Dymocks Franchise Systems (NSW) Pty Ltd v Todd

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Chapman (TGA) Ltd v Christopher
• Re Gartner Wines Pty Ltd;D'arrigo v Carter
• Aiden Shipping Company Ltd v Interbulk Ltd (Vimeira)

[See more]

• Caboolture Park Shopping Centre Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) v White Industries (Qld) Pty Ltd
• Hamilton v Al-Fayed (No 2)

CONSIDERS

• Supreme Court (now known as Senior Courts) Act 1981 - Articles : S-51

REFERS TO

• Arklow Investments Ltd and Another v I.D. MacLean
• Metalloy Supplies Ltd v M.A. (U.K.) Ltd
• Murphy v Young & Company 's Brewery Plc

[See more]

• Hamilton v Fayed and Others
• Akedian Company Ltd v Royal Insurance Australia Ltd
• Carborundum Abrasives Ltd v Bank of New Zealand (No 2)
• Ken Morgan Motors Pty Ltd v Toyota Motor Corpn Australia Ltd (unreported) 23 November 1993, Victoria Supreme Ct
• Alexander Lindo, Abraham Lindo, and Henry Lindo, - Appellants; Edward Moulton Barrett-Respondent
• Packing in Ltd v Chilcott
• Interbulk Ltd (Appellants) Aiden Shipping Company Ltd (Respondents) I.C.C.O. International Corn Company N.v (Respondents) Interbulk Ltd (Appellants)

CITED in

• R K Joinery Ltd (Claimant/Respondent) Ramneek Kaur Virdi (Defendant) Amritpal Singh Virdi (Additional defendant/Appellant)
• Manton International Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation
• Centrehigh Ltd v Amen

[See more]

• Hellas Telecommunications (Luxembourg)
• Nicholas Courtauld Rayner v The Lord Chancellor
• Merchantbridge & Company Ltd and another v Safron General Partner 1 Ltd and Others
• DB Trustees (Hong Kong) Ltd v Consult Asia Pte Ltd
• Peterborough City Council v K, L, M, N and P
• Todd Owen Dean v Dr Mark Van Thien Phung
• CIGNA Worldwide v ACE Ltd
• Re VC Computer Holdings Ltd
• Hull and Holderness Magistrates' Court v Alister Charles Darroch and Another Media Protection Services Ltd and Another (Interested Parties)
• George Yu v Ping Cao
• Wilton UK Ltd (Suing on Behalf of Itself as Shareholder in Banks Mount Oswald Ltd, The Fifth Defendant) v John Michael Shuttleworth
• Muir v Commissioner of Inland Revenue
• Majuro Investment Corporation v Timis and ors (Ruling on Costs)
• Equitas Ltd and Another v Horace Holman and Company Ltd and Another
• Winston Finzi v Mahoe Bay Company Ltd and Another
• Martin S. Kenney Cc International Ltd Appellants v Ace Ltd Respondent to Appeal
• The Companies Law (2013 Revision) (as Revised) v VC Computer Holdings Ltd (in Official Liquidation) (‘the Company’)
• Andrew Turvill v David Lindon Bird and Others
• Michael Paul Chen-Young (as Executor of the Estate of Paul Chen-Young (Deceased)) and Others v Eagle Merchant Bank Jamaica Ltd and 3 others
• Suisse Security Bank & Trust Ltd v Francis (in the capacity of Governor of the Central Bank of The Bahamas)

CONSIDERED in

• Hitachi Capital (UK) Plc v V-12 Finance Ltd
• Adrian Kirby (Applicant/Claimant) v Alexander Hoff (Respondent/Defendant)
• Dr Robin Rudd v John Bridle

[See more]

