Hughes v Lord Advocate

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Overseas Tankship (U.K.) Ltd v Morts Dock and Engineering Company Ltd (The Wagon Mound)
• Woolley v Ministry of Health; Roe v Ministry of Health

[See more]

• Carmarthenshire County Council v Lewis
• Harvey v Singer Manufacturing Company

REFERS TO

• Haynes v Harwood
• Miller v South of Scotland Electricity Board

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Hughes v Lord Advocate

REVERSES

• Hughes v Lord Advocate

DISTINGUISHES

• Glasgow Corporation v Muir

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1963] UKHL J0221-3
• [1963] 1 All ER 705
• 1963 SC HL 31

[See more]

• [1963] 2 WLR 779
• [1963] AC 837

REFERRED in

• McSherry v British Telecom
• Low v R J Haddock Ltd and Another; Carrick v Same
• Aquator Shipping Ltd v Kleimar N.v (Capricorn I)

[See more]

• Transworld Oil Ltd v North Bay Shipping Corporation (Rio Claro)
• Hobbs (E.) (Farms) Ltd v Baxenden Chemical Company Ltd
• Squires v Perth and Kinross District Council
• Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board
• Wieland v Cyril Lord Carpets Ltd
• Wilson v Coulson
• Hepworth v Kerr
• Tremain v Pike
• Griffiths v Taylor
• Ruaro v Holcomm Marine Pty Ltd
• Markose v Epsom & St Helier NHS Trust
• Griffiths v Arch Engineering Company (Newport) Ltd
• Europe Mortgage Company Ltd v GA Property Services Ltd
• Hay v Dowty Mining Equipment Ltd
• Navios Enterprise, The (Puritan)
• Pryke v Gibbs Hartley Cooper Ltd
• Owners and charterers of the Navios Enterprise v Owners of the Puritan [QBD (Admiralty)]
• Anthony and Others v The Coal Authority
• Craig Sparrow v Arnaud Andre
• Dovuro Pty Ltd v Wilkins
• McAlpine (Sir Robert) & Sons Ltd v Minimax Ltd
• Cheong Fatt Tze Mansion Sdn Bhd v Hotel Continental Sdn Bhd (Hong Hing Thai Enterprise Sdn Bhd)
• The Chief Constable of Hampshire Police v Kerry Ann Taylor
• Massey v Unifi
• Robb Appellant Against Salamis (M & I) Ltd (Formerly Known as Salamis Marine & Industrialltd) Respondents
• O'Neill v DSG Retail Ltd
• McDonald (Deceased) v National Grid Electricity Transmission Plc
• Sylvie Aya Agouman v Leigh Day (A Firm)
• Stewart v West African Terminals Ltd
• Corr v IBC Vehicles Ltd
• Crown River Cruises Ltd v Kimbolton Fireworks Ltd and Another
• Claire Busby v Berkshire Bed Company Ltd
• Ehmler and Another v Hall
• Ogwo v Taylor
• Chadwick v British Railways Board
• Jaensch v Coffey
• Hunter v British Coal Corporation and Others
• Christopher Edwards v London Borough of Sutton
• Saqib Khan and Another v Harrow Council and Another
• Anne Mitchell+karin Mitchell (aps) V. Glasgow City Council
• Gray v Thames Trains Ltd and another
• Groom v Selby
• Rubenstein v HSBC Bank Plc
• Donaghey v Boulton & Paul Ltd
• Ohoud Al-Najar (a protected party by her litigation friend Khadia Al-Mulla) v The Cumberland Hotel (London) Ltd
• Alexis Maitland Hudson v Solicitors Regulation Authority
• Khan v Meadows
• Mullin v Richards
• Banque Financiere de la Cite S.A. (formerly Banque Keyser Ullmann S.A.) v Westgate Insurance Company Ltd (formerly Hodge General & Mercantile Company Ltd); Banque Keyser Ullmann S.A. v Skandia (U.K.) Insurance Company Ltd
• Page v Smith
• Ms Lorna Armstead v Royal Sun Alliance Insurance Company Ltd
• McLoughlin v O'Brian
• Videan v British Transport Commission
• Pearson Education Ltd v The Charter Partnership Ltd
• South Australia Asset Management Corpn v York Montague Ltd (also known as Banque Bruxelles Lambert S.A. v Eagle Star Insurance Company Ltd)
• Holbeck Hall Hotel Ltd and Another v Scarborough Borough Council
• Reeves v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis
• Corr v IBC Vehicles Ltd
• Smith v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd; Maloco v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd
• Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v Miller Steamship Company Pty (Wagon Mound) (No. 2)
• Parsons (H.) (Livestock) Ltd v Uttley Ingham & Company Ltd
• Smith v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd; Maloco v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd
• Robinson v Post Office

