Federal Commerce & Navigation Company Ltd v Molena Alpha Inc. (Benfri, Lorfri, Nanfri)

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Sea and Land Securities Ltd v William Dickinson & Company Ltd

REFERS TO

• Hong Kong Fir Shipping Company Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd
• Hanak v Green
• Mardorf Peach & Company Ltd v Attica Sea Carriers Corporation of Liberia (Laconia)

[See more]

• George Russell v Anthony Snider Pellegrini
• Gilbert Ash (Northern) Ltd v Modern Engineering (Bristol) Ltd
• Morgan & Son v Martin Johnson & Company
• Steelwood Carriers Inc. of Monrovia, Liberia v Evimeria Compania Naviera S.A. of Panama (Agios Giorgis)
• Mersey Steel and Iron Company v Naylor Benzon & Company
• Smyth (Ross T.) & Company Ltd v T. D. Bailey, Son & Company
• Tankexpress A/S v Compagnie FinanciŠre Belge Des Petroles S.A.
• Associated Bulk Carriers Ltd v Koch Shipping Inc.
• Mottram Consultants Ltd v Bernard Sunley & Sons Ltd
• United Scientific Holdings Ltd v Mayor, Aldermen and Burgesses of the County Borough of Burnley now The Council of the Borough of Burnley
• Tagart, Beaton & Company v James Fisher & Sons
• Halcyon Steamship Company Ltd v Continental Grain Company
• Nippon Yusen Kaisha v Acme Shipping Corporation (Charalambos N. Pateras)
• Rawson v Samuel
• Ellis Mechanical Services Ltd v Wates Construction Ltd
• Dawnays Ltd v F. G. Minter Ltd and Trollope and Colls Ltd
• Havelock v Geddes
• Nova (Jersey) Knit Ltd v Kammgarn Spinnerei G.m.b.H.
• French Marine v Compagnie Napolitaine D'Eclairage et de Chauffage par le Gaz

CITES

• Shillito, The
• Hansen v Harrold Brothers
• Decro-Wall International S.A. v Practitioners in Marketing Ltd

[See more]

• Henriksens Rederi A/S v T. H. Z. Rolimpex (Brede)
• Tankexpress A/S v Compagnie FinanciŠre Belge Des Petroles S.A.
• Seven Seas Transportation Ltd v Atlantic Shipping Company S.A. (Satya Kamal)
• Williams & Company v Canton Insurance Office Ltd
• Turner v Haji Goolam Mahomed Azam
• Freeth v Burr
• Re Whitfield's Estate
• Clausen v Canada Timber and Lands, Ltd

APPROVES

• Compania Sud Americana de Vapores v Shipmair B.v (Teno)

CONSIDERS

• Sea and Land Securities Ltd v William Dickinson & Company Ltd
• Mondel v Steel

DISTINGUISHES

• Aries Tanker Corporation v Total Transport Ltd
• Shaffer (James) Ltd v Findlay Durham & Brodie
• Sweet & Maxwell Ltd v Universal News Services Ltd

[See more]

• Henriksens Rederi A/S v T. H. Z. Rolimpex (Brede)

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [1978] EWCA Civ J0418-2
• [1978] 3 All ER 1066
• [1978] 1 Lloyd's Rep 581

[See more]

• [1978] 3 WLR 309
• [1978] QB 927

CONSIDERED in

• Jennifer Jean Lee v Futurist Developments Ltd (Defendant/Part 20 Claimant) Jennifer Jean Lee and Another (Part 20 Defendants)
• Aleena Shipping Inc. (A Body Corporate) v Minas X. Kyriakou
• Edlington Properties Ltd v J H Fenner and Company Ltd

[See more]