• Carlton Landmark Properties Ltd and Others v Landmark Group Ltd
• Raleigh Uk Ltd v Mail Order Cycles Ltd
• R + v Versicherung A.G. v Risk Insurance and Reinsurance Solutions S.A. and Others
• BE Studios Ltd v Smith & Williamson Ltd
• Raleigh Uk Ltd v Mail Order Cycles Ltd
• Re Chambeyron Pty Ltd (No 2)
• V Guernroy Ltd
• Tablet Investments (Guernsey) Ltd v Brahma Finance (BVI) Ltd Nicholas Braham
• Apex Frozen Foods v Ali
• Merchantbridge & Company Ltd and another v Safron General Partner 1 Ltd and Others
• Aura Energy Ltd v ASEAN Deep Value Fund (No 2)
• Ramkarun Bushan Deepchand v Anbananden Sooben
• Gavin Flatman v Gill Germany
• John Gdanski(Applicant) v Palms Court Management Pty Ltd (ACN 067 353 422)
• Joshi v Patel
• Kuwait Airways Corporation v Iraqi Airways Company
• KSMC Holdings Pty Ltd t/as Hubba Bubba Childcare on Haig v Bowden (No 3)
• Dr Meera Kailash Dal v Dr Marcus Bicknell
• Hurford Hardwood Kempsey Pty Ltd v Kempsey Timbers (Sawmilling) Pty Ltd (No 5)
• Wigmans v AMP Ltd (No 3)
• Bruce Adams ((First Applicant)) v David Marocchi ((First Respondent))
• QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v Hotchin and Others
• Macquarie International Health Clinic Pty Ltd v Sydney South West Area Health Service (No 3)
• The Owners – Strata Plan 30791 v Southern Cross Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd (in Liquidation)
• Maylord Equity Management Pty Ltd as trustee of the Batterham Retirement Fund v Nauer (No. 3)
• Lorie Najjar & Sons Pty Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Najwa Najjar
• Stene Marshall v QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd (ACN 003 191 035)
• HRX Pty Ltd v Scott
• Centrehigh Ltd v Karen Amen and Others
• The Scout Association v Bolt Burdon Kemp
• Dweck v Forstater
• Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC v WPMC Ltd ((in Liquidation))
• Travelers Insurance Company Ltd v XYZ
• PR Records Ltd Apellant v 1) Vinyl 2000 Ltd 2) Susan Agnes Owlett - and - Adrian Owlett
• Memet Aldemir v Cornwall Council
• Various Claimants v Giambrone & Law (A Firm)& Others
• Convergence Group Plc and Another v Chantrey Vellacott (A Firm)
• PME v The Scout Association
• Manuel Heron (Claimant/ Interested Party) v TNT (UK) Ltd (Appellant/ Defendant) Mackrell Turner Garrett (A Firm)
• Dranez Anstalt v Hayek
• Jeffery & Katauskas Pty Ltd v SST Consulting Pty Ltd and Others
• David Mann v Transport for London
• Select Car Rentals (North West) Ltd v Esure Services Ltd
• Ociusnet UK Ltd v Altus Digital Media Ltd (formerly Ociusnet Digital Media Ltd)
• Mistrina Pty Ltd v Australian Consulting Engineers Pty Ltd — Costs
• PM Works Pty Ltd v Management Services Australia Pty Ltd trading as Peak Performance PM
• May v Christodoulou
• Oriakhel v Vickers and Others
• Ventures Food Ltd v Little Dessert Shop Limted
• Topalsson GmbH v Rolls Royce Motor Cars Ltd
• J v S
• The RBS Rights Issue Litigation
• (1) Merchantbridge & Company Ltd and Another v (1) Safron General Partner 1 Ltd (2) H E Mohd Al Zubair and Others (Defendants (Costs Only)
• Nature's Care Holdings Pty Ltd v Chen (No 4)
• John Anthony Popely v Ronald Albert Popely
• Rickard Constructions Pty Ltd v Rickard Hails Moretti Pty Ltd and Others; Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v SST Consulting Pty Ltd and Others; Jeffery & Katauskas Pty Ltd v SST Consulting Pty Ltd and Others; Rickard Hails Moretti Pty Ltd v SST Consulting Pty Ltd and Others
• Burnden Holdings (UK) Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Gary John Fielding
• Minister for P E v Yates and Regs Skips
• Leeds United Association Football Club Ltd and Leeds United Football Club Ltd (formerly Leeds United 2007 Ltd) v The Phone-in Trading post Ltd (t/a Admatch) and Robert Weston
• Leeds United v Admatch
• The Representation of Nasser Ibrahim Abdallah
• Julian John Watson v Tariq Mahmood Sadiq
• Eh Baker and Wc Rameka as Trustees of The Thomas Baker Wahanau Trust v Waimakuku Whanau Trust Board Incorporated Hc Nap
• Mana Property Trustee Ltd v James Developments Ltd
• The Fish Man Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Hadfield
• S H Lock (NZ) Ltd v New Zealand Bloodstock Leasing Ltd and New Zealand Bloodstock Finance Ltd and New Zealand Bloodstock Progeny Ltd
• Johan Aarts v Barnardos New Zealand NZEmpC Auckland
• Shanghai Neuhof Trade Company Ltd v Zespri International Ltd
• AT v RN
• Fankhauser and Others v Strongline Buildings Ltd
• Fern Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Financial Trust Ltd and Anor
• Wadsworth v Cognata Investments Ltd
• Capital + Merchant Finance Ltd ((in Receivership) and (in Liquidation)) v Vision Securities Ltd ((in Receivership))
