Guinness Plc v Saunders and Another

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Le Seignior Mounteagle port Action sur le Case envers Eliz. Countess de Wore
• Lennard Mownt port action de Trus & le Case fuit tiel un John Sleyer ch per
• Un Case que vient en l'Eschequer fuit referr de estre consider a les 2. Chief

[See more]

• Phipps v Boardman

REFERS TO

• Aberdeen Railway Company v Blaikie Brothers
• Re Macadam. Dallow v Codd
• Barrett v Hartley

[See more]

• New Sombrero Phosphate Company v Erlanger

RESUELVE RECURSO

• Guinness Plc v Saunders and Another

AFFIRMS

• Guinness Plc v Saunders and Another

CONSIDERS

• Hely-Hutchinson v Brayhead Ltd
• Companies Act 1985 - Articles : S-317
• Companies Act 1985 - Articles : S-727

[See more]

• Companies Act 1948 - Articles : S-199

DISTINGUISHES

• Phipps v Boardman
• Re Duomatic Ltd
• Craven-Ellis v Canons Ltd

APPLIES

• Bray v Ford

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1990] UKHL J0208-3
• (1990) 108 NR 44
• [1990] 1 All ER 652

[See more]

• [1990] BCLC 402
• [09/02/1990] TLR 2
• [1990] 2 AC 663
• [1990] 2 WLR 324

CONSIDERED in

• Alan Peter Whalley (the Liquidator of MBA Investment Management Ltd) v George Malcolm Doney and Another (Repondents)
• Maple Mechanical Services Ltd and Another (Plaintiff) v 1. Brian John Maddox and Others
• Intercontinental Bank v Erastus Bankole Oladipo Akingbola and Others

[See more]

• Craven Textile Engineers Ltd v Batley Football Club Ltd
• Tajik Aluminium Plant v Abdukadir Ganievich Ermatov and Others
• Robert Lee and Others (Claimant/Appellant) v Clarke Osborne and Others
• R v Secretary of State for Education, ex parte Prior
• E-Clear (UK) Plc (Applicant/Claimant) v Elias Elia and Others (Respondent/Defendant)
• Specialist Group International Ltd v Richard Simon Deakin and Another
• Environmental Recycling Technologies Plc and Another v Daley
• Eastbourne Borough Council v Foster
• Specialist Group International Ltd v Deakin and Another
• Kirby v Dental Council of New South Wales
• Krupace Holdings Pty Ltd v China Hotel Investments Pty Ltd and Others
• Akierman Holdings Pty Ltd v Akerman (No 2)
• Hanco ATM Systems Ltd v Cashbox ATM Systems Ltd and Others
• Global Corporate Ltd v Dirk Stefan Hale
• Silver v Dome Resources NL
• Cobbetts Llp and Another v Mark Reginald Stuart Hodge
• Mudgee Dolomite & Lime Pty Ltd v Robert Francis Murdoch; Mudgee Dolomite & Lime Pty Ltd
• Shepherd & Company Solicitors v Mr Peter Ian Brealey
• Peter Ian Brealey v Shepherd & Company Solicitors
• AI Airports International Ltd (formerly known as Meinl Airports International Ltd); PI Power International Ltd (formerly known as Meinl International Power Ltd) v Bjorn Pirrwitz
• WELLINGTON AUDIO VISUAL Ltd and Ors v EURO BOSTON GROUP Ltd and Anor HC AK
• Kapa-Watene and Others as Trustee of Te Uri O Hau Settlement Trust v Latimer and Others
• Liquidator of Marini Ltd v Dickenson
• Murad and Another v Al-Saraj and Another
• Buckingham Homes Ltd v Peter Malcolm Rutter
• Recovery Partners GP Ltd Revoker LLP v Mr Irakli Rukhadze
• K. & A. LAIRD (N.S.W.) Pty Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v AIDZAN Pty Ltd ((in Liquidation)) in its own capacity and in its capacity as trustee of the Peter Laird Trust, the Peter Alan Laird Property Trust (known as the PAL Property Trust) and the Aidzan Superannuation Fund
• Harris v Digital Pulse Pty Ltd
• News International Plc and Others (Plaintiffs) v Michael Clinger and Others
• Thompson (John) and Janet Thompson v Goblin Hill Hotels Ltd, Mies Investments Ltd, Marvin Goodman and Rosalie Goodman
• British Caribbean Bank Ltd v Johnston International Ltd ((in Liquidation))
• Zambia v Meer Care and Others
• Murad and Another v Al-Saraj and Another
• Jonathan David Bass v MS Bronia Rachel Buchanan
• Medcalf v Mardell and Others
• Clico Investment Bank Ltd v Louis Andre Monteil
• Ancient Order of Foresters in Victoria Friendly Society Ltd v Lifeplan Australia Friendly Society Ltd
• Fairford Water Ski Club Ltd v Craig Ronald Cohoon
• Hotel Portfolio II UK Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Andrew Joseph Ruhan
• Autumn Holdings Asset Inc. v Renova Resources Private Equity Ltd (suing as a shareholder of the Second Defendant/Respondent, Pallinghurst (Cayman) General Partner LP (GP) Ltd)
• Short v Crawley (No. 30)
• Lee Panavision Ltd v Lee Lighting Ltd
• Stephen John Hunt (as the Liquidator of Wow Internet Ltd) v Qasim Majid
• Mactaggart v Church Street Investments Ltd; Church Street Investments Ltd v Mactaggart
• Hickox v Leeward Isles Resorts Ltd
• Instant Access Properties Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Mr Bradley John Rosser
• Sunrise Radio Ltd and Another (Petitioner) v Dr Avtar Lit and Others

