102 A. 637 (N.J.L. 1917), 28, Kimble v. Mayor and Common Council of City of Newark

Citation: 102 A. 637, 91 N.J.L. 249

Opinion Judge: BERGEN, J.

Party Name: MINNIE B. KIMBLE, RESPONDENT, v. THE MAYOR AND COMMON COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NEWARK, APPELLANT

Attorney: For the appellants, Harry Kalisch and Joseph G. Wolberg. For the respondents, F. Hamilton Reeve and J. Frank McDavitt.

Judge Panel: For affirmance -- THE CHANCELLOR, GARRISON, TRENCHARD, PARKER, BERGEN, MINTURN, BLACK, HEPPENHEIMER, WILLIAMS, JJ. 9. For reversal -- THE CHIEF JUSTICE, SWAYZE, KALISCH, WHITE, JJ. 4. SWAYZE SWAYZE, J. (dissenting).

Case Date: Monday November 19, 1917

Court: New Jersey Supreme Court