Grovit and Others v Doctor and Others

Core Citations

---

CITES

• Practice Statement (Judicial Precedent)

CONSIDERS

• Caughie v Robertson & Company

CONSIDERS

• Birkett v James
• Department of Transport v Chris Smaller (Transport) Ltd

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1997] UKHL J0424-1
• [1997] 2 All ER 417
• [25/04/1997] TLR 1

[See more]

• [1997] 1 WLR 640
• [1997] CLC 1038

CONSIDERED in

• Luke v Wansbroughs (A Firm)
• Orrin v Ashcroft
• Harsha Padhiar and Others v Ranji Patel and Others

[See more]

• Urbanski (Plaintiff) v Chamberlain (Ex Manchester District Registry)
• Mohamed Al-fayed v Emanouel Antiques Ltd
• Lace Co-Ordinates Ltd v Nem Insurance Company Ltd
• R v The Immigration Appeal Tribunal and Another
• Josselyne Cohen v Kingsley Napley
• Tag Capital Ventures Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Gary Potter
• Harry Hedges and Another v Stephen James Jackson
• Alphonso Bishop v Felton & May (A Firm)
• Jolen Holdings Pty Ltd v Bella Barista Pty Ltd (deregistered) and ors
• Orbit Developments (Southern) Ltd v McCarthy & Stone (Developments) Ltd
• J M Greening (Male) and E J Greening and Another (Claimants (Plaintiffs)/Respondents) v R Williams (male)
• Paul Mckenna (Plaintiff) v European Journal of Clinical Hypnosis and Others
• Smith and Others v London Borough of Bromley and Another
• Al-Fayed v Emanouel Antiques Ltd
• Jessup v Wetherell
• Austin v Newcastle Chronicle and Journal Ltd
• Eve Michaela Davey (Plaintiff v Chester Health Authority (Defendant
• Co-Operative Retail Services Ltd v Guardian Assurance Plc
• The Queen v Snowcrest Ltd and and Another (Respondent/Plaintiff)
• David Becker (Plaintiff/Appellant) v Baileys Shaw & Gillet (A Firm)
• Girdharimal Choraria (Plaintiff v Nirmal Kumar Sethia (Defendant
• Zaibunnisha Ashraf Shikari and Another (Shikari- deceased) v Manzur Malik
• Pamela Ann Watson v James Edward Woodhouse
• Barratt Manchester Ltd v Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council
• The Queen (on the application of Anthony Nelson) v The Parole Board of England and Wales
• Stephen Patrick Morrissey v (1) Connor Conicholas (2) Ipc Media Ltd
• Target Holding Ltd (Claimant/Appellant) v Brian David Oxborough and Others
• Adelson and Another v Vanderson and Another
• David Matthias Miles (Plaintiff/Appellant) v Ian Michael Mcgregor
• Kincardine Fisheries Ltd v Sunderland and Marine Mutual Insurance Company Ltd and Another (First and Second Respondents)
• Dhanodad et Al v Nelson et Al
• Ibe (Plaintiff) v London Weekend Television
• Robert Lawrence Weston (Claimant/ Respondant) v Kenneth William Bates (First Defendant/ Appellant) Leeds United Football ClubSecond
• Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc (and Others) v Baglan Abdullayevich Zhunus (formerly Baglan Abdullayevicj Zhunussov) and Others
• Purcell Meats (Scotland) Ltd v Intervention Board for Agricultural Produce
• Sanders v Percy and Another
• Re Vitara Foods Ltd
• Re Jayden
• Sourian v State of NSW
• Gill v Eatts and Another: Gill v ABC & 2 Ors
• Metal Manufactuers v Nautitech P/L & 2 Ors
• HRH Prince Idriss Al-Senussi v Shahid Hussain and Others
• Habib Bank Ltd v Gulzar Haider Jaffer and Another
• Neufville v Papamichael
• Bank of India (Plaintiff/Appellant) v 1. Rajendra Makanjibhai Patel and Others
• Kenneth Edward Rogers and Another (Appellants) Rhys Evans (A Firm)and Others (Respondents)
• Geoffrey John Mitchell and Another v Buckingham International Plc and Others
• UCB Corporate Services Ltd (Formerly UCB Bank Plc) (Claimant/Appellant) v Halifax (SW) Ltd
• Lesley Hird v Milner and Another
• Ucb Corporate Services Ltd and Another (Claimant/Appellant) v Halifax (sw) Ltd
• Neufville v Papamichael
• Serdar Mohammed v Ministry of Defence
• Dermot Gerard Richard Walsh (Appellant/Claimant) v Andre Martin Misseldine (Respondent/Defendant)
• Madarassy v Nomura International Plc
• Katsouris Brothers Ltd v Haitoglou Bros S.A. (Defendant/Applicant)
• Kerschbaumer v Voisin and Company
• FG Hemisphere Associates
• Gurney Consulting Engineers v Gleeds Health & Safety Ltd and Gleeds Management Services Ltd
• Telstra New Zealand Holdings Ltd v Commissioner of Inland Revenue Hc Ak
• Securum Finance Ltd v Ashton and another
• Sheldon Gary Adelson and Another v Debbie anderson and Another
• Fay v Chief Constable of Bedfordshire Police
• Watford Control Instruments Ltd v Colin Brown
• Morgan Sindall Construction and Infrastructure Ltd v Capita Property and Infrastructure (Structures) Ltd
• Morgan Sindall Construction and Infrastructure Ltd v Capita Property and Infrastructure (Structures) Ltd
• Craig Lloyd v Richard Hayward
• Louise Keith v Michah Lucian Alexander Benka