CITED in

• Secretary of State for Business Innovation and Skills Petitioner Against Thomas Banks Hamilton Respondent
• Cobbetts LLP and another v Hodge
• Quarter Master UK Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Pyke and Others

[See more]

• Lehman Brothers; CRC Credit Fund Ltd and Others v GLG Investments Plc (Sub-Fund: European Equity Fund) and Others
• Re Ciro Citterio Menswear Plc ((in Administration)), Ciro Citterio Menswear Plc and Others v Thakrar and Others
• Stuart Knight and Another v Gower Kneller Frost and Others
• Chirnsize and Another v Fay
• Chirnside and another v Fay
• Re Sunrise Radio Ltd; Kohli v Lit and Others
• Ravenhart Service (Holdings) Ltd, Re, Reiner v Gershinson
• Gwembe Valley Development Company Ltd v Koshy and Another
• Crown Dilmun and Another v Sutton and Another
• Clark v Cutland
• FHR European Ventures LLP and Others v Mankarious and Others
• Lloyd Christopher Biscoe v Graham William Milner
• Whalley v Doney; Re MDA Investment Management Ltd
• Jonathan David Bass v MS Bronia Rachel Buchanan
• Peter Dooley v Anthony Carmelos Norris
• Global Energy Horizons Corporation v Mr Robert Gresham Gray
• Fairford Water Ski Club Ltd v Craig Ronald Cohoon
• Timothy Colin Hamilton Ball (Liquidator of PV Solar Solutions Ltd) and Another v Paul James Hughes and Another

REFERRED in

• Nuneaton Borough AFC Ltd, Re (No 2)
• CIMB Bank Bhd v Jaring Communications Sdn Bhd
• Shanxi Weixin Construction Engineering Company Ltd v Chang Tong Lee and Another

[See more]

• Tan Sri Dato’ Tajudin Ramli and Another v Technology Resources Industries Bhd
• Avel Consultants Sdn Bhd and Another v Mohd Zain Yusof and Others
• Pharmmalaysia Bhd v Dinesh Kumar Jashbhai Nagjibha Patel
• Wong See Yaw and Another v Bright Packaging Industry Bhd
• Interactive Technology Corporation Ltd v Jonathan Ferster (First Defendant)
• Fairford Water Ski Club Ltd v Cohoon and another
• Cowan de Groot Properties Ltd v Eagle Trust Plc
• Kathryn Mary Clevely v Janet Mary Atkinson (as personal representative of the estate of Barbara Frances Campbell deceased)
• Peter Ian Brealey v Shepherd & Company Solicitors
• Recovery Partners GP Ltd v Mr Irakli Rukhadze
• Robert Gresham Gray v Global Energy Horizons Corporation
• Henry George Dickinson v Nal Realisations (Staffordshire) Ltd
• Ultraframe (UK) Ltd v Fielding
• Hotel Portfolio II UK Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Andrew Joseph Ruhan
• Derby & Company Ltd v Weldon (No. 1)
• Kenneth Davies v Stephen Ford
• The Serious Fraud Office v Litigation Capital Ltd (a company incorporated in the Marshall Islands) and Others
• R v Panel on Take-overs and Mergers, ex parte Guinness Plc

FOLLOWED in

• Avel Consultants Sdn Bhd and Another v Mohd Zain Yusof & 2 Ors

APPLIED in

• Hampshire Cosmetic Laboratories Ltd v Mutschmann and Cayman National Bank
• Recovery Partners GP Ltd v Mr Irakli Rukhadze

ADOPTED in

• Mona Computer Systems (S) Pte Ltd v Singaravelu Murugan

This document cites

---

• Bray v Ford
• Hely-Hutchinson v Brayhead Ltd
• Guinness Plc v Saunders and Another
• Phipps v Boardman
• Phipps v Boardman



See all quotations

• Un Case que vient en l'Eschequer fuit referr de estre consider a les 2. Chief
• Aberdeen Railway Company v Blaikie Brothers
• Barrett v Hartley
• Re Macadam. Dallow v Codd
• Craven-Ellis v Canons Ltd
• Le Seignior Mounteagle port Action sur le Case envers Eliz. Countess de Wore
• Re Duomatic Ltd
• New Sombrero Phosphate Company v Erlanger
• Lennard Mownt port action de Trus & le Case fuit tiel un John Sleyer ch per
• Companies Act 1985
• Companies Act 1948