O'Brien v Chief Constable of South Wales Police

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Berger v Raymond Sun Ltd
• R v Straffen
• Makin v Attorney General for New South Wales

[See more]

• R v Randall (Edward Peter)
• Thorpe v Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police

REFERS TO

• R v Edwards
• R v Kilbourne
• Harris v Tippett

[See more]

• R v Boardman
• R v H and Another

RESUELVE RECURSO

• O'Brien v Chief Constable of South Wales Police

ACLARA

• Metropolitan Asylum District v Hill

AFFIRMS

• O'Brien v Chief Constable of South Wales Police

CITES

• R v H (1995)
• R v X (Prior Acquittal)
• R v Kilbourne

[See more]

• R v Edwards (John)
• R v Boardman
• Michael Obrien and Chief Constable of The South Wales Police/

APPROVES

• Mood Music Publishing Company Ltd v De Wolfe Ltd

CONSIDERS

• R v H (1995)
• Criminal Justice Act 1988 - Articles : S-133
• Criminal Justice Act 2003 - Articles : S-100

[See more]

• Criminal Justice Act 2003 - Articles : S-106
• Criminal Justice Act 2003 - Articles : S-109
• Criminal Justice Act 2003

DISTINGUISHES

• DPP v P

CONSIDERED in

• Desmond v Bower
• Mahboob v Chief Constable of West Midlands Constabulary
• Alexander Christoforou v Christakis Christoforou

[See more]

• Cheshire Building Society v Dunlop Haywards (DHL) Ltd
• Mario Alberto Tabra Guerrero & 30 Others (Claimant) Monterrico Metals Plc (Defendant) Menandro Neyra Caucha and Another (Claimant) Monterrico Metals Plc and Another (Defendant)
• Re S
• Cheshire West and Chester Council v M
• B (A Child)
• Ruta Kerseviciene v Mide Quadri
• CW & CG Claims Ltd v Clarkewood Ltd
• Brigita Morina v Elena Nikolayevna Scherbakova
• Vito Zepinic v Health Care Complaints Commission
• Zepinic v Attorney-General of NSW
• Trump International Ltd v DTTM Operations LLC
• WU v BU (by her litigation friend, the Official Solicitor)
• Diorite Securities Ltd (as Trustee of the Jenneret Settlement) and Another v Arvind Tiku
• Mark Christopher Breslin and Others and Seamus McKenna and Others.
• Mark Christopher Breslin and Others and Seamus McKenna and Others - Ruling No 14
• Claverton Holdings Ltd v Barclays Bank Plc
• Mansard Mortgages 2007-2 Plc v Beyat Holdings Ltd
• Styles and Ors v AG
• H v The Attorney General
• Premier Events Group Ltd v Malcolm James Beattie
• R v P (Children: Similar Fact Evidence)
• John McLinden v Shiao-Chen Lu
• Peter Sharp & Son (A Firm) v Gea Farm Technologies (UK) Ltd
• Grace Kennedy Remittance Services Ltd v Paymaster (Jamaica) Ltd and Lowe
• Qatar Investment and Projects Development Holding Company v Phoenix Ancient Art S.A.
• Habibur Rahman v Azizur Rahman
• Kabushiki Kaisha Sigma Plaintiff v 1. Trustcorp Ltd ((in Liquidation)) 2. Hideo Seto (in His Capacity as Trustees of the Estate of Kenshin Oshima, a Bankrupt) Defendants
• Condron v ACC Bank and Others and Cuttle v ACC Bank Plc
• Christine Dacosta v Mount Saint Agnes Academy
• R v Weir (Antony Albert) and Others
• Jp Morgan Chase Bank & Others v Springwell Navigation Corporation
• Alex Wolffe v The Queen
• Superpharm Ltd v Darren Dookie
• Clarise Jupiter v Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago Ltd
• Signia Wealth Ltd v Vector Trustees Ltd (as trustee of the Cap Ferret Trust)
• Rebekah Vardy v Coleen Rooney
• Alex Wolffe v The Queen
• C v D [2006]
• R v Edwards (Karl Adrian)

REFERRED in

• Silversafe Ltd and Another v Hood and Others
• Re M and L (Children)
• Revenue and Customs Commissioners v Atlantic Electronics Ltd

[See more]

• Bilta (UK) Ltd ((in Liquidation)) and Others v SVS Securities Plc and Others
• Ms Jane Laporte and Another v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis
• Eloise Mukami Kimathi (1) James Karanja Nyoro (2) and Others v Foreign and Commonwealth Office
• Mansard Mortgages 2007-2 Plc v Beyat Holdings Ltd
• Andrew Mitchell MP v News Group Newspapers Ltd
• La Cotte Consulting Ltd v Sovereign Steel Stockholders (A Firm)
• Thyssen Canada Ltd and Mariana Maritime S. A and Another
• R v P (Children: Similar Fact Evidence)
• F v M
• JXJ v The Province of Great Britain of the Institute of Brothers of the Christian Schools (“the de la Salle Brothers”)
• Peter Sharp & Son (A Firm) v Gea Farm Technologies (UK) Ltd
• Ahmed Hegazy and Others v The Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis Mark Jones (Third Party) Steven White (Fourth Party) William Wilson (Fifth Party) Neil Brown (Sixth Party)
• Standard Life Assurance Ltd v Gleeds (UK) (A Firm)
• Simon Kelly v Raymond Kelly
• Grace Kennedy Remittance Services Ltd v Paymaster (Jamaica) Ltd and Another
• Atlantic Electronics Ltd v The Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs
• Crypto Open Patent Alliance v Craig Steven Wright
• Dunnes Stores Unlimited Company and Another v Dafora Unlimited and Others
• Polanski v The Conde Nast Publications Ltd
• Alan Charlton and Idris Ali v R

CITED in

• Shobna Gulati and Others v MGN Ltd
• PJSC Tatneft v Gennadiy Bogolyubov
• Primafacio Ltd v Tres Canopia Ltd

[See more]

• Janet Laughton v Salah Eldin Ahmed El Sayed Shalaby
• Jordan’s (Hugh) Applications 13/002996/1; 13/002223/1; 13/037869/1
• Thomas Ross Young V. Her Majesty's Advocate
• Qatar Investment and Projects Development Holding Company v Phoenix Ancient Art S.A.
• Omar Barraq Mohidin (First Claimant) Basil Khan (Second Claimant) Ahmed Hegazy (Third Claimant) v Commissioner of the Police of the Metropolis Mark Jones (Third Party) Steven White (Fourth Party) William Wilson (Fifth Party) Neil Brown (Sixth Party)
• Jordan’s Applications

APPLIED in

• Signia Wealth Ltd v Marlborough Trust Company Ltd (as Trustee of the Cap Ferret Trust) and Another Nathalie Dauriac-Stoebe (acting on behalf of Marlborough Trust Company Ltd as trustee of the Cap Ferret Trust and for the benefit of the beneficiaries of the Cap Ferret Trust) (Third Party) Grecco Ltd (Fourth Party) John Caudwell (Fifth Party)
• Styles, Day, Carney and De Sousa v Attorney General
• Shobna Gulati and Others v MGN Ltd

[See more]

• Otkritie International Investment Management Ltd and Others v Georgy Urumov (also Known as George Urumov) and Others

FOLLOWED in

• CGU Insurance Berhad v Asean Security Paper Mills Sdn Bhd

APPROVED in

• Breslin and others and Murphy and Daly

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2006] 1 LRC 383
• [2005] 2 All ER 931
• [29/04/2005] TLR 2

[See more]

• 338 NR 27
• [2005] 2 WLR 1038
• [2005] 2 AC 534

RELIED UPON in

• Wrangle v Brunt and Another
• Thurrock Council v Martin Stokes

This document cites

---

• R v Kilbourne
• Managers of the Metropolitan Asylum District v Hill and Others (Appeal No. 1)
• R v Z
• DPP v P
• Michael Obrien and Chief Constable of The South Wales Police/



See all quotations

• Mood Music Publishing Company Ltd v De Wolfe Ltd
• R v Randall (Edward Peter)
• Thorpe v Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police
• R v Kilbourne
• R v Boardman
• R v Edwards
• R v H (1995)
• R v H (1995)
• Makin v Attorney General for New South Wales
• R v Boardman
• Metropolitan Asylum District v Hill
• Harris v Tippett
• Berger v Raymond Sun Ltd
• R v Edwards (John)
• O'Brien v Chief Constable of South Wales Police
• R v Straffen
• R v X (Prior Acquittal)
• Criminal Justice Act 2003
• Criminal Justice Act 1988
• Civil Procedure Rules 1998
• R v H and Another