• Digital Masters Ltd v The Country Channel Ltd
• Maehl v Lenihan
• Waterhouse v Contractors Bonding Ltd
• Houghton v Saunders
• B v B Hc Dun
• Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc v Baglan Abdullayevich Zhunus (formerly Baglan Abdullayevich Zhunussov)
• Glass Slipper Ltd v Crimson Flower Productions Ltd
• Adris and Others v the Royal Bank of Scotland Plc
• Goknur Gida Maddeleri Enerji Imalat v Organic Village Ltd
• CFC 26 Ltd and Another v Brown Shipley & Company Ltd and Others
• LIC Telecommunications Sarl v VTB Capital Plc
• I-Remit Incorporated v Far East Express Remittance Ltd
• The Ecu Group Plc v HSBC Bank Plc
• The Ecu Group Plc v HSBC Bank Plc
• The Companies Act, Ch. 308 and the Companies (winding up amendment) Act, 2011 v Montaque Corporate Partners Ltd (‘in Official Liquidation’)
• Phoenix Global Fund Ltd et Al v Citigroup Fund Services (bermuda) Ltd
• The Official Receiver v Johannes Christian Martinus
• Julie Anne Davey v James Money
• Dolphin Quays Development Ltd v Mills (aka Mills v Birchall)
• Between: (1) Arnage Holdings Ltd (2) Brooklands Holdings Ltd (3) East Farthing Holdings Ltd (4) Ms Katia Rabello (5) Mr Fernando Toledo Plaintiffs v Walkers (A Firm) Defendant
• China Branding Group Ltd (in Official Liquidation) Between:- Tony Bobulinski Appellant v China Branding Group Ltd (in Official Liquidation) Respondent
• Cigna Worldwide Insurance Company (by and Through Its Court Appointed Receiver, Josie Senesie, and in Respect of the Assets, Under Takings and Affairs of Its Licensed Liberian Branch and business) Plaintiff v Ace Ltd Defendant
• St John's Trust Company (PVT) Ltd v James Watlington
• CHINA BRANDING GROUP Ltd (in OFFICIAL LIQUIDATION) BETWEEN:- Tony Bobulinski Appellant v China Branding Group Ltd (in Official Liquidation) Respondent
• Cigna Worldwide Insurance Company (by and Through Its Court Appointed Receiver, Josie Senesie and in Respect of the Assets, Undertakings and Affairs of Its Licensed Liberian Branch and Business) Plaintiff v Ace Ltd Defendant
• St John's Trust Company (PVT) Ltd v James Watlington
• Stephen Hunt (as Trustee in Bankruptcy of Janan George Harb) v Janan George Harb Hrh Prince Abdul Aziz Bin Fahd Abdful Aziz
• Idoport Pty Ltd and Anor v National Australia Bank Ltd and Others, National Australia Bank Ltd v OAMPS Ltd and Ors
• BETWEEN: (1) Arnage Holdings Ltd (2) Brooklands Holdings Ltd (3) East Farthing Holdings Ltd (4) Ms Katia Rabello (5) Mr Fernando Toledo Plaintiffs v Walkers (A Firm) Defendant
• Dolphin Quays Development Ltd v Mills (aka Mills v Birchall)
• Paul Chen-Young v Eagle Merchant Bank Jamaica Ltd
• Arkin v Borchard Lines Ltd and Others (Nos 2 and 3)
• Fishermen and Friends of the Sea v Environmental Management Authority and BP Trinidad and Tobago Llc
• Green Elite Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Mr. Fang Ankong
• The Companies Law (2013 Revision) v the Primeo Fund (in Official Liquidation)
• Donna Dorsett-Major v The Director of Public Prosecutions
• Clarke v Meadus
• Excelerate Technology Ltd (Claimant) Lindsay Cumberbatch (First Defendant) Red Foot Technologies Ltd (Second Defendant) David Osmond (Third Defendant)
• Majuro Investment Corporation (a company incorporated in Marshall Islands) v Vasile Timis (also known as Frank Timis)
• Asprey Capital Ltd v Rediresi Ltd
• Asprey Capital Ltd v Rediresi Ltd
• MC Wholesaling Pty Ltd v Zheng
• Harold Brady v General Legal Council
• Brewer v Mann
• Trafalgar Multi Asset Trading Company Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v James David Hadley
• Tan Chi Fang and 3 others v HM Attorney General
• Tan Chi Fang v HM Attorney General
• Cafe de LecqvRossborough Insurance
• Bombardier Transportation UK Ltd v Merseytravel
• Deutsche Bank A.G. v Sebastian Holdings Inc. and Another
• Michael Paul Chen-Young (as Executor of the Estate of Paul Chen-Young (Deceased)) and Others v Eagle Merchant Bank Jamaica Ltd and 3 others
• Phil Ryan v LVR Capital Ltd ((in Administration))
• Petromec Inc. v Petroleo Brasileiro S.A. Petrobras and Others
• Nelson v Greening and Sykes (Builders) Ltd
• Ceredigion Recycling & Furniture Team v Clifford Pope
• Titan Petrochemicals Group Ltd and the Companies Act
• Systemcare (UK) Ltd v Services Design Technology Ltd and Another
• Sims v Hawkins
• Deutsche Bank AG v Sebastian Holdings Incorporated and Another
• Thompson v Berkhamsted Collegiate School
• BARNDEAL Ltd and CHERRYWALK PROPERTIES Ltd and London Borough of RICHMOND-UPON-THAMES
• Hilden Developments Ltd v Phillips Auctioneers Ltd
• Daniels v Pereyra
• The RBS Rights Issue Litigation

