Aldi Stores Ltd v WSP Group Plc and Others

Core Citations

---

CONSIDERS

• Thomas and Another v Baptiste and Others

REFERS TO

• Toth v Ledger
• Henderson v Henderson. [HIGH COURT of CHANCERY]
• Aldi Stores Ltd v (1) Wsp Group Plc (2) Wsp London Ltd (3) Aspinwall & Company Ltd

RESUELVE RECURSO

APPLIES

• Johnson v Gore Wood & Company (A Firm)

CITES

• Hunter and Others v Chief Constable of West Midlands
• Assiscurazioni Generali SpA v Arab Insurance Group
• Johnson v Gore Wood & Company (A Firm)

[See more]

• Lord Browne of Madingley v Associated Newspapers Ltd
• Mersey Care NHS Trust v Ackroyd (No.2)

REVERSES

• Aldi Stores Ltd v (1) Wsp Group Plc (2) Wsp London Ltd (3) Aspinwall & Company Ltd

CONSIDERS

• Dexter Ltd v Vlieland-Boddy
• Gleeson v J. Wippell & Company Ltd

REFERRED in

• Merlina Jacqueline Samuel v Syleta Monica Susan Samuel
• Gladman Commercial Properties v Fisher Hargreaves Proctor and Others
• Joseph Charles Garnham v Christopher Ian Millar (Personally) and Others

[See more]

• TQ Delta, LLC (a company incorporated under the laws of the State of Delaware, USA v Zyxel Communications UK Ltd
• Fehily v Atkinson
• Autogas (Europe) Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v Thomas Tadeus Ochocki
• Elite Property Holdings Ltd v BDO LLP
• Camerata Property Inc. v Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) Ltd [QBD (Comm)]
• C. Christo & Company Ltd v Nicholas Christoforou
• Anish Nambiar v Solitair Ltd
• Spire Healthcare Limtied v Nicholas Brooke
• Arcadia Group Ltd v Telegraph Media Group Ltd
• Harrison and Another v Black Horse Ltd
• Zavarco Plc v Tan Sri Syed Mohd Yusof Bin Tun Syed Nasir
• Fereshteh Habibollazadeh Behbehani v Falah Syed Hussein Syed Hashim Behbehani
• AB Volvo (Publ) and Others v Ryder Ltd and Others
• Tariq Alsaifi v Trinity Mirror Plc & Board of Directors and Another
• Revenue and Customs Commissioners v Kishore
• Canary Riverside Estate Management Ltd v Alan Coates
• Mrs Beverley Goldman & Others v Zurich Insurance Plc
• John Patrick Dowdall v William Kenyon & Sons Ltd and Others
• Gazprom Export LLC v DDI Holdings Ltd
• William Alexander Spicer v The Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis
• Jonathan Mark Broomhead v National Westminster Bank Plc
• Pricewaterhousecoopers LLP v BTI 2014 LLC
• Taylor Goodchild Ltd v Taylor and Another
• Philip Davies v Carillion Energy Services Ltd (1st Defendant) His Energy Ltd ((in Liquidation)) (2nd Defendant)
• MW High Tech Projects UK Ltd v Outotec (USA) Inc.
• Total Sprint Ltd v Swale Borough Council
• Antonio Troitiño Arranz v The 5th Section of the National High Court of Madrid, Spain
• Safe-T-Systems Holdings Ltd v ILR Safety CC
• Ivy Okedina v The Lord Chancellor/Ministry of Justice
• Daewoo Shipbuilding and Marine Engineering Company Ltd v Songa Offshore Equinox Ltd
• Bank of Scotland Plc (Claimant Appellant) v Elizabeth Jean Watson and Another
• Test Claimants in the Franked Investment Income Group Litigation and Others v Revenue and Customs Commissioners; Test Claimants in the Franked Investment Income Group Litigation and Others v Revenue and Customs Commissioners
• CIP Properties (AIPT) Ltd v Galliford Try Infrastructure Ltd EIC Ltd (Third Party) Kone Plc (Fourth Party) DLG Architects LLP (Fifth Party) Damond Lock Grabowski & Partners (A Firm)(Sixth Party)
• Aib Group (UK) Plc v Mr Stuart Harold Turner and Others
• Joseph Donovan v Prescott Place Freeholder Ltd & Others
• Skatteforvaltningen v MCML Ltd
• Trust Risk Group SpA v AmTrust Europe Ltd
• Akkurate Ltd ((in Liquidation)) v John Christopher Richmond
• ACC Bank Plc v Cunniffe
• Hearst Holdings Inc. v AVELA Inc.
• Salahuddin Amin v Director General of the Security Service and Others
• Vaqar Malik v Iftikhar Ahmad Malik
• Primekings Holding Ltd v Anthony King
• Salim Shalabayev v JSC BTA Bank
• Município De Mariana (and the Claimants identified in the Schedules to the Claim Forms) v BHP Group Plc (formerly BHP Billiton Plc)
• Koza Ltd v Koza Altin Isletmeleri as
• Warner-Lambert Company LLC v Generics (UK) Ltd (trading as Mylan) and Others
• Your Lawyers Ltd v Capital Interchange Ltd
• Resolution Chemicals Ltd (Respondent/Claimant) v H. Lundbeck A/s
• PSV 1982 Ltd v Sean Anthony Edward Langdon
• Starlight Shipping Company v Allianz Marine & Aviation Versicherungs AG
• Mr Nopporn Suppipat v Mr Nop Narongdej
• Mad Atelier International B.v v. Mr Axel Manes
• Grosvenor Chemicals v UPL Europe
• Tyne & Wear Passenger Transport v National Union of Rail
• Peter Orji v Sukhdip Nagra
• Verica Tomanovic v The Foreign and Commonwealth Office
• Koza Ltd v Koza Altin Isletmeleri as
• Município de Mariana v BHP Group Plc (formerly BHP Billiton Plc)