• Joe Macari Servicing Ltd v Chequered Flag International Inc.
• Bank of America Europe DAC (formerly Merrill Lynch International Bank Ltd) v Citta Metropolitana Di Milano
• Re K (Deceased)
• Adelson v Associated Newspapers Ltd
• Ghouse Abdul Wahab (Appellant/Claimant) v Amir Khan and Others (Respondents/Defendants)
• Kadian Sandcroft v Reliable Industries Ltd
• Miguel Angel Gomez Martinez Plaintiff v The Proprietors, Strata Plan No. 46 (Plantation Village) Defendant
• Dorthy Messam v Kirk Market Ltd
• Dorthy Messam v Kirk Market Ltd
• Ronham & Associates Ltd v Christopher Gayle and Mark Wright [Consolidated Appeals]
• Beverley Mcmain v Trevor Anthony Carby
• CVM Television v Fabian Tewarie
• Suisse Security Bank and Trust Ltd v Harajchi et Al
• Symonette v Checkers Café (Bahamas) Ltd et Al
• Ballord et Al v Sun International Bahamas Ltd and Paradise Enterprises Ltd
• High Point Development Company Ltd v Bahamas Hotel Catering and Allied Workers Union et Al
• Mead, Horace v CIBC (Ja) Ltd & Attorney General of Jamaica
• Saunders v Bahamasair Holding Ltd and Moss
• Hofer v Bermuda Hospitals Board
• Mackey v Island Hotel Company Ltd
• Holder v Life of Barbados
• Sandals Royal Management Ltd v Mahoe Bay Company Ltd
• Solomon's Funeral Home Ltd and Calmore Solomon v Errol Solomon
• Grupo Torras S.A. v Skeikh Fahad Mohammed Al Sabah
• Anderson et Al v Bain et Al
• Bussoz et Al v Thiery
• Edwards v Johnson
• Ernie Christian v Clive Edwards
• Wolsey et Al v Bahamas Electricity Corporation
• Ballantyne, Beswick & Company (A Firm) v Jamaica Public Service Company
• Werner Fuhrken Batista v Dietrich Fuhrken Batista
• West v Survance et Al
• David A. Penn v Registrar of Corporate Affairs
• Michael Lorne v The Gleaner Company, Wyvolyn Gager & Glen Cruickshank
• Werner Fuhrken Batista v Dietrich Fuhrken Batista
• The Private Trust Corporation Ltd v Vohra et Al
• Clinton Smith v Jamaica Public Service Company Ltd
• Farrington et Al v Island Hotel Company Ltd
• Christopher Cargill v James Godfrey; Maurice Gabay v MJC Masterbuilders Ltd
• Gerville Williams and Others v Commissioner of Independent Commission of Investigations and Others
• Flexnon Ltd v Constantine Michell
• Beverley Nicholls v Ralph Thorne
• Tajo Beharry v BWIA International Airways Ltd
• Between Meldine Powell (by her Guardian Etta Lou Robinson) Plaintiff v Randy McLean Alfred McLean (Administrators of the Estate of Alfred Lawrence Powell) Respondents
• Atkinson v Corbin and Armstrong
• John Woodside v Caribbean Health & Fitness Ltd et Al
• Mr Ali Fozan Alfozan v Mr Husamaldean Alrasheed
• Jimmy Bailey v WM. E. Meyer & Company Ltd
• Sylvan Clement Francis v Paul Pearson
• Icebird Ltd v Winegardner
• Atkins v Restonic Caribbean Ltd and Sealy
• Between: Magdalyn Burlington Plaintiff v Butterfield Bank (Cayman) Ltd Defendant
• Wendy Willis Johnson v KEITHRELL HANNA
• Icebird Ltd v Winegardner
• Stellar Energy Ltd v Renward Wells
• Nadkins Ltd v Saunders et Al
• Minnis v Insurance Company of the Bahamas Ltd
• Between “A” Applicant v “R” Respondent
• Willers v Joyce (No 1)
• Firstcaribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Sunset Village Inc.
• David A. Penn v Registrar of Corporate Affairs
• Chairman v Saunders
• Balkissoon v Persaud and J.S.P. Holdings Ltd
• Fritz Pinnock v Financial Investigations Division
• Major Consulting Ltd v Cibc Trust Company (Bahamas) Ltd
• Michael Wilson and Partners Ltd v Robert Colin Nicholls and Others
• Firstcaribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Sunset Village Inc.
• Neville Davidson v Serge Island Dairies
• Miguel Angel Gomez Martinez Plaintiff v The Proprietors, Strata Plan No. 46 (Plantation Village) Defendant
• Camille Patricia Thompson v Gavin Whyte
• The Central Bank of Ecuador et Al v Ansbacher (Bahamas) Ltd as Trustee of Conticorp Bahamas Trust et Al
• Moses v Charles et Al
• Embassy Investments Ltd Plaintiff v 1. Ascot Corporate Name Ltd (for and on Behalf of Itself and All Other Members of Syndicate 1414 At Lloyd's) 2. Faraday Capital Ltd (for and on Behalf of Itself and All other Members of Syndicate 435 at Lloyd's) 3. Simon King (for and on Behalf of Himself and All Other Members of Syndicate 2010 at Lloyd's) 4. Württembergische Versicherung Ag 5. Ecclesiastical Insurance Company Ltd 6. Houston Casualty Company 7. Simon White (for and on Behalf of Himself and All Other Members of Syndicate 1200 at Lloyd's) 8. 9. Christine Dandridge (for and on Behalf of Herself and All Other Members of Syndicate 609 at Lloyd's) 10. Talbot 2002 Underwriting Capital Ltd (for and on Behalf of Itself and All Other Members of Syndicate 1183 at Lloyd's) 11. Catlin
• Television Jamaica Ltd v CVM Television Ltd
• “A” v “R”
• West Indies Petroleum Ltd v Courtney Wilkinson