APPLIED in

• Sony/Atv Music Publishing LLC and Another (Claimants1) v Wpmc Ltd ((in Liquidation)) and Another David Bailey (Costs Defendant)
• Harcus Sinclair (A Firm) v Buttonwood Legal Capital Ltd and Others
• Michael Steven Vaughan v 1. Ellen Mary Jones 2. Mark Adrian Fowler 3. Jane Anne Fowler

[See more]

• Latimer Management Consultants Ltd and Others v Ellingham Investments Ltd and another
• Jackson v Thakrar
• Heron v TNT (UK) Ltd and another
• Myatt v National Coal Board and Another (No 2)
• (1) Sir Kevin Barron MP v (1) Jane Collins MEP
• Planning and Environment Minister v Yates, Yates (Née Van Neste) and R’S Skips Ltd
• Goodwood Recoveries Ltd v Breen
• The Creative Foundation v Dreamland Leisure Ltd and Others
• Excalibur Ventures LLC v Texas Keystone Inc. and Others (Defendants/Costs Claimants) Psari Holdings Ltd and Others (Costs Defendants)
• Brampton Manor (Leisure) Ltd v McLean (No. 2)

REFERRED in

• BE Studios Ltd v Smith and Williamson Ltd
• Herridge v Parker and Another
• R+v Versicherung AG v Risk Insurance and Reinsurance Solutions SA and Others

[See more]