CONSIDERED in

• Green v Sunset & Vine Productions Ltd & Others
• Tompkins v Royal Mail Group Plc
• Ivor Desmond Bloomfield v Albany Roofing Services Ltd

[See more]

• Hadlow v Peterborough City Council
• Sullivan v South Glamorgan County Council
• Dennis Augustine Kelly v Cedo Construction Ltd
• Laurence James Ehmler and Adrian James Harris (Respondents (Plaintiffs) v Steven John Hall (Appellant
• Victoria Nonaolapo Subuloye (Plaintiff) Robert Bailey (Defendant)
• Kuwait Airways Corporation (Plaintiff) v Iraqi Airways Company (body Corporate)
• Helen Renner (Plaintiff v Wirral Health Authority (Defendant
• Terence Mulcahy (Plaintiff) The British Steel Corporation (Defendants)
• Kiani (as Personal Representative of the late Abdul Kiani) v Land Rover Ltd and Ors
• Edith Vera Thompson v H. & E. Knowles (Lye) Ltd
• Victor Maurice Sands (Plaintiff) (Appellant) National Coal Board (corporate body) (Defendants) (Respondents)
• Brian Albert Thirkettle v The Square D Ltd
• John Smith v National Coal Board
• Janet M Robb (Widow of David Main Robb Deceased) (Respondent/Plaintiff) v Ft Everard & Sons Ltd
• Graham (Plaintiff) v Esso Petroleum Ltd
• Jeffrey Parker and David Anthony Parker (by their mother and next friend Ethel Parker) (Plaintiffs Appellants) v Thompsn (Defendant Respondent)
• Sinead Ryan (an infant who sues by her father and next friend John Ryan) (Appellant (Plaintiff) v The London Borough of Camden (Respondent
• Gerrard v Staffordshire Potteries Ltd
• Dennis James Canet v Peter William Hales
• H.P. Bulmer Plc v Daniel Oldham
• MacPherson v Proprietors of Strata Plan 10857 and Another
• Michael Winston Sanby v R
• National Australia Bank Ltd v Nemur Varity Pty. Ltd
• John Urquhart (Appellant - Plaintiff) v Limehouse Paperboard Mills Ltd (Respondents - Defendants)
• Robert Parton (Appellant - Plaintiff) v Ductile Group Services Ltd (Respondents - Defendants)
• Tambree v Travel Compensation Fund and Others
• Arthur Ernest Pearce (Plaintiff) v Gibbons (Dudley) Ltd
• Ben Peter Anderson v The Territory Insurance Office Board
• Barry Martin v Hendersons Industries Pty. Ltd
• Ryan Spreadborough v Kevin John McDonald [NTMC]
• Sally Lillington v Gregory Ansell and Another
• Steven Keating v Andrew Hurrell and Another
• Kristopher Hicks (A protected party by his mother and litigation friend Gillian Hicks) v Michael Young
• Susan Cecelia Matthews v Tameika Almal Matthews (Administratrix and Co-Administratrix of the Estate of Demol Kenlish James, Deceased, of Barrouallie)
• McGovern v British Steel Corporation
• White v Malco
• Paul v Cooke
• Julie Patricia Edwards v Endeavour Energy
• Ryan v State Rail Authority of New South Wales
• Hemsley v Lindsay
• NSW Land & Housing Corporation v Watkins
• Michael Anthony Bastard Mcnamara (Plaintiff/Appellant) v North Tyneside Metropolitan Borough Council
• Billington v Maguire and Another
• Eckersley and Others v Binnie & Partners and Others
• Idris Farah (by his litigation friend Fatuma Mohamad) v Ahmed Abdullahi
• Scott v Gavigan
• Garry v Sisk
• Christopher Jebson v Ministry of Defence
• Madden v Elliott
• Reeves v Carthy
• Surtees v Kingston-upon-Thames Borough Council; Surtees v Hughes and Another
• Wade v Connolly