CITED in

• Owners &/or Bailees of the Cargo of the Ship Panamax Star v Owners of the Ship Auk
• Phelps v Button
• Smyth (Scheherazade) v Professor James Nixon

[See more]

• Beckett (Beatrice Maeve) and Shane Lawton Beckett v Anthony Robert William Beckett and Evangeline Jemima Beckett
• McLaughlin & others v London Borough of Lambeth
• Hofer v Bermuda Hospitals Board (ruling on strike-out)
• First Caribbean International Bank (Jamaica) Ltd (formerly CIBC (Ja) Ltd) and Attorney General of Jamaica v Horace Meade
• Tapper (Melanie) v First Global Bank Ltd
• Elm Hardware Distributors Ltd v Elsie Taylor, Unice Snape and CSR Properties Ltd
• Michael Witter Appellant v Cox Lumber Ltd Respondent
• Mohammed Zaman v Paradise UK Ltd
• Aktas v Adepta
• Gladys Scatliffe (Widow and intended personal Representative of the Estate of Jacinto Scatliffe) Claimant/Respondent v The BVI Health Services Authority Defendant/Applicant

REFERRED in

• Artibell Shipping Company Ltd v (1) Markel International Insurance Company Ltd (2) Other Underwriters Subscribing to the Policy of Marine Insurance Referred to in the Claim Form
• Arbuthnot Latham Bank Ltd v Trafalgar Holdings Ltd Chishty Coveney & Company v Ibrahim Khan Raja
• Manches and Company v Joseph

[See more]