CONSIDERED in

• Iain Paul Barker v Paul Baxendale-Walker
• Pixdene Ltd v Paddington and Company Ltd
• Walbrook Turstees Ltd v William Fattal

[See more]

• Kent County Council v Josie Lawrence (Respondent/Claimant)
• Appleby v Northern Devon Healthcare NHS Trust
• Otkritie Capital International Ltd and Another v Threadneedle Asset Management Ltd and Another
• Mashood Iqbal v (1) Muzaffar Ahmad Mansoor (First Defendant) (2) Ejaz Baig (Second Defendant) (3) Mubashra Nida Mansoor (Third Defendant) (4) Pedro Louro (Fourth Defendant) (5) Catijah Bibi Cooraban (Fifth Defendant) (6) Dean Manson Solicitors (Sixth Defendant)
• Tarik Solak v Kheirs Financial Services Pty Ltd (ACN 100 505 324), Gamel Kheir and Bank of Western Australia Ltd (ACN 050 494 454)
• St Vincent European General Partner Ltd v Bruce Robinson (and Others)
• Walbrook Trustees (Jersey) Ltd & Others v William Simon Fattal & Others
• C G Maloney Pty Ltd v Noon
• Sayed S. Sangamneheri v The Chartered Institute of Arbitrators
• Irina Idjatulina v Finishing Touches (SPMU) Ltd
• Harris for and on behalf of the estate of Harris and Harris v Rapisarda
• The Royal Bank of Scotland Plc v Highland Financial Partners LP and Others
• Mary Kathryn Leslie (in her personal capacity and as a trustee of the Mary Lawrence Childrens Settlement) v Robert James Ball
• Oleg Vladimirovich Deripaska v Michael Cherney
• Phaestos Ltd and Another v Peter Ho
• Land Securities Plc & Others v Fladgate Fielder ( A Firm)
• Sharon Lesley Walsh v Redmayne-Bentley LLP
• Test Claimants in the Act Group Litigation (Classes 2 and 4) v HM Revenue and Customs
• David John Frosdick v The Official Receiver
• BA (Claimants and Respondents in the appeal) BB and Others The Secretary of State for the Home Department (Defendant and Appellant in the appeal) Bail for Immigration Detainees (Intervener)
• Nataliya Golubovich v Alexey Golubovich
• Mr Desmond Schweppe v (1) Mr Ian Closier (First Defendant) (2) Mr John Horsman (Second Defendant)
• AP Racing v Alcon Components
• Mardas v New York Times Company and Another
• Cullen v Glencullen Holdings Ltd ((in Receivership))
• Burden and Others v Esr Group (NZ) Ltd and Others
• Taylor Goodchild Ltd v Scott Taylor
• William Andrew Tinkler v Esken Ltd (formerly Stobart Group Ltd)
• Cydlia Zara Adler v Cripps Trust Corporation Ltd (in its capacity as Administrator of the estate of Alexander Klein deceased)
• Jonathan Mark Broomhead v National Westminster Bank Plc
• Pricewaterhousecoopers LLP v BTI 2014 LLC
• Popinder Kaur Dhillon (Acting by Her Litigation Friend) v Yaw Asiedu
• Otkritie Capital International Ltd and Another (Respondents/Appellants) v Threadneedle Asset Management Ltd and Another
• Mark Damian Clarkson v Future Resources FZE
• Outotec (USA) Inc. v MW High Tech Projects UK Ltd
• SLF Associates Inc. (a company registered in the Seychelles) v HSBC (UK) Bank Plc
