Trust Corporation Ltd; Appleby Trust (Mauritius) Ltd; HRH Princess Camilla De Bourbon Des Deux Siciles; Camillo Crociani Foundation IBC (Bahamas) Ltd; BNP Paribas Jersey Nominee Company Ltd
• Trilogy Management Ltd v YT Charitable Foundation (International) Ltd; HM Attorney General; OM — LC2 Charitable Foundation International; The Empowerment Charitable Trust; The Saving Grace Charitable Trust; OM — VC5 Charitable Foundation; The Well Trust; Mrs C
• Bertrand des Pallières v JP Morgan Chase & Company
• B v Erinvale PTC Ltd
• Ibm United Kingdom Pensions Trust Ltd v (1) Mr George Metcalfe (2) Ibm United Kingdom Holdings Ltd and Another
• Powell v Powell
• Boston Trust Company Ltd v Szerelmey Ltd
• R v Lord Chancellor, ex parte Child Poverty Action Group
• Henry John Northey v Jennifer Frances Juul
• Charlotte Swift v Malcolm Carpenter
• George v Ford, Wilson, Collymore and Guardian Life of the Caribbean Ltd
• Whakatohea Kotahitanga Waka (Edwards) v Ngati Ira O Waioweka, Ngati Patumoana, Ngati Ruatakenga and Ngai Tamahaua (Te Kahui Takutai Moana O Nga Whanau Me Nga Hapu O Te Whakatohea)
• HM Attorney General v Zedra Fiduciary Services (UK) Ltd
• Mccallum Jnr v Mccallum and Others as Trustees of The Mccallum Family Trust
• Montag Trustee Services Ltd v Grossberg Fiduciaries Ltd
• The Companies Act (2020 Revision) and Adenium Energy Capital, Ltd (in Official Liquidation)
• Adenium Energy Capital, Ltd
• The Companies Act (2018 Revision) and China Shanshui Cement Group Ltd Between: Tianrui (International) Holding Company Ltd Petitioner v China Shanshui Cement Group Ltd First Respondent Asia Cement Corporation Second Respondent China National Building Material Company Ltd Third Respondent
• Christopher Felix v Republic Bank Ltd and Methanol Holdings (Trinidad) Ltd
• Wong, Wen-Young v Grand View Private Trust Company Ltd
• Anita Doreen Mussell v Christopher Edward Keith Patience
• Ann Maxine Patton v Alvarez, Jimenez, De Pass, S.A. A/K/A
• Wilkinson v Kitzinger and Another (Same-sex marriage)
• Wingate v Butterfield Trust (Bermuda) Ltd
• Belgravia Internation Bank & Trust Company Ltd et Al v CIBC Trust Company Bahamas Ltd
• Damian Lines (as administrator of the Estate of Mrs NE Brock, deceased) v Maureen Wilcox
• The Companies Act (2023 Revision) and Direct Lending Income Feeder Fund, Ltd (in Official Liquidation)
• Lopez v Telecommunications Services of Trinidad & Tobago
• HR Trustees v German
• Pauline Ann Price v Valery Ann Saundry
• Oracle Fund Ltd, Re ((in Liquidation))
• Certain Ltd Partners in Henderson PFI Secondary Fund II LLP (A Firm) v Henderson PFI Secondary Fund II LP (A Firm)and Others
• The Companies Act (2023 Revision) and Direct Lending Income Feeder Fund, Ltd (in Official Liquidation)
• Farrell et Al v Colonial Life Insurance Company (Trinidad) Ltd et Al
• DJ (Junior), DS (Senior) and SW v AR and NK (Grand Cayman) (a Bank)
• Re Portsmouth City Football Club Ltd; Neumans LLP v Andronikou and Others
• Seuradge et Al
• Trustee L and Others v Attorney General and Others
• Asbestos Injuries Compensation Fund Ltd (and WorkCover Queensland) (No 2)

CITED in

• Re Axa Equity and Law Life Assurance Society Plc (No 2). ; Re Axa Sun Life Plc (No 2)
• Frost v Bovaird
• Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Re Gdk Financial Solutions Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) v Gdk Financial Solutions Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) (No 4)

[See more]