• Intercontinental Bank v Erastus Bankole Oladipo Akingbola and Others
• Tbl Realisations Plc ((in Administration)) (Bank) v Mona Awada and Another (Mr and Mrs Awada)
• Gulf Agri Trade Fzco v Aston Agro Industrial Ag
• The Secretary of State for Defence v Cyril Spencer
• Leon Corporation (Plaintiffs v Atlantic Lines and Navigation Company Inc. (Defendants "Leon"
• West Coast Air Ltd v Gambia Civil Aviation Authority and Another
• Bank Saderat Iran (Applicant/Respondent) v Calgarth Investments Ltd (Respondent/Applicant)
• Courage Ltd (Now Known as The Inntrepreneur Beer Supply Company Ltd) (Plaintiff) v Bernard Crehan and Another
• Cole Sopov and Norma Walker v Kane Constructions Pty Ltd
• CSR Investments Pty Ltd v Alcan Northern Territory Alumina Pty Ltd
• Slater & Gordon Ltd v Sellars
• Namoi Cotton Co-operative Ltd v IAMA Agribusiness Pty Ltd
• Westpac Banking Corporation ACN 007 457 141 v Zdenko Herceg
• Fearns (trading as Autopaint International) v Anglo-Dutch Paint & Chemical Company Ltd and Others
• (1) Geoffrey Philip Sankey (First Claimant/Respondent) (2) Christopher William David Yeomans (Second Claimant/Respondent) v The Helping Hands Group Plc
• Saudi Arabian Airlines Corporation v Sprite Aviation No. 6 Designated Activity Company
• Peninsular and Oriental Steam Navigation Company v Youell
• Savoy Motor Company (Appellants/plaintiffs) v Algin Air Ltd (Respondents/Defendants)
• Rotor Maxx Support Ltd v Air Palace Company, Ltd,
• Lee v Chang,
• Elance Steel Fabricating Company Ltd v Three-O-Six Industrial Services Inc.,
• Carol Tarasoff v Carol Tarasoff,
• Air Palace Company, Ltd v Rotor Maxx Support Ltd,
• Zodiac Maritime Agencies Ltd v Fortescue Metals Group Ltd
• Miwa Pty Ltd v Siantan Properties Pte Ltd
• Edlington Properties Ltd v J H Fenner and Company Ltd
• MW v JG,
• O'Meara v Bank of Scotland
• Resource Land Fund v, LP v JBuck and Sons Inc.,
• Cheltenham Borough Council v Christine Susan Laird
• B.I.C.C. Plc v Burndy Corporation
• Crehan v Courage Ltd
• Burton v Mellham Ltd
• Dalkia Utilities Services Plc v Celtech International Ltd
• Bim Kemi v Blackburn Chemicals Ltd
• Zephyr v Bank of Nova Scotia
• Woodar Investment Development Ltd v Wimpey Construction U.K. Ltd
• Richard Dale Agnew and Another v The Commissioner of Inland Revenue and Another

CITED in

• Gulf Steel Company Ltd v Al Khalifa Shipping Company Ltd (Anwar Al Sabar)
• Eltran Pty Ltd Vwestpac Banking Corporation
• Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd

[See more]

• Santiren Shipping Ltd v Unimarine S.A. (Chrysovalandou Dyo)
• Dry Bulk Handy Holding Inc. v Fayette International Holdings Ltd [QBD (Comm)]
• Altonwood Ltd and Crystal Palace F.C. (2000) Ltd
• Progressive Mailing House Pty Ltd Vtabali Pty Ltd
• Compania Comercial y Naviera San Martin S.A. v China National Foreign Trade Transportation Corporation (Constanza M, Costanza M)
• Daebo Shipping Company Ltd v The Ship Go Star
• Banco Central S.A. v Lingoss & Falce Ltd (Raven)
• First National Bank of Chicago v West of England Shipowners Mutual Protection and Indemnity Association (Luxembourg) (Evelpidis Era, My Era, Nisyros Era)
• Owneast Shipping Ltd v Qatar Navigation QSC
• Overseas Union Enterprise Ltd v Three Sixty Degree Pte Ltd
• Tradax Export S.A. v Dorada Compania Naviera S.A. (Lutetian)
• Golden Endurance Shipping SA v Rma Watanya SA and Others
• Exmar BV v National Iranian Tanker Company (Trade Fortitude)
• Dry Bulk Handy Holding Inc. (a company incorporated in Panama) & Compania Sud Americana de Vapores SA v Fayette International Holdings Ltd (a company incorporated in the British Virgin Islands) & Metinvest International SA
• Bruns v Colocotronis (Vasso)
• Zodiac Maritime Agencies Ltd v Fortescue Metals Group Ltd (The Kildare)
• Overland Shoes Ltd v Schenkers Ltd ; Same v Schenkers International Deutschland GmbH
• Etablissement Esefka International Anstalt v Central Bank of Nigeria
• Lakeport Navigation Company Panama S.A. v Anonima Petroli Italiana S.p.A. (Olympic Brilliance)
• Brandeaux Advisers (UK) Ltd and Others v Chadwick
• Durkin v DSG Retail Ltd
• Western Bulk Shipowning III A/S v Carbofer Maritime Trading ApS [QBD (Comm)]
• COSCO BULK CARRIER Company Ltd v ARMADA SHIPPING SA and Another
• Future Publishing Ltd v The Edge Interactive Media Inc. and Others
• Zurich Insurance Plc UK Branch v International Energy Group Ltd
• Colonial Bank v European Grain and Shipping Ltd (Dominique)
• Hamiltonian Hotel & Island Club Ltd v Daulphin 1989 Civil Appeal No 10
• Nationalwide News Network Ltd v AIG Jamaica Insurance Company Ltd
• Japan Line Ltd v Aggeliki Charis Compania Maritima S.A. (The Angelic Grace)
• Equitas Ltd and Another v Walsham Brothers & Company Ltd