• LIC Telecommunications Sarl v VTB Capital Plc
• The Libyan Investment Authority v JP Morgan Chase & Company
• General Medical Council v Ijaz Hayat
• Harrison and Another v Black Horse Ltd
• Daewoo Shipbuilding and Marine Engineering Company Ltd v Songa Offshore Equinox Ltd
• William Andrew Tinkler v Iain George Ferguson
• Peter Richard Andreewitch (A.K.A. Richard Andreewitch) v Magali Moutreuil
• Briefline Assets Ltd v Nikolay Anatolyevich Falin
• Camerata Property Inc. v Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) Ltd
• Joseph Donovan v Prescott Place Freeholder Ltd & Others
• Tempo Group Ltd Chen Ching Chih Maxima Resources Corporation Plaintiffs/Respondents v Fortuna Development Corporation New Frontier Development Corporation Wynner Group Ltd Defendants/Appellants
• Torchlight GP Ltd v (1) Millinium Asset Services Pty Ltd
• Jardine Strategic Holdings Ltd
• Merkanti Holding P.L.C v Raiffeisen Bank International AG
• Between: Merkanti Holding P.L.C (formerly MFC Holding Ltd, a company incorporated in Malta) First Appellant/Third Defendant 1128349 B.C. Ltd (a company incorporated in British Columbia, Canada) Second Appellant/Sixth Defendant v Raiffeisen Bank International AG (a body incorporated under the laws of Austria) Respondent/Plaintiff
• Jepter Lorde v Sagicor Financial Corporation Ltd
• Investec Trust (Guernsey) Ltd v Glenalla Properties Ltd
• Mexico Infrastructure Finance LLC v Corporation of Hamilton
• Torchlight GP Ltd v Millinium Asset Services Pty Ltd
• Mr Stephen Mark v Universal Coatings & Services Ltd
• Kotonou v National Westminster Bank Plc
• WWRT Ltd v Carosan Trading Ltd
• Khubchand Thanwerdas Karnani (Acting herein by his duly constituted Attorney on record Kishor Kubchand Karnani) v Allied (Investments) Ltd
• Vaqar Malik v Iftikhar Ahmad Malik
• Pickthall v Hill Dickinson LLP
• Iftikhar Malik v Vaqar Malik
• Josie Lawrence v Kent County Council
• Ismail Kamoka and Others v The Security Service and Others
• Churchil Ltd v The Open College Network South Eastern Region Ltd (Trading as Laser Learning Awards)
• Deena Mohamed v Sandra Persad
• PSV 1982 Ltd v Sean Anthony Edward Langdon
• Briefline Assets Ltd v Nikolay Anatolyevich Falin
• Stuart v Goldberg Linde
• Genevieve Bute v R.L. Seale & Company Ltd
• Cynthia Ramoutar v David Ramkhellawan
• Champerslife Pty Ltd v Manojlovski and Another
• BCLI v Commissioner of the Police for the Metropolis
• William Andrew Tinkler v Iain George Thomas Ferguson
• Labrouche v Frey and Others
• Aktas v Adepta
• Robert John McKendrick v The Financial Conduct Authority
• JMW Solicitors LLP v Injury Lawyers 4U Ltd
• WWRT Ltd v [1] Carosan Trading Ltd, [2] Boris Kaufman
• Papiss Demba Cisse v Sandra Diene
• Briefline Assets Ltd v Nikolay Anatolyevich Falin
• Sethia London Ltd v Mr Ajay Sethi