• Murphy v Rayner and Others
• Media CAT Ltd v Adams (No. 2)
• XYZ v Travelers Insurance Company Ltd
• Gatnom Capital v Sanders and Others
• Sahan Salekipour v Mohinder Singh Parmar and Another Amir Saleem (Third Party/Applicant)
• Nanyang Law LLC v Alphomega Research Group Ltd
• DB Trustees (Hong Kong) Ltd v Consult Asia Pte Ltd
• Memet Aldemir v Cornwall Council
• Mr Carl Ferri v Mr Ian Gill
• R (Ewing and another) v Office of the Deputy Prime Minister and another
• PME v The Scout Association
• Ociusnet UK Ltd v Altus Digital Media Ltd (formerly Ociusnet Digital Media Ltd)
• Ventures Food Ltd v Little Dessert Shop Limted
• Davey v Money and another; Dunbar Assets Plc v Davey
• Re Professional Computer Group
• Alan Phillips Associates Ltd v Terence Edward Dowling T/A The Joseph Dowling Partnership and Others
• Burnden Holdings (UK) Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Gary John Fielding
• Julian John Watson v Tariq Mahmood Sadiq
• Kazakhstan Kagazy Plc v Baglan Abdullayevich Zhunus (formerly Baglan Abdullayevich Zhunussov)
• Goknur Gida Maddeleri Enerji Imalat v Organic Village Ltd
• Travelers Insurance Company Ltd v XYZ
• (1) Progas Energy Ltd v The Islamic Republic of Pakistan
• Julie Anne Davey v James Money
• Moorview Development Ltd v First Active Plc
• Excalibur Ventures LLC v Texas Keystone Inc. and Others
• Peter Willers v Elena Joyce
• Mr Nigel Rowe & Others v Ingenious Media Holdings Plc & Others
• Marley v Rawlings (No 2)
• Trafalgar Multi Asset Trading Company Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v James David Hadley
• Susan Glover v Iain Paul Barker
• Petromec Inc. v Petroleo Brasileiro S.A. Petrobras and Others
• Europeans Ltd v HM Revenue and Customs
• Ghassemian Hamila Sartipy (Aka Hamila Sartipy) v Tigris Industries Inc.
• Flatman v Germany (Law Society intervening)
• SFL ACE 2 Company Inc. v DCW Management Ltd (Formerly Allseas Global Management Ltd)
• Hilden Developments Ltd v Phillips Auctioneers Ltd

FOLLOWED in

• Probiotec Ltd v the University of Melbourne
• Spartafield Ltd v Penten Group Ltd and Another
• Tinseltime Ltd v Eryl Roberts and Others (Defendants/Applicants) Gavin Edmondson

DISTINGUISHED in

• Raffles Town Club Pte Ltd v Lim Eng Hock Peter

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• 21/07/2004 Daily Cases
• [2005] 4 All ER 195
• [2004] 1 WLR 2807

This document cites

---

• Murphy v Young & Company 's Brewery Plc
• Hamilton v Al-Fayed (No 2)
• Arundel Chiropractic Centre Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation
• Interbulk Ltd (Appellants) Aiden Shipping Company Ltd (Respondents) I.C.C.O. International Corn Company N.v (Respondents) Interbulk Ltd (Appellants)
• Aiden Shipping Company Ltd v Interbulk Ltd (Vimeira)



See all quotations

• Metalloy Supplies Ltd v M.A. (U.K.) Ltd
• Chapman (TGA) Ltd v Christopher
• Caboolture Park Shopping Centre Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) v White Industries (Qld) Pty Ltd
• Ken Morgan Motors Pty Ltd v Toyota Motor Corpn Australia Ltd (unreported) 23 November 1993, Victoria Supreme Ct
• Re Gartner Wines Pty Ltd;D'arrigo v Carter
• Forest Pty Ltd v Keen Bay Pty Ltd
• Akedian Company Ltd v Royal Insurance Australia Ltd
• Alexander Lindo, Abraham Lindo, and Henry Lindo, - Appellants; Edward Moulton Barrett-Respondent
• Hamilton v Fayed and Others
• Gore (t/as Clayton Utz) v Justice Corporation Pty Ltd
• Arklow Investments Ltd and Another v I.D. MacLean
• Supreme Court (now known as Senior Courts) Act 1981
• Judicial Committee Act 1833
• Judicial Committee Act 1843
• Civil Procedure Rules 1998