APPLIED in

• Re Welsh Irish Ferries Ltd
• Leon Corporation v Atlantic Lines and Navigation Company Inc.
• Century Textiles and Industry Ltd v Tomoe Shipping Company (Singapore) Pte. Ltd (No. 1) (Aditya Vaibhar)

[See more]

• Globalink Transportation and Logistics Worldwide LLP v DHL Project & Chartering Ltd
• Re Freerider Ltd
• Re Freerider Ltd
• Geldof Metaalconstructie NV v Simon Carves Ltd
• National Westminster Bank v June Frankham
• Autoweld Systems Ltd v KITO Enterprises LLC
• Esso Petroleum Company Ltd v Milton

REFERRED in

• Workspace Management Ltd v YJL London Ltd
• Eller v Grovecrest Investments Ltd
• Voest Alpine Intertrading G.m.b.H. v Chevron International Oil Company Ltd

[See more]

• Artifical Solutions Germany Gmbh v Creative Virtual Ltd and Another
• Cheltenham Borough Council v Laird
• Fuller v Happy Shopper Markets Ltd and another
• The Secretary of State for Defence v Cyril Spencer
• Itex Intagrani Export S.A. v Care Shipping Corporation (Cebu (No. 2))
• Angelakis (G. & N.) Shipping Company S.A. v Compagnie National Algerienne de Navigation (Attika Hope)
• Triad Shipping Company v Stellar Chartering & Brokerage Inc. (Island Archon)
• Zhoushan Jinhaiwan Shipyard Company Ltd v Golden Exquisite Inc. and Others
• Owneast Shipping Ltd v Qatar Navigation QSC [QBD (Comm)]
• Bukit Cerakah Development Sdn Bhd v L'Grande Development Sdn Bhd
• Chuan Hup Agencies Pte Ltd v Global Minerals (Sarawak) Sdn Bhd
• S.E.A. Housing Corporation Sdn Bhd v Lee Poh Choo
• Sim v Rotherham Metropolitan Borough Council; Barnfield v Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council; Townend v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council; Rathbone v Croydon London Borough Council
• Moondance Maritime Enterprises SA (Claimant/Owners) v Carbofer Maritime Trading APS (Defendant/Charterers)
• Torvald Klaveness A/S v Arni Maritime Corporation (The Gregos)
• Dole Dried Fruit and Nut Company v Trustin Kerwood Ltd
• Smith v Muscat
• Colonial Bank v European Grain and Shipping Ltd (Dominique)
• Sylvia Shipping Company Ltd v Progress Bulk Bonding Ltd
• Gold Group Properties Ltd v BDW Trading Ltd
• R (Burkett) v Hammersmith and Fulham London BC
• SK Shipping (S) Pte Ltd v Petroexport Ltd
• Western Bulk Carriers K/S v Li Hai Maritime Inc. (The "Li Hai")
• Connaught Restaurants Ltd v Indoor Leisure Ltd
• Glencore Grain Rotterdam B.v v Lebanese Organisation for International Commerce (Lorico)
• CIS General Insurance Ltd v IBM United Kingdom Ltd
• Hotel Portfolio II UK Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Andrew Joseph Ruhan
• Sonat Offshore S.A. v Amerada Hess Development Ltd (Chris Chenery)
• Pat Systems v Graeme Neilly
• Safeway Stores Ltd v Interserve Project Services Ltd (formerly known as Tilbury Douglas Consrtruction Ltd)
• Eureka Medical Ltd v Life of Jamaica Ltd and Others
• Alexey Samarenko v Dawn Hill House Ltd
• Highness Electrical Engineering Pte Ltd v Sigma Cable Company (Pte) Ltd
• Pacific Rim Investments Pte Ltd v Lam Seng Tiong and Another
• San International Pte Ltd (fomerly known as San Ho Huat Construction Pte Ltd) v Keppel Engineering Pte Ltd
• Courage Ltd v Crehan (Case C-453/99)