DISTINGUISHED in

• Football Dataco Ltd and Others v Stan James (Abingdon) Ltd and Others

CITED in

• Harrison and Another v Black Horse Ltd
• Building Register Ltd v Mark Weston and Another
• Chamonix Private Equity Llp v Caledonia Investments Plc

[See more]

• Dickinson and Another v UK Acorn Finance Ltd
• Royal Bank of Scotland Plc v Highland Financial Partners LP [QBD (Comm)]
• Agbenowossi-Koffi v Donvand Ltd (t/a Gullivers Travel Associates)
• Dunkley v Dunkley and another
• Deansgate 123 LLP v Ian Garth Workman
• Musst Holdings Ltd v Astra Asset Management UK Ltd
• Amtrust Europe Ltd v Trust Risk Group S.p.A.
• Brian Thomas Taylor v John Robinson
• Simer Kaur Dhillon v Barclays Bank Plc
• Robert John McKendrick v The Financial Conduct Authority
• Lemas and Another v Williams
• Rizwan Hussain v Gulraj Vaswani
• Bloomsbury Law Solicitors (Formerly Ahmud & Company Solicitors) v Howard MacPherson
• Gladman Commercial Properties v 1.) Fisher Hargreaves Proctor and Others
• Mark Damian Clarkson v Future Resources FZE
• Anthony King v Kings Solutions Group Ltd
• Damian Warburton v The Chief Constable of Avon and Somerset Constabulary
• Patricia Jane Griffin v David Howard Higgs
• Seele Austria GmbH & Company v Tokio Marine Europe Insurance Ltd
• Winston Finzi v Jamaican Redevelopment Foundation Inc. and Others
• Bilta (UK) Ltd ((in Liquidation)) & Others v Tradition Financial Services Ltd
• John Alexander Melvin Hemming v Sonia Vanessa Poulton
• Navigator Equities Ltd v Oleg Vladimirovich Deripaska
• Serious Organised Crime Agency v Agidi
• Liverpool Victoria Insurance Company Ltd v Dr Asef Zafar
• ADM International SARL v Grain House International S.A. (Formerly known as Compagnie Agricole De Commercialisation Et De Conditionnement Des Cereales Et De Legumeineuses S.A.)

FOLLOWED in

• AP Racing Ltd v Alcon Components Ltd
• David Barnett and Others (Claimants/Appellants) v Nigel Hall Menswear Ltd

REPORTED OPINION OF in

• [2008] 1 WLR 748
• [2008] 1 WLR 748
• [2008] CILL 2549

[See more]

• [2008] 115 Con LR 49
• [2008] Build LR 1
• [2008] PNLR 14

RELIED UPON in

• Mansing Moorjani v Durban Estates Ltd

APPLIED in

• Prince Marwaha v Entertainment One Ltd
• The Joint Administrators of Lehman Brothers Holdings Plc ((in Administration)) v LB GP No.1 Ltd ((in Liquidation))
• Amanda Stephanie Clutterbuck and Another (Claimants/Appellants) v William Cleghorn (as judicial factor to the estate of Elliot Nichol deceased)

[See more]

• Prescott Place Freeholder Ltd v Constantin Batin

This document cites

---

• Johnson v Gore Wood & Company (A Firm)
• Canada Trust Company v Stolzenberg (No 2)
• Lord Browne of Madingley v Associated Newspapers Ltd
• Dexter Ltd v Vlieland-Boddy
• Assiscurazioni Generali SpA v Arab Insurance Group



See all quotations

• Johnson v Gore Wood & Company (A Firm)
• Mersey Care NHS Trust v Ackroyd (No.2)
• Henderson v Henderson. [HIGH COURT of CHANCERY]
• Hunter and Others v Chief Constable of West Midlands
• Gleeson v J. Wippell & Company Ltd
• Toth v Ledger
• Aldi Stores Ltd v (1) Wsp Group Plc (2) Wsp London Ltd (3) Aspinwall & Company Ltd
• Thomas and Another v Baptiste and Others