• British & Commonwealth Holdings Plc and and Others v British & Commonwealth Holdings Plc and and Others
• Metrolink Victoria Pty Ltd v Inglis
• Merryn Elizabeth McKenna v Hunter & New England Local Health District
• General Insurance Ltd (AMP) v Roads & Traffic Authority of New South Wales
• Arscott v The Coal Authority
• Teachers v Julian
• Michael Gilman v Ups Ltd and Another
• X v Hounslow London Borough Council
• Southern Colour (Vic) Pty Ltd(Applicant) v Michael Parr (First Respondent)
• Matthew Morgan (an Infant by Janice Morgan His Mother and Next Friend) (Plaintiff (Appellant) George Blunden and Jenny Johnson (Sued on Their Own Behalf and on Behalf of All Other Persons Who Were Members of The Bingfield Adventure Playground Management Committee) (Defendants (Respondents) Jason Reilly (an Infant Suing by His Father and Next Friend Anthony Matthew Reilly) (Plaintiff (Appellant) George Blunden, David Forbes and Jenny Johnson (Sued on Behalf of Themselves and All Other Members of The Bingfield Adventure Playground Interim Managment Committee) (Defendants (Respondents)
• Ogwo v Taylor
• Webster & Others v Ridgeway School
• Mr Brian James Lear v Hickstead Ltd and Another
• Trustees of London Clinic v Michael Alan Edgar
• Mr Allan Hodgson v Creation Consumer Finance Ltd
• Independent Broadcasting Authority (formerly Independent Television Authority) (First Respondents (Plaintiffs) v E.M.I. Electronics Ltd (Second Respondents (First Dfs.) Bicc Construction Ltd (formerly British Insulated Callender's Construction Company Ltd) (Appellants (Second Dfs.) Royal Exchange Assurance (Third Party)
• Rosenberg v Percival
• Gittani Stone Pty. Ltd v Pavkovic
• Susan Cecelia Matthews v Julian Glasgow
• Green v Sunset & Vine Productions Ltd & Others
• John Hill v Ministry of Justice
• Great North Eastern Railway Ltd v Gary Neil Hart
• Patrick George McGurk v J. P. Mauger Ltd
• Iona Nicola McKay Hotchkiss v Channel Islands Knitwear Company Ltd
• Tapp v Australian Bushmen's Campdraft & Rodeo Association Ltd
• Mr Philip James Clay v TUI UK Ltd
• Fitzsimons v Telecom Éireann
• Minors v Simon et Al
• Simmons v British Steel Plc; British Steel Plc v Simmons
• Corr (Administratrix of Corr, deceased) v IBC Vehicles Ltd
• Clare v Perry (t/a Widemouth Manor Hotel)
• Keino Barnett v Roland Byfield
• KY v Bahler,
• Tomlinson v Congleton Borough Council and another
• Donoghue v Folkestone Properties Ltd
• Jolley v Sutton London Borough Council
• John Dawson V. Ruth Page
• Essa v Laing Ltd
• Kuwait Airways Corporation v Iraqi Airways Company (Nos 4 & 5)
• Ashrafi Persian Trading Company Pty Ltd T/as Roslyn Gardens Motor Inn and Another v Ashrafinia
• Attorney General of the British Virgin Islands v Hartwell
• Miguel Fernander v Neptune Watertoys Ltd d/b/a Blue Adventures
• Alverine Witter v Gore Development Ltd
• Brendan Berichon v The Queen
• Spencer v Wincanton Holdings Ltd
• Rubenstein v HSBC Bank Plc
• Orange v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police
• Banque Financiere de la Cite S.A. (formerly Banque Keyser Ullmann S.A.) v Westgate Insurance Company Ltd (formerly Hodge General & Mercantile Company Ltd); Banque Keyser Ullmann S.A. v Skandia (U.K.) Insurance Company Ltd
• The Attorney General Appellant v Craig Hartwell Respondent
• Jebson v Ministry of Defence