FOLLOWED in

• Industrial & Agricultural Industrial Sdn Bhd v Golden Sands Construction Sdn Bhd
• Golden Sands Construction Sdn Bhd; Industrial & Agricultural Distribution Sdn Bhd
• Permodalan Plantations Sdn Bhd v Rachuta Sdn Bhd

[See more]

• De Beers UK Ltd (formerly Diamond Trading Company Ltd) v Atos Origin IT Services UK Ltd
• Kool Team Marketing v Pacific Sunwear Pte Ltd
• Chua Chay Lee and Others v Premier Properties Pte Ltd
• Engineering Construction Pte Ltd v Sanchoon Builders Pte Ltd

DISTINGUISHED in

• Vaswani v Italian Motors (Sales and Services) Ltd
• Eminence Property Developments Ltd v Heaney

APPEAL RESOLVED in

• Federal Commerce & Navigation Company Ltd v Molena Alpha Inc. (Benfri, Lorfri, Nanfri)

AFFIRMED in

• Federal Commerce & Navigation Company Ltd v Molena Alpha Inc. (Benfri, Lorfri, Nanfri)

NOT FOLLOWED in

• Hyundai Merchant Marine Company Ltd v Trafigura Beheer B.v "The Gaz Energy"

This document cites

---

• Dawnays Ltd v F. G. Minter Ltd and Trollope and Colls Ltd
• Mottram Consultants Ltd v Bernard Sunley & Sons Ltd
• Nippon Yusen Kaisha v Acme Shipping Corporation (Charalambos N. Pateras)
• Tankexpress A/S v Compagnie FinanciŠre Belge Des Petroles S.A.
• Associated Bulk Carriers Ltd v Koch Shipping Inc.



See all quotations

• Aries Tanker Corporation v Total Transport Ltd
• Gilbert Ash (Northern) Ltd v Modern Engineering (Bristol) Ltd
• United Scientific Holdings Ltd v Mayor, Aldermen and Burgesses of the County Borough of Burnley now The Council of the Borough of Burnley
• Henriksens Rederi A/S v T. H. Z. Rolimpex (Brede)
• Nova (Jersey) Knit Ltd v Kammgarn Spinnerei G.m.b.H.
• Sweet & Maxwell Ltd v Universal News Services Ltd
• Decro-Wall International S.A. v Practitioners in Marketing Ltd
• Re Whitfield's Estate
• Shaffer (James) Ltd v Findlay Durham & Brodie
• Hong Kong Fir Shipping Company Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd
• Hanak v Green
• Shillito, The
• Tankexpress A/S v Compagnie FinanciŠre Belge Des Petroles S.A.
• Williams & Company v Canton Insurance Office Ltd
• Morgan & Son v Martin Johnson & Company
• Clausen v Canada Timber and Lands, Ltd
• Seven Seas Transportation Ltd v Atlantic Shipping Company S.A. (Satya Kamal)
• Turner v Haji Goolam Mahomed Azam
• Sea and Land Securities Ltd v William Dickinson & Company Ltd
• George Russell v Anthony Snider Pellegrini
• Mondel v Steel
• Mardorf Peach & Company Ltd v Attica Sea Carriers Corporation of Liberia (Laconia)
• Halcyon Steamship Company Ltd v Continental Grain Company
• Sea and Land Securities Ltd v William Dickinson & Company Ltd
• Freeth v Burr
• Hansen v Harrold Brothers
• Henriksens Rederi A/S v T. H. Z. Rolimpex (Brede)
• Compania Sud Americana de Vapores v Shipmair B.v (Teno)
• Rawson v Samuel
• Tagart, Beaton & Company v James Fisher & Sons