71 A. 253 (N.J.L. 1908), Carter v. West Jersey and Seashore Railroad Company

Citation: 71 A. 253, 76 N.J.L. 602

Opinion Judge: PITNEY, CHANCELLOR.

Party Name: WILLIAM D. CARTER, ADMINISTRATOR, &c., OF IDA M. CARTER, DECEASED, DEFENDANT IN ERROR, v. WEST JERSEY AND SEASHORE RAILROAD COMPANY, PLAINTIFF IN ERROR

Attorney: For the plaintiff in error, Gaskill & Gaskill. For the defendant in error, Lewis Starr and Allen S. Morgan, with whom was James Gay Gordon (of the Philadelphia bar).

Judge Panel: GARRISON GARRISON, J. (dissenting). For affirmance -- THE CHANCELLOR, CHIEF JUSTICE, SWAYZE, TRENCHARD, PARKER, BERGEN, MINTURN, BOGERT, VREDENBURGH, VROOM, GREEN, GRAY, DILL, J.J. 13. For reversal -- GARRISON, REED, VOORHEES, J.J. 3.

Case Date: November 16, 1908

Court: New Jersey Supreme Court