CITED in

• Gordon v Wilson and Others
• Brown v Lewisham and North Southwark Health Authority
• Dowson v Sunderland Hospitals NHS Trust

[See more]

• Bailey v Gore Bros Ltd
• Ray McCalla v Atlas Protection Ltd and Ringo Company Ltd
• Mgica (1992) Ltd (Formerly Mgica Ltd) v Kenny & Good Pty Ltd
• Eastman Chemical International A.G. v N.M.T. Trading Ltd
• The Trecarrell
• Murphy v William Henderson and Sons, Ltd; McBride v Same
• Minors v Simon and Douglas
• Deborah Waller v Dr Christopher James
• British & Commonwealth Holdings Plc v Quadrex Holdings Inc.
• Kuwait Airways Corporation v Iraqi Airways Company
• Christopher Goldscheider v Royal Opera House Covent Garden Foundation
• Neindorf v Junkovic
• March v Stramare (E and Mh) Pty Ltd
• Uni-Ocean Lines PTE. Ltd v C-Trade S.A. (Lucille)
• Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd v Conarken Group Ltd and another
• Jason Lowdon (Appellant/Claimant) v Jumpzone Leisure UK Ltd (Respondent/Defendant)
• Loraine v Wirral University teaching hospitals NHS foundation trust
• Ms Lydia Graves (Claimant/ Appellant) v Mr Marinus Gerardus Brouwer
• Pearson Education Ltd v The Charter Partnership Ltd
• Hide v The Steeplechase Company (Cheltenham) Ltd and Others
• Conole v Redbank Oyster Company
• Holbeck Hall Hotel Ltd and Another v Scarborough Borough Council
• Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd v Conarken Group Ltd and another

FOLLOWED in

• Hanna (Erro)l v University of the West Indies
• Perre v Apand Pty Ltd
• Perre v Apand

[See more]

• Chan Loo Khee v Lia Siew San
• Saatchi & Saatchi Pte Ltd and Others v Tan Hun Ling (Clarke Quay Pte Ltd, Third Party)

APPLIED in

• Sullivan v South Glamorgan County Council
• Malcolm v Broadhurst
• Bradford v Robinson Rentals Ltd

[See more]

• ST (a Protected Party by his mother and Litigation Friend, KT) v Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust
• Sonia Wilson v Muffler Specialist Ltd
• Jolley v Sutton London Borough Council
• Draper v Hodder

DISTINGUISHED in

• Crossley v Rawlinson
• Strong Wise Ltd v Esso Australia Resources PTY Ltd (The "APL Sydney")
• Doughty v Turner Manufacturing Company Ltd

[See more]

• Banque Financiere de la Cite S.A. (formerly Banque Keyser Ullmann S.A.) v Westgate Insurance Company Ltd (formerly Hodge General & Mercantile Company Ltd); Banque Keyser Ullmann S.A. v Skandia (U.K.) Insurance Company Ltd

This document cites

---

• Miller v South of Scotland Electricity Board
• Woolley v Ministry of Health; Roe v Ministry of Health
• Carmarthenshire County Council v Lewis
• M'Alister or Donoghue (Pauper) v Stevenson
• Glasgow Corporation v Muir



See all quotations

• King v Phillips
• Thurogood v Van Den Berghs & Jurgens Ltd
• Haynes v Harwood
• Harvey v Singer Manufacturing Company
• Hughes v Lord Advocate
• Overseas Tankship (U.K.) Ltd v Morts Dock and Engineering Company Ltd (The Wagon Mound)
• Crown Suits (Scotland) Act 1857
• Occupiers' Liability (Scotland) Act 1960