• Bradstock Trustee Services Ltd v Nabarro Nathanson [ChD]
• Motor Vehicles Insurance Ltd v Woodlawn Capital Pty Ltd
• Re SPhinX Group
• Jolyon Toby Dennis Maugham QC v Uber London Ltd
• Inderjit Singh Bhullar v Jatinderjit Singh Bhullar and Others
• Woodward v Smith and Others
• Trustee L and ors v Attorney General and ors
• Trustee L and Others v Attorney General and Others
• Junior Mills and Norval Thompson v Stainton Knott & Anormp; Ors
• Trustee L v Attorney General
• Neumans LLP (A Firm) v Andrew Andronikou and Others
• Morgan and Another v Hinton Organics (Wessex) Ltd and Others

REFERRED in

• Wilson v Law Debenture Trust Corporation Ltd
• Bradstock Trustee Services Ltd v Nabarro Nathanson (A Firm)
• Airways Pension Scheme Trustee Ltd v Mark Owen Fielder

[See more]

• Patrick James Gordon Pettigrew and Others v Edwin Colin Neale Edwards
• Blades v Isaac and another
• Serious Organised Crime Agency v Szepietowski
• Alsop Wilkinson v Neary and Others
• Karen Pegler v Timothy Bruce McDonald
• Charlotte Swift v Malcolm Carpenter
• Wingate v Butterfield Trust (Bermuda) Ltd
• UC Rusal Alumina Jamaica Ltd and Others v Wynette Miller and Others
• Pauline Ann Price v Valery Ann Saundry
• R v Lord Chancellor, ex parte Child Poverty Action Group
• R (Corner House Research) v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry
• Christine Mary Green (as Administratrix of the Estate of Peter Maclean Maitland Deceased) (Claimant/ Applicant) v Richard Joseph Astor and Others
• Village Residents Association Ltd v an Bord Pleanála (No 2)

APPLIED in

• Hitesh Gandesha v Narendra Gandesha
• Bridge Trust Company Ltd v Att Gen
• Barclays Private Bank & Trust Ltd v McLaughlin

FOLLOWED in

• Re Cotorro Trust

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1995] 1 All ER 961
• [1995] ICR 685

DISTINGUISHED in

• Gayle (Maxwell) and Others v Desnoes and Geddes Ltd and Others

RELIED UPON in

• Lawrence Ewan McGaughey v Universities Superannuation Scheme Ltd

This document cites

---

• Re Charge Card Services Ltd
• Chapman and Others v Chapman and Others
• William Kurt Wallersteiner (Plaintiff Appellant) M. J. G Moir (Defendant Respondent) M. J. G Moir (Plaintiff on counterclaim) William Kurt Wallersteiner Hartley Baird Ltd and Another (Defendants on counterclaim)
• Re Norfolk's (Duke of) Settlement Trusts
• Interbulk Ltd (Appellants) Aiden Shipping Company Ltd (Respondents) I.C.C.O. International Corn Company N.v (Respondents) Interbulk Ltd (Appellants)



See all quotations

• Scherer v Counting Instruments Ltd (Note)
• Nurcombe v Nurcombe
• Holden & Company v Crown Prosecution Service (No. 2)
• Ridehalgh v Horsefield; Watson v Watson (Wasted Costs Orders)
• Dagnell and Another v J L Freedman & Company (A Firm) and Others
• Aiden Shipping Company Ltd v Interbulk Ltd (Vimeira)
• Davies (Joy Rosalie) v Eli Lilly & Company
• Ritter v Godfrey
• Civil Service Co-operative Society v General Steam Navigation Company
• Re Courage Group's Pension Schemes
• Re Dallaway, decd
• Exchange Securities and Commodities Ltd, Re (No 2)
• Re Vauxhall Motors Pension Fund
• Re Westdock Realisations Ltd
• Re Charge Card Services Ltd
• Re Evans, decd
• Beddoe, Re, Downes v Cottam
• Imperial Group Pension Trust Ltd and Others v Imperial Tobacco Ltd and Others
• Re Berkeley Applegate (Investment Consultants) Ltd
• Cowan v Scargill
• Thrells Ltd v Lomas
• Davies (Joseph Owen) v Eli Lilly & Company
• Re Buckton. Buckton v Buckton
• Re Exchange Securities & Commodities Ltd
• Re Biddencare Ltd
• Re Imperial Foods Ltd Pension Scheme
• Smith v Croft
• Re Mills' Estate, ex parte Commissioners of Works and Public Buildings
• Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1890
• Courts Act, 1981