158 N.Y. 175, People ex rel. Fleming v. Dalton

Citation: 158 N.Y. 175

Opinion Judge: BARTLETT, J.

Party Name: PEOPLE ex rel. FLEMING v. DALTON, Commissioner of Water Supply, et al.

Attorney: Samuel H. Ordway, for appellant. Theodore Connoly and William J. Carr, for respondents.

Judge Panel: Gray and O'Brien, JJ., dissenting. GRAY, J. (dissenting). O'BRIEN, J., concurs. All concur (PARKER, C. J., in result) with BARTLETT, J., for reversal, except GRAY and O'BRIEN, JJ., who file dissenting memorandum. Order reversed, etc.

Case Date: February 28, 1899

Court: New York Court of Appeals Court of Appeals