73 A. 80 (N.J.Eq. 1909), McCarter v. Firemen's Insurance Company

Citation: 73 A. 80, 74 N.J.Eq. 372

Opinion Judge: GARRISON, J.

Party Name: ROBERT H. McCARTER, attorney-general, appellant, v. FIREMEN'S INSURANCE COMPANY et al., respondents

Attorney: Mr. Robert H. McCarter, attorney-general, and Mr. Malcolm MacLear, for the appellant. Mr. Bennet Van Syckel and Mr. Richard V. Lindabury, for the respondents.

Judge Panel: SWAYZE, J. (dissenting). For affirmance--THE CHIEF-JUSTICE, SWAYZE, REED, BERGEN. For reversal--THE CHANCELLOR, GARRISON, TRENCHARD, BOGERT, VREDENBURGH, VROOM, DILL. For affirmance--THE CHIEF-JUSTICE, SWAYZE, REED, BERGEN--4. For reversal--THE CHANCELLOR, GARRISON, TRENCHARD, BOGERT, VREDENBURGH...

Case Date: Monday June 14, 1909

Court: New Jersey Supreme Court