• Southern Empire Development Sdn Bhd v Tetuan Shahinuddin & Ranjit (disaman sebagai sebuah firma)
• Heng Weng Chin and Others; Public Bank Bhd
• Transcom Rand (M) Sdn Bhd v MARA Holdings Sdn Bhd
• Bank Pembangunan Malaysia Bhd v Abdul Razak Sheikh Mahmood
• Yogananthy as Thambaiya v Idris Osman
• Public Bank Bhd v Heng Weng Chin
• Board of Trustees of the Sabah Foundation v Datuk Syed Kechik bin Syed Mohamed
• Fung Lai Chuen (f) and Another; Mayban Securities Sdn Bhd
• Jasa Keramat Sdn Bhd v Monatech (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd
• The "Tokai Maru"
• Ineos Upstream Ltd v Persons unknown Entering or Remaining without the Consent of the Claimant(s) on Land and Buildings Shown Shaded Red on the Plans Attached to the Amended Claim Form
• Kolden Holdings Ltd v Rodette Commerce Ltd and Another
• Audergon v Law Baguette Ltd
• Grenda Investments Ltd v Philip Barton
• Fg Hemisphere Associates Llc v Democratic Republic of Congo and La Generale Des Carrieres Et Des Mines
• Prudential Assurance Company Ltd v McBains Cooper (A Firm) and Others
• Josselyne Cohen v Kingsley Napley
• Barratt Manchester Ltd v Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council
• Goshawk Aviation Ltd v Terra Aviation Network S.A.S.
• Solland International Ltd and Others (Claimants/Appellants) v Clifford Harris & Company
• Watford Control Instruments Ltd v Colin Brown
• Dr Fatima Jabbar v Aviva Insurance UK Ltd
• Société Générale v Goldas Kuyumculuk Sanayi Ithalat Ihracat A.S. and Others
• Keith Hudson, Clandale Sheckleford, Winston Letts and Carmen Letts v Vernon Smith and Alwyn Smith
• Follett (Maria) v Bournville Briscoe, Edward Mendez, Lenworth Thomas and Ricardo Thomas
• Alcan Jamaica Company v Herbert Johnson et Al
• Joshua Beacon v Inspector Ford & Attorney General
• RBTT Bank Jamaica Ltd v YP Seaton, Earthcrane Haulage Ltd and YP Seaton & Associates Company Ltd; YP Seaton v RBTT Bank Jamaica Ltd [Consolidated Suits]
• Carr (Lambert) and Colleen Carr v Dudley Burgess
• Attorney-General v Administrator-General of Jamaica (Administrator of the Estate Elaine Evans, deceased)
• Desmond v MGN Ltd
• Jeyaretnam Joshua Benjamin v Lee Kuan Yew
• Aljawharah Bint Ibrahim Abdulaziz Alibrahim v Asturion Fondation
• London Borough of Havering v Persons Unknown
• Sylvan Clement Francis v Paul Pearson
• Leeson v Marsden another
• R v Immigration Appeal Tribunal, ex parte S

FOLLOWED in

• Hongkong Bank Malayia Bhd v Tan Tock Sing
• Heng Weng Chin and Others; Public Bank Bhd
• Mayban Securities Sdn Bhd v Fung Lai Chuen and Another

[See more]

• MARA Holdings Sdn Bhd; Transcom Rand (M) Sdn Bhd
• Omega Securities Sdn Bhd v Public Bank Bhd
• Jasa Keramat Sdn Bhd v Monatech (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd

DISTINGUISHED in

• Geninvest SA v Bank of Butterfield Intl
• Avonwick Holding Ltd v Azitio Holdings Ltd
• Charles Ridley v Dubai Islamic Bank PJSC

[See more]

• Louise Keith v Michah Lucian Alexander Benka

APPLIED in

• R Harrold v Nursing & Midwifery Council
• Choraria v Sethia
• Reid (Spurgeon) v Corporal Lobban and Attorney General for Jamaica

[See more]

• Arbuthnot Latham Bank Ltd v Trafalgar Holdings Ltd

RELIED UPON in

• Geo-Minerals GT Ltd v Geo-Minerals (Holdings) Ltd
• Richards Lorenzo v United Car Rentals Ltd & Osmond Bernard
• Glen Morgan v Attorney General of Jamaica

This document cites

---

• Birkett v James
• Department of Transport v Chris Smaller (Transport) Ltd
• Practice Statement (Judicial Precedent)
• Caughie v Robertson & Company
• Grovit and Others v Doctor and Others