115 N.W. 429 (Mich. 1908), Carton v. Secretary of State

Citation: 115 N.W. 429, 151 Mich. 337

Opinion Judge: GRANT, C.J. [151 Mich. 358] BLAIR, J. OSTRANDER, J. [151 Mich. 348] CARPENTER, J. [151 Mich. 371] HOOKER, J. MONTGOMERY, J.

Party Name: CARTON, President of Constitutional Convention, v. SECRETARY OF STATE.

Attorney: [151 Mich. 338] Henry M. Campbell, Victor M. Gore, Frank S. Pratt, Andrew L. Moore, and Roger I. Wykes, for relator. John E. Bird, Atty. Gen. (Henry E. Chase and Thomas Ambrose Lawler, of counsel), for respondent.

Judge Panel: MOORE, J., concurred with CARPENTER, J. It has been suggested that none of these should apply to section 2, because of the language, 'and the same,' used in section 1, which is thought to restrict its application to amendments proposed by the Legislature, and although section 2 is silent it is sa...

Case Date: March 09, 1908

Court: Michigan Supreme Court