An inquiry pursuant to Article 40.4.2 of the Constitution. Clive Gooden v St. Otteran's Hospital

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Mental Treatment Act, 1945
• Mental Treatment Act, 1953
• Re D. (Application of Midland Health Board)

REFERS TO

• R.T. v Director of the Central Mental Hospital
• Re Philip Clarke

CITES

• Doyle v Commissioner of an Garda Síochána
• Heydon's Case
• Nestor v Murphy

[See more]

• Pepper (Inspector of Taxes) v Hart
• R v Judge of City of London Court
• River Wear Commissioners v Adamson and Others
• Croke v Smith (No. 2)

FOLLOWS

• DPP (Ivers) v Murphy

CONSIDERED in

• B v Clinical Director of Our Lady's Hospital Navan
• RGF v The Clinical Director Department of Psychiatry Midland Regional Hospital Portlaoise
• B v The Mental Health Tribunal

[See more]

• Health Service Executive (HSE) v X (M)
• J.G.H. v Residential Institutions Review Committee
• Health Service Executive v H.H.
• S (v T) v Health Service Executive & Mercy University Hospital Ltd
• Custom House Capital Ltd ((in Liquidation))
• J.B. v Mental Health (Criminal Law) Review Board and Others
• Environmental Protection Agency v Neiphin Trading Ltd & Others
• L.W. v Health Service Executive
• Health Service Executive (HSE) v M (J) & P (R)
• RGF v The Clinical Director, Department of Psychiatry, Midland Regional Hospital, Portlaoise
• F.X. v Clinical Director of Central Mental Hospital
• F.C. v Mental Health Tribunal

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2005] 3 IR 617

CITED in

• Monahan v Legal Aid Board
• J.B. v The Director of the Central Mental Hospital, Dr. Ronan Hearne and another
• B (J) v Director of The Central Mental Hospital & Hearne

[See more]

• O'Donnell v South Dublin County Council
• F.X. v Clinical Director of Central Mental Hospital and Another
• Monahan v Legal Aid Board and Others
• A.B v HSE and Others
• T. O'D. v Harry Kennedy, Clinical Director of the Central Director of the Central Mental Hospital, and the Health Service Executive
• A.M. v Harry Kennedy, Clinical Director of the Central Mental Hospital
• A.X. v Mental Health Tribunal and Another

REFERRED in

• J.F. v The Mental Health Tribunal
• X v Health Service Executive and Others
• G (A Minor Suing by her Father and Next Friend SG) v Health Service Executive

[See more]

• Cahill v The Minister for Education and Science
• M.X. v Health Service Executive
• G. v Department of Social Protection
• JN and TM (A Minor Suing by his Mother and Next Friend JN) v John Harraghy & Health Service Executive
• RGF v The Clinical Director, Department of Psychiatry, Midland Regional Hospital, Portlaoise
• Child and Family Agency v M.L. (Otherwise G.)
• M.R v Cathy Byrne, Dr Fidelma Flynn and Sligo Mental Health Services

APPROVED in

• E.H. v Clinical Director of St Vincent's Hospital

DISTINGUISHED in

• S.M. v Mental Health Commission

This document cites

---

• Convenio Europeo para la Protección de los Derechos Humanos y de las Libertades Fundamentales
• Nestor v Murphy
• Re D. (Application of Midland Health Board)
• Pepper (Inspector of Taxes) v Hart
• Pepper (Inspector of Taxes) v Hart



See all quotations

• Doyle v Commissioner of an Garda Síochána
• Croke v Smith (No. 2)
• Re Philip Clarke
• DPP (Ivers) v Murphy
• R.T. v Director of the Central Mental Hospital
• Heydon's Case
• River Wear Commissioners v Adamson and Others
• R v Judge of City of London Court
• Mental Health Act, 2001
• Mental Treatment Act, 1945
• Mental Treatment